Best Simmons Beautyrest Alternatives

By Rachael Harris

Feb 15th, 2022

If you’re in the market for a new mattress, and are deciding between investing in a Beautyrest or opting for an alternative, this comparison will help you with your search. We’ve matched several Beautyrest models with other brands that offer different prices or features.

This list includes beds for all sleep positions and styles. Back sleepers and stomach sleepers should take note of hybrids or models that offer firm mattress options. Additionally, all of these beds can be ordered from the ease of your home, rather than venturing out to a mattress store.

Best Beautyrest Mattress Alternatives

Beautyrest Mattress Best Alternative Option
Beautyrest Black GhostBed Luxe
Beautyrest Black Hybrid Saatva
Beautyrest Harmony Brooklyn Bedding Plank
Beautyrest Harmony Lux Hybrid WinkBeds EcoCloud
Beautyrest Harmony Lux Carbon Helix Dawn Luxe
Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond Puffy Lux Hybrid

Beautyrest Black vs. GhostBed Luxe

Feel

The Beautyrest Black and GhostBed Luxe both excel at keeping you cool and providing  a superb spinal support system. The two have different constructions which make for slightly different feels.

The Beautyrest Black is an innerspring mattress series with 3 classes—L, C, and K class—each with firmness options ranging from plush to extra firm. It sleeps cool and champions spinal alignment with a perfect 10/10 score during our evaluation. It also scored 9.5/10 on pressure relief and 9/10 on motion transfer. The combination of foam and coils adjust to your body’s unique shape and movement, which sets the stage for muscle relief and undisturbed sleep.

The GhostBed Luxe is an all-foam mattress that is very slightly firmer than the Black, though it’s still considered medium-firm. 7-layers of foam incorporate various cooling technologies that garnered a 9/10 score in cooling on our evaluation. The Luxe also scored 9.25 in responsiveness and spinal alignment. It doesn’t offer quite as much pressure relief as the Black, but it’s great for combination sleepers who need a bed to adapt to their changing positions.

Special Features

The standout features for these beds center on cooling. The Beautyrest Black touts their unique BlackICE 4.0 system. They don’t go into detail about what that entails, but they assure prospective buyers that it delivers on its promise. Additionally, you can opt for a cooling upgrade at extra cost. This upgrade adds Beautyrest’s RightTemp Memory Foam, which utilizes highly conductive carbon fiber to further disperses heat in the mattress.

The Black’s BeautyEdge prevents sleepers from rolling off the bed, which is important for couples on a queen size or anyone who sleeps near the edge of their bed. T3 Pocketed Coil Technology creates a supportive bounciness that contributes to this bed’s exceptional spinal support. Lastly, you can add a comfort upgrade of GelTouch Foam, which further cushions joints and enhances cooling.

The GhostBed Luxe uses its own “ice” design in surface and foam cooling. Ghost Ice Fabric cover is cool-on-contact and works in three phases. The first is 1 inch of airflow technology fiber, followed by 1 inch of gel memory foam. Next is a Ghost Ice Layer, a patent pending technology that cools in response to your body’s heat. Finally, gel and latex-like support layers ensure you wake feeling rested and ache-free.

Cost

Neither the Beautyrest Black nor the GhostBed Luxe are budget mattresses; however, the Luxe is cheaper than the Black. The Luxe also comes with all it’s cooling and comfort features, while the Black offers upgrades at extra cost. It’s worth noting that Beautyrest offers free white glove delivery with their mattress purchases.

Trial Period and Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period.
  • 10-year warranty.

GhostBed:

  • 101-night trial period (30 days minimum).
  • 25-year limited warranty.

Beautyrest Black Hybrid vs. Saatva

Feel

The Beautyrest Black Hybrid line is quite diverse, and includes medium, plush and ultra-plush options. Like most of their collections, the hybrid line runs cool due to proprietary technologies and a breathable coil system.

Saatva’s hybrid mattress is also available in multiple firmness levels. Buyers can choose from plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. The coil system provides excellent support. In fact, this bed scored a perfect 10/10 on spinal alignment in our lab evaluation. Mattress Advisor also included the Saatva Hybrid on our list of top-rated beds for side sleepers. The cushy euro pillow top certainly helps create an airy, luxury feel.

Special Features

Each of the Beautyrest Hybrid mattress models feature specialized materials. The simplest version, the X-Class Medium, comes in at $2,599, and includes 2 inches of gel memory foam as well as the T3 Pocketed Coil Technology. There’s also the X-Class Plush for $200 more, with 4 inches of memory foam and the pocketed coil, and the X-Class Ultra Plush for $800 more, with memory foam, latex, as well as the T3 Pocketed Coil.

