Best Bed-in-a-Box Mattresses of 2020

By Loren Bullock

For years, mattress shopping meant driving to a warehouse or furniture store, lying on various models, and then shoving your new mattress in your vehicle to take home. Then, you and a team of people had to maneuver the mattress through doorways and up the stairs before you finally set it on your foundation.

Now, mattress companies are making it easier than ever to buy a bed; you have the option to order a mattress online. Instead of having the entire mattress laid out, it is compressed into a box and shipped to your front door—just that simple. In this guide, we’ve selected the top 10 bed-in-a-box mattresses for you to explore.

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Best Mattresses in a Box

We’ll take a deep dive into each bed and see what makes it great to help you choose the best mattress for you.


Nectar Mattress: Best for Back Pain

Nectar

Best for:

  • Budget shoppers
  • Side sleepers
  • People who need a mattress with good edge support

Got this because I was having lower back pain on my very old bed. Took about 2 nights for the back pain to go away.”

Kelly T.
Customer Rating
4.8 / 5
MA Score
8.7 / 10
Firmness

Medium firm: 5.5-6/10

Trial Period

365 days

Nectar is one of the most affordable memory foam mattresses that works well for all types of sleepers. So well, in fact, that only 3% of customers have ever returned their Nectar—that’s a 97% satisfaction rating.

The Nectar mattress is a memory foam bed that is surprisingly cool. This might have something to do with the cooling cover (that is also resistant to dust mites) and quilted gel foam top layer that provides air flow. The memory foam also provides great pressure relief for people with hip or back pain.

Nectar offers one of the most generous trial and warranty combinations in the bed-in-a-box industry: you get a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty. You read that right. You have a full year to try out the Nectar mattress, and if you decide to keep it, your warranty covers it forever.

Read our full Nectar mattress review.


Casper Mattress: Best for Side Sleepers

Casper

Best for:

  • Combination sleepers
  • People with back or shoulder pain
  • Sleepers who toss and turn

I can't thank Casper enough for a wonderful night's sleep, a happy morning, and a saved marriage.”

Susan
Customer Rating
4.5 / 5
MA Score
9.1 / 10
Firmness

Medium firm: 6/10

Trial Period

100 days

The Original Casper mattress is their most popular model in addition to being one of our favorite beds in a box, and it is easy to see why. The memory foam layers work together to create a mattress that is responsive, motion isolating, and pressure relieving, a good combination for side sleepers.

Casper is made of 4 layers of foam. The top layer is open-cell foam that gives the mattress breathability, allowing body heat to escape. The second comfort layer makes Casper responsive to restless sleepers as they shift positions throughout the night. Next we have our zoned support layer that contours to your body and offers pressure relief to sensitive areas. The bottom layer provides support and durability.

When you purchase a Casper mattress, you get a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty—the standard combination for most online mattress brands.

Read our full Casper mattress review.


Puffy Lux Mattress: Best for Hot Sleepers

Puffy Lux

Best for:

  • People who sleep with a partner
  • Side sleepers
  • Anyone with back pain

We are planning on buying another Puffy for our permanent home. This mattress is fantastic!”

Beth
Customer Rating
5 / 5
MA Score
9.3 / 10
Firmness

Medium-soft to medium: 5.5 - 7

Trial Period

101 days

The Puffy Lux is Puffy’s luxury mattress. It is great at a lot of things including reducing motion transfer, providing pressure relief, responding to your movements, and of course, keeping you cool. Puffy Lux landed its position as our best cooling mattress for hot sleepers with its ClimateComfort™ foam, cooling gel memory foam, and other breathable layers.

Puffy features other high-quality mattress materials that target eliminating pressure points. The ClimateComfort™ foam stays the same temperature all year long, no matter what season, so the pressure-relieving effects are not altered.

Each Puffy Lux purchase comes with a 101-night trial period and a lifetime warranty for as long as you own the mattress—a guarantee that you’ll love your Puffy bed.

Read our full Puffy Lux mattress review.


Layla Mattress: Best Firm Mattress

Layla

Best for:

  • Those with joint pain or arthritis
  • Anyone who shares a bed
  • People unsure of what firmness level they prefer

Great sleep, no more low back pain.”

Carol S.
Customer Rating
4.5 / 5
MA Score
8.8 / 10
Firmness

Soft side: 4-5/10; Firm side: 7/10

Trial Period

120 days

Layla is a dual-sided, flippable mattress. The difference between each side is firmness: there is a soft side and a firm side. The plush, soft side is a great choice for side sleepers or those who want their mattress to hug them. The firm side is a good option for back and stomach sleepers or people with back pain that prefer a firm feel.

