Beautyrest vs Sealy Mattress Comparison

Sealy and Simmons Beautyrest are household names. Both Simmons and Sealy started in the 1800s in the United States, and they still manufacture their mattresses in the USA. They’re two brands that you’ll often see when shopping at a local retailer, but now you can purchase their mattresses from the comfort of your living room. 

In this review, we’re going to compare the Sealy Hybrid line with Beautyrest’s most popular mattresses. We’ll help you understand the differences between the companies and their mattresses so you can find the best bed for your needs.  

Comparison At a Glance

Key Similarities

• Hybrid Design: Every Beautyrest mattress is a hybrid bed made from layers of pocketed coils, memory foam, and polyfoam. The Sealy Hybrid line of mattresses is made from these same materials. 
• Multiple Firmnesses: Both companies offer multiple firmnesses with some of their beds. This allows shoppers to choose the right feel for their sleeping position and personal preferences. 
• Warranty: Both mattress brands offer a 10-year warranty. This is the industry-standard warranty period. 

Key Differences

• Price: Beautyrest is a luxury mattress brand with average pricing that’s higher than Sealy’s hybrid beds. 
• Thickness: While both brands manufacture mattresses that are thicker than the common 10” bed, Beautyrest mattresses are typically thicker than Sealy beds. These additional layers mean a more opulent feel. 
• Cooling: Beautyrest’s cooling upgrades make their mattresses better for hot sleepers than the Sealy mattresses. 
• Delivery: Beautyrest mattresses come with free white glove delivery, which means new mattress setup and old mattress removal. Sealy mattresses only come with free standard delivery, so you’ll have to set up your new bed.

Beautyrest Black Hybrid vs Sealy Hybrid Essentials

Compare Mattress Construction

The Simmons Beautyrest Black Hybrid is a high-quality mattress. With either 13.5” or 15” of foam and coils, depending on which model you choose, there’s enough cushion and responsive support for every body size. The Original has a medium feel, the Comfort Upgrade a medium-soft firmness, and the Comfort + Pressure Relief is a soft mattress. This mattress is best for people who find most beds too firm. 

The Sealy Hybrid Essentials mattress is their entry-line hybrid bed. It measures 12” thick, with sufficient support for most body types. The support system is made from pocketed coils, a design that gives at pressure points while supporting the body’s natural curves. There are just two top foam layers, with the comfort layer made from high-density gel-infused memory foam. The feel is one of firm support with a slightly bouncy, traditional innerspring mattress feel. 

When comparing these mattresses, the biggest difference is that the Sealy Hybrid Essentials is much firmer. A firmer mattress is typically better for stomach sleepers, while the softer feel of the Beautyrest Black Hybrid is well-suited for side sleepers. Back sleepers may enjoy either mattress, simply depending upon firmness preference. The thicker foam layers of the Beautyrest mattress make it better at isolating motion, better for couples. 

Black Hybrid Optional Features Come at a Price

The high-end Beautyrest Black Hybrid is roughly twice as expensive as the more affordable Sealy Hybrid Essentials mattress, depending upon which size and model you choose. 

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond vs Sealy Hybrid Performance

An Inside Look

The Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond mattress is a thick, lavish hybrid mattress. With 9.5” of supportive pocketed coils, there’s plenty of support for every body size. Above these coils are 5–6 foam layers with various cooling innovations. Compared to most mattresses that have three or fewer foam layers, the Lux Diamond is softer and feels more like sleeping on a cloud. It comes in medium, plush, and ultra-plush firmnesses. 

The Sealy Hybrid Performance is Sealy’s most affordable hybrid with their Posturepedic Technology. With Posturepedic, there are 20% more steel coils where you need them most—along the body’s heavy trunk. This added support stops the hips from sinking in too low. Above this support system are three layers of foam. The top layer of ComfortSense Gel Memory Foam brings both cushion and cooling. It comes in plush (medium-soft) or firm (medium-firm). 

We recommend the Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond mattress for side sleepers, lightweight people, and anyone else who wants an incredibly plush, luxurious feel. The Sealy Hybrid Performance is better for stomach sleepers, plus-size people, and people with back pain. This is thanks to the added support along the body’s core that comes with Sealy’s Posturepedic Technology. Both are high-quality mattresses that are durable and sleep cool. 

Sealy Hybrid Performance: More Affordable but Less Customizable 

The Sealy Hybrid Performance has a lower price point than the Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond. Only the Beautyrest mattress is available in twin size. 

Beautyrest Black vs Sealy Hybrid Premium

An Inside Look

The Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is their most extravagant mattress. It’s made from the most advanced foam and coil technologies that Simmons has to offer. Their T3 Pocketed Coils with BeautyEdge provide excellent support and contouring along the entire mattress surface. The multiple memory foam layers offer unbeatable pressure relief and cooling properties. Choose from the medium-firm Original and Cooling Upgrade, or the plush pillow top model.   

The Sealy Hybrid Performance is Sealy’s most luxurious hybrid mattress. At 14”–15” thick, this mattress boasts sufficient cushion and support for every body size. It has three upper foam layers, including Sealy’s luxurious Immersion Advanced Memory Foam for excellent pressure relief. Its supportive coils are zoned for great body contouring and support. It comes in three firmnesses that range from plush to firm, therefore working for every sleeping position. 

The Sealy Hybrid Performance’s zoned support makes it superior for bigger bodies. The Beautyrest Black contains even greater cooling innovations, wonderful for hot sleepers. Both mattresses are luxuriant and incredibly durable. 

Both Customizable; Both at Luxury Prices

These mattresses have comparable price points, although the most luxuriant Beautyrest Black model is more expensive than the Sealy Hybrid Premium mattress. 

Beautyrest Mattresses Are Slightly Thicker

Beautyrest and Sealy mattresses have similar dimensions. They’re both thicker than most mattresses. 

Learn more about mattress sizes.

Trial Period

Sealy and Simmons Beautyrest have nearly identical 100-night sleep trials with free returns. The only difference is that Sealy has a 30-day waiting period before they’ll accept a return, while Simmons does not. 

Warranty

Both brands back their mattresses with the mattress industry-standard 10-year limited warranty. These warranties cover defects that occur during this period. 

Which Brand Is Right for You?

Beautyrest offers the ultimate in luxury hybrid mattresses. Every one of their beds has thick foam layers that provide excellent motion isolation and pressure relief. Sealy’s Hybrid line is less expensive, with the Premium and Premier offering zoned support that’s great for heavy people, stomach sleepers, and back pain relief. 

Another difference that’s helpful when deciding which is the right brand is that Beautyrest mattresses are typically softer and more cloud-like than Sealy beds. For a firmer feel, go with Sealy. But if you’re after a plush experience, consider Beautyrest. 

Both mattress brands offer risk-free 100-night trials. This means you can try out any of the mattresses outlined in this review in your bedroom before making a final commitment.