The Saatva Hybrid features targeted Lumbar Zone wire and memory foam sandwiched between 2 layers of responsive coils. The upper layer of densely packed, innerspring coils quickly conforms to your body’s movements and the lower layer of durable, steel coils prolongs mattress life and prevents sagging. A frame of thick foam provides edge support and a euro pillow top adds luxurious comfort.

Cost

The Saatva Classic runs considerably less, at $1,695 for a queen size mattress. Both brands offer complimentary White Glove Delivery.

Trial Period and Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period
  • 10-year warranty

Saatva: 

  • 180-night trial period
  • 15-year warranty

Beautyrest Harmony vs. Brooklyn Bedding Plank

Feel

The Beautyrest Harmony and Brooklyn Bedding Plank are firm mattresses designed to evenly distribute weight and keep your spine in alignment. With a dual-design, the Plank allows sleepers to choose between a firm and extra firm side. The Harmony is extra firm for those that already know they are on Team Firmness.

While both mattresses incorporate foam in their design, the Harmony also uses a T1 Pocketed Coil Technology, making it a hybrid mattress. These coils create a targeted support system for where the body needs relief the most. Both mattresses offer excellent pressure relief, which is good for those with back pain. They also keep their shape and isolate motion, making them a great option for couples.

Special Features

The Harmony and Plank both come with cooling and comfort technologies to enhance their design. Brooklyn Bedding designed the Plank with a minimalist approach, starting with a quilted top consisting of a Titanflex comfort and high-density foam to promote a flatter sleep. For those who tend to sleep hot, they can choose to add an optional cooling panel to both sides. This panel uses a premium phase change molecule fabric to create a cool on contact feel.

The Harmony comes with charcoal-infused memory foam and TENCEL fabric to provide natural cooling. It also uses NaturalCool and AirCool Foam to circulate airflow. Like the Plank, sleepers can upgrade their mattress by adding the Emerald Bay cool-to-touch technology. This soft gel foam adds breathability to help eliminate night sweats. The Harmony also offers a comfort upgrade that adds an indulgent pillow top to your mattress.

Beautyrest also partners with SEAQUAL Initiative, a community focused on cleaning the oceans and raising awareness of marine issues. They offer sustainable fabric technologies for all Harmony mattresses. So when you buy a Harmony mattress you can help promote cleaner oceans.

Cost

The Beautyrest Harmony and Brooklyn Bedding Plank have similar price ranges, with the Harmony costing slightly more for the smaller sizes and less for the larger sizes.

Trial Period & Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Brooklyn Bedding:

  • 120-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Hybrid vs. WinkBeds EcoCloud

Feel

The Beautyrest Harmony Lux Hybrid and WinkBeds EcoCloud are both sustainable hybrid mattresses. Made with 100% natural Talalay latex, the EcoCloud is extra bouncy and good for the environment. The Harmony Lux Hybrid uses unique sustainable fabric technologies created by Seaqual, a leader in ocean plastic recovery and upcycling activities.

The Harmony Lux Hybrid is a good option for those that want extra back support. Both use special support systems to provide targeted pressure relief for where your body needs it most. They also have excellent responsiveness so you can change positions and move around easily.

Special Features

WinkBeds offers cooling and comfort technologies with their mattresses. Those purchasing the Harmony Lux Hybrid can select the Trilliant Cooling upgrade for a responsive, enhanced cooling experience. For an added plush, buyers can also choose additional comfort layers.

The Harmony Lux Hybrid comes with WinkBeds’ proprietary ContourFit Design Construction, which provides a more responsive sleep. It also ensures a more consistent top panel comfort so you can get the same good night’s sleep every night.

WinkBeds designed the EcoCloud with an Extra-Edge support system to prevent sagging from occurring. This proprietary innerspring support system creates a firmer barrier along the edges to allow individuals to sleep on the edge without getting that dreaded sinking feeling.

Cost

Both the Harmony Lux Hybrid and EcoCloud have similar prices for their starting sizes, but as the mattresses get bigger, the EcoCloud becomes more expensive. It’s worth considering the EcoCloud comes with a lifetime warranty and the Harmony Lux Hybrid has some additional fees for cooling and comfort upgrades.

Trial Period & Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

WinkBeds:

  • 120-night trial period. Free returns.
  • Lifetime warranty.

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Carbon vs. Helix Dawn Luxe

Feel

The Beautyrest Harmony Lux Carbon and Helix Dawn Luxe are both hybrid mattresses that use layers of foam and innerspring systems to create the perfect balance. On the firmness scale, the Helix Dawn Luxe is closer to the firm end. Beautyrest offers its Harmony Lux Carbon mattress in a plush, medium, and extra firm option, making it totally customizable to your needs.