Read More: Best Firm Mattresses

Both sides are made with copper-infused foam. The copper infusion is great for relieving joint inflammation and arthritis pain. Copper also helps to keep the surface of the mattress cool. 

If getting a 2-in-1 mattress isn’t cool enough, Layla comes with a 120-ight trial and a lifetime warranty, so you have 4 months to try out each side of Layla.

Read our full Layla mattress review.


Helix Mattress: Best Hybrid Mattress

Helix

Best for:

  • People who need a mattress customized to their preferences
  • Those who sleep hot
  • Side sleepers

This Bed changed my life! I sleep like a baby at night now and I have no more back pain.”

Janeth S.
Customer Rating
4.6 / 5
MA Score
8.9 / 10
Firmness

Customizable: Varies based on selection

Trial Period

100 days

Helix offers a unique shopping experience with their mattress quiz. After you take it, they will match you up to one of their 9 mattress models based on your specific sleep preferences—get a mattress tailored to you.

The Helix Midnight is their most popular model, and for good reason. It gives virtually no motion transfer, so couples and co-sleepers can move around without disturbing one another. It’s breathable foam allows Helix to sleep cool. On top of that, its responsiveness adjusts to your movements and works for all types of sleepers.

Read our full Helix mattress reviews.


Leesa Mattress: Best for Stomach Sleepers

Leesa

Best for:

  • Combination sleepers
  • Couples with back pain
  • People who sleep hot

I've never slept this good I've always been a stomach sleeper but now I can sleep comfortably on my back and stomach!”

Jenny
Customer Rating
4.8 / 5
MA Score
9.3 / 10
Firmness

Medium firm: 6/10

Trial Period

100 days

Leesa is one of the highest-rated mattresses we’ve ever tested in our Mattress Advisor lab. Using three foam layers, Leesa is cooling, responsive, motion isolating, and offers nearly perfect spinal alignment. Because Leesa is on the firmer side and does offer this alignment, it is a great mattress for stomach sleepers.

The top layer of foam is both cooling and responsive; the responsiveness keeps you on top of the bed, rather than sinking into the foam, something stomach sleepers need to keep their spines aligned. The middle layer allows for pressure relief on your hips and shoulders. 

Leesa offers a standard 100-night trial and 10-year warranty, but as a certified B corporation, they donate a mattress to those in need for every 10 sold.

Read our full Leesa mattress review.


Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress: Best Online

Brooklyn Signature

Best for:

  • All body types
  • Hot sleepers
  • People who want to choose their firmness level

My husband and I love this mattress. We wake up feeling refreshed and our sleep has improved dramatically.”

Ramona C.
Customer Rating
4.7 / 5
MA Score
9.1 / 10
Firmness

Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm

Trial Period

120 days

The Signature mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is a premium hybrid mattress that mixes gel foam and encased pocketed coils for a comfy mattress that pretty much works for everyone. That’s why we made it our top pick for the best mattress in a box.

The Brooklyn Signature mattress has 1,024 individually wrapped pocket coils for added support and responsiveness as well as an extra inch of base foam for a more durable mattress. When it comes to sleeping hot, the Signature’s top layer gel-infused foam to draw heat away from the body and give everyone a cool night’s sleep.

Read our full Brooklyn Signature mattress review.


Amerisleep AS3: Best Memory Foam Mattress

Amerisleep AS3

Best for:

  • Couples with different sleep positions
  • People with hip and back pain
  • Those who want a durable mattress

The mattress is firm yet soft and allows you to move around without disturbing your partner.”

Dan P.
Customer Rating
4.6 / 5
MA Score
8.4 / 10
Firmness

Medium: 6/10

Trial Period

100 days

Memory foam mattresses are exploding in the mattress market right now thanks to their reputation for being great for couples pressure relief, and durability. The AS3 by Amerisleep is no exception, making it on our list as the best memory foam mattress in a box.

The AS3 is wrapped in a celliant cover that increases blood flow and recovery for a good night’s sleep. The comfort layers are made with open-cell foam for cooling breathability, while the transition layer gives that contouring pressure point relief. Finally, the support foam is built to last up to 20 years without sagging or giving into impressions.

As you may have guessed with a name like Amerisleep, the AS3 mattress is made in the USA. This allows the company to cut out the middleman and keep costs low for customers; not only is the AS3 comfortable, it’s affordable as well.

