Best Crib Mattress Pads

By Sheryl Grassie

May 14th, 2021

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Mattress protectors are insurance for a bed. Good mattresses, even for a crib, are expensive and a good protector is worth having. Easily washable, protective covers keep the crib fresh and extend mattress life. In general, mattress protectors are designed to act as a barrier between everything happening on the surface of the crib, like a leaky diaper or a drippy bottle, and the mattress itself. There are many types of protectors that come in a variety of materials; there are different options to fit different needs.

Our Picks for the Best Crib Mattress Pads

little ones mattress pad

Best For Travel

Little One’s Pad for Pack N Play Crib Mattress Cover

Add comfort and keep the mattress dry, this is the cover you need with your Pack N Play or other portable crib. It is a high quality four-layer pad that is soft and comfortable on the top, waterproof on the bottom, and highly absorbent in-between.

It keeps both baby and mattress dry. It is chemical free and long-lasting. Good for 100’s of washings, it is dryer safe and will not melt or crinkle. It has a lifetime guarantee for