When it comes to edge support, the Harmony Lux Carbon earned a perfect 10/10 in Mattress Advisor testing. This means that if you tend to sleep close to the mattress’s edge, you’ll notice hardly any sagging. Both mattresses excel in spinal alignment and motion transfer.

Special Features

As a Helix Luxe mattress, the Dawn comes with zoned lumbar support coils and a premium quilted pillow top. The zoning technology provides a firmer surface under your hips and softer cushion around your shoulders. Buyers can choose between a GlacioTex Cooling Cover or TENCEL Cover. The GlacioTex Cooling Cover uses fibers with high thermal conductivity to pull heat away from your body, while the moisture-wicking TENCEL Cover improves airflow.

The Harmony Lux Carbon also keeps cool at night thanks to its RightTemp Wave Foam. This new patented foam features strong, highly conductive carbon that delivers a consistent cooling feeling. Beautyrest also offers a pillow top upgrade option for those that want extra plush.

Another added bonus of the Harmony Lux Carbon is that it’s made from recovered plastic from the ocean. Beautyrest partners with Seaqual, an initiative focused on cleaning the oceans, to incorporate sustainable fabric into their durable designs.

Cost

The Helix Dawn Luxe can cost more, depending on the features selected. The Harmony Lux Carbon comes with a free white glove delivery to have a professional set up your new mattress and remove your old one.

Trial Period & Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Helix:

  • 100-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 15-year limited warranty.

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond vs Puffy Lux Hybrid

Feel

The Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond has four firmness options ranging from soft (3/10 on the mattress firmness scale) to medium (5/10) while the Puffy Lux Hybrid is available in a medium-firm (6/10) only. Each hybrid combines layers of foam and innersprings, with the innerspring layers providing more bounce than a typical all-foam mattress.

The Harmony Lux Diamond should accommodate side sleepers, back sleepers, and combination sleepers, but stomach sleepers are likely to find it too soft. The Puffy Lux Hybrid’s Mattress Advisor score for pressure relief (7/10) doesn’t match up very well with the side sleeping position, and it might not be responsive enough for combination sleepers or restless sleepers.

Special Features

When it comes to cooling, the presence of innerspring layers gives each mattress a head start against all-foam feds. Additionally, both the Harmony Lux Diamond and Puffy Lux Hybrid use gel-infused foam to reduce heat buildup. The Puffy features a Cooling Cloud Foam Layer and a layer of Climate Comfort Memory Foam. The Harmony Lux Diamond’s design includes layers of Gel Touch Foam, RightTemp Wave Foam, and Micro Diamond Memory Foam.

Four versions are available with the Harmony Lux Diamond: the Classic Top with Medium or Plush firmness and the Pillow Top with Medium or Ultra-Plush firmness. The softer options include additional layers, which means you could get a mattress weighing more than 200 pounds. Although Beautyrest has free white-glove delivery and set-up service, the much lighter Puffy Lux Hybrid (106 pounds in California king size) would be easier to move from room to room.

Despite being the lighter mattress, the Puffy Lux Hybrid has a higher weight capacity than the Harmony Lux Diamond. The Puffy mattress can support up to 700 pounds (or two 350-pound people on a queen-size or larger) while the Harmony Lux Diamond is recommended for people weighing 230 pounds or less.

Cost

The mattresses are pretty close in terms of prices. A queen-size Puffy Lux Hybrid costs about $2,250, and a queen-size Harmony Diamond Lux Classic Top with Medium Firmness is $1,999.

Trial Period and Warranty

Beautyrest:

  • 100-night trial period.
  • 10-year warranty.

Puffy:

  • 101-night trial period.
  • Lifetime warranty.

Beautyrest Mattresses vs Alternative Mattresses

Beautyrest has a 100+ year reputation for high quality mattresses, so why consider alternatives? An obvious reason is savings. Beautyrest crafts a durable, technologically advanced bed, but high-quality alternatives are available at a more accessible price point.

Related: Tempur-Pedic Alternatives

Some customers may also prefer the expedited shipping and set-up experience of bed-in-a-box brands. Compressed and rolled mattresses initially fit much better in tight spaces, including doorways and stairwells.

Finally, many customers rest more soundly knowing their bed is covered under warranty for any surprise cracks or impressions from normal wear. Beautyrest only covers manufacturer defects under their warranty. Additionally, Beautyrest only offers a 100-night sleep trial, while other brands offer anywhere from 120-nights to a full year.

Beautyrest is undoubtedly worthy of its long-standing, world-class presence in the mattress market. Still, today’s consumers have many Beautyrest mattress alternatives with outstanding performance, pricing, and customer service policies of their own.