Read our full AS3 mattress review.


Tuft & Needle Mattress: Best Budget Mattress

Tuft & Needle

Best for:

  • Value shoppers
  • All sleep positions
  • Those who are unsure of what they want in a mattress

So comfortable that it fixed my back pain. Great price too!”

Travis W.
Customer Rating
4.9 / 5
MA Score
8.7 / 10
Firmness

Medium-firm: 6-6.5/10

Trial Period

100 days

The Tuft & Needle mattress is a great option for most types of sleepers and it comes at a very wallet-friendly price. We recommend the Tuft & Needle mattress for anyone who needs a bed, but doesn’t want to break the bank to get one.

Read More: Best Cheap Mattresses for Your Budget

This mattress works well with any body type thanks to Tuft & Needle proprietary foam; the more pressure that is put on the bed, the more the bed reacts to the pressure and provides support. Being CertiPUR-US certified, this bed is also an eco-friendly option. The CertiPUR-US certification ensure that a mattress has been tested for durability, content, performance, and emissions, meaning minimal off-gassing effects.

Read our full Tuft & Needle mattress review.


Purple Mattress: Best for Heavy People

Purple

Best for:

  • Side sleepers with back pain
  • Back sleepers
  • People who sleep hot

I love my Purple mattress and my Purple Pillow! I am sleeping an hour longer a night and that is HUGE.”

Michael T.
Customer Rating
4.6 / 5
MA Score
8.4 / 10
Firmness

Medium firm-firm: 6.5/10

Trial Period

100 days

Purple is a unique online mattress brand, both in advertising and in construction. What makes Purple different is its hyper-elastic polymer mixed with high-density foam. The hyper-elastic polymer is made into their Smart Comfort Grid™, which is the key to relieving pressure from your most sensitive areas, making it one of the best mattresses for heavy people.

Plus-sized sleepers often have a difficult time with a mattress’s durability because their materials wear down quicker. The Smart Comfort Grid™ is resistant to weight as well as wear and tear—they literally backed over it with a semi truck in an advertisement, body weight won’t make a dent.

The medium-firm, high-density, polyfoam layers also add extra support and responsiveness to the mattress, making it a good choice for side and back combination sleepers.

Read our full Purple mattress review.


Buying Guide: Best Mattress in a Box

Buying an online mattress is unfamiliar territory for most people, but we’re here to help you navigate the space and find the bed-in-a-box of your dreams.

In this buying guide, we’ll go over the following:

What is a Mattress in a Box?

A bed-in-a-box mattress is simply a mattress that has been compressed and rolled into a box, so it can be easily shipped and placed at your front door. With your mattress in a box, you can pick up your package, carry it to your bedroom, and unroll it to full size.

The mind behind this genius concept is Bill Bradley. In 2007, he founded bedinabox.com where the first foam mattresses were compressed and put into a box. This didn’t really take off, however, until brands like Casper and Tuft & Needle jumped into the mix.

Nowadays, physical mattress retailers, such as Mattress Firm and Ashley Furniture, also carry boxed mattresses in their online stores to keep up with the competition. Everywhere you turn it seems like a new bed-in-a-box is popping up.

Benefits of Ordering a Mattress Online

You might be wondering what’s so great about bed-in-a-box mattresses. Well, it’s more than just keeping up with current technology.

Choices

Ordering a mattress online affords you the ability to check out hundreds of different options. Memory foam beds aren’t the only type that compress, you can find innerpring, latex, organic, and even hybrids! Some mattress info hubs even allow you to compare mattresses to see which one is right for you (cough couch Mattress Advisor).

You can also order pillows, a foundation, a box spring, a bed frame, and bedding along with your mattress in just a few clicks. Some brands are online only and others have pop-up stores or partner with retailers.

Convenience

Going to a mattress store and buying a mattress the traditional way can be cumbersome. Chances are, you can’t move a full mattress without some help. Not only do you have to bother your friends to accompany you to the store, but you are limited to the mattress models that store sells as well. If they don’t have what you’re looking for, you have to migrate to a new warehouse.

Ordering a bed-in-a-box allows you to just click your mouse a few times and wait. Very rarely do you need anyone else’s help to make this purchase or set it up.

Ease of Set Up

Having your mattress placed on your front porch boxed up gives you the ease of simply carrying it into your house. You don’t have to angle it a certain way to get it through the door, and you don’t need more than one person’s help (and this is only if the box is really heavy).

Though most boxed beds are intentionally lightweight, many bed-in-a-box companies give you the option of white glove delivery. This means that not only will the company deliver your mattress, but they will set it up for you and get rid of your old mattress. That is next to no work on your part.

Types of Mattresses

Boxed mattresses come in all mattress types. Let’s explore each material.

Memory Foam Mattress

Memory foam mattresses are constructed from multiple layers of foam with different densities. This mattress type is great for couples, people who wake up with aches and pains, and side sleepers. Memory foam mattresses aren’t great for hot sleepers because they tend to retain body heat.

Innerspring Mattress

Traditional innerspring mattresses are the beds that most of us grew up sleeping on. They have a core of coil springs padded on either side by cushioning foam. Innerspring mattresses are good for people who toss and turn and providing air flow to hot sleepers. They aren’t so great for couples and pain relief.

Innerspring beds with a pillow top are a good option for side sleepers specifically because they cushion the hips and shoulders while the coils keep you aligned.

Latex Mattress

Latex mattresses feature latex foam as their main layer. Latex foam can be either natural or synthetic, both offer pressure relief, are naturally cooling, and are responsive. A mattress that uses natural latex can combine with organic cotton or wool layers to make an organic mattress.

Hybrid Mattress

Hybrid mattresses combine different mattress materials to create a bed that uses the strength of each material. Memory foam mattresses are motion isolating; innerspring mattresses are responsive; latex mattresses are cooling and pressure relieving. A hybrid mattress will consist of 2-3 of these materials.

Best Online Mattresses by Sleeping Position

The best mattress for you mostly depends on your sleeping position.

Side Sleepers

People who sleep on their side need a mattress that can keep their spine perfectly straight and ease pressure from their hips and shoulders. Because of this memory foam and latex mattresses are the best choice for side sleepers. If you sleep hot, or you’re a side sleeper who also tosses and turns, latex is your best bet.

Back Sleepers

Back sleeping is considered the best sleeping position, but it isn’t the most popular. Those who sleep on their back need a mattress that can allow their spine to maintain its natural curve. Memory foam and innerspring mattresses are a good choice for back sleepers thanks to their contouring abilities.

Stomach Sleepers

The bad news? Stomach sleeping is considered the worst position for your health and alignment. The good news? Stomach sleepers need a firm mattress for their spine to stay aligned but with a soft top layer for their hips and shoulder to sink into, and that can be any type of mattress.

FAQs

How long do bed-in-a-box mattresses last?

Just as long as any other mattress! The mattress warranty will give you a good idea of how durable your new mattress is. If it is the standard 10-year warranty, expect it to last anywhere from 5-7 years. If the warranty is 25 years to a lifetime, your bed should last much longer before it begins to sag or have body impressions.

Can you return an online mattress?

Yes! The biggest concern shoppers may have when ordering a mattress online is that they might not like it once they get it. Bed-in-a-box companies have foreseen this and went on the offensive. These brands often have very generous trial periods etched into their return policy.

Trial periods allow you to see if you like the mattress before you commit to having it forever. On average, bed-in-a-box trial periods are 100 days—that is over three months of rest before you have to make a final decision.

If you decide you don’t like the mattress, you can ship it back for a full refund. Most brands also cover the cost of shipping.

Do you need a box spring for a bed-in-a-box mattress?

It depends on the mattress. Each bed has different needs for its foundation: some will need a box spring, some will not. The best way to know if your mattress needs a box spring or not is to check your warranty.

Read More: Do You Need a Box Spring?


Recap: Our Top Picks for the Best Mattresses in a Box

Mattress Superlative MA Score
Nectar Best for Back Pain 8.7/10
Casper Best for Side Sleepers 9.1/10
Puffy Lux Best for Hot Sleepers 9.3/10
Layla Best Firm Mattress 8.8/10
Helix Best Hybrid Mattress 8.9/10
Leesa Best for Stomach Sleepers 9.3/10
Brooklyn Signature Best Online Bed in a Box 9.1/10
Amerisleep AS3 Best Memory Foam Mattress 8.4/10
Tuft & Needle Best Budget Mattress 8.7/10
Purple Best for Heavy People 8.4/10

Summary

Bed-in-a-box mattresses are mattresses that are delivered to your front door in a box. Sometimes the brand will do an in-home setup and get rid of your old mattress as well. They are convenient, less bothersome, and take minimal work on your part.

If you want to compare bed-in-a-box mattresses, check out our mattress comparison chart.


Comments (0)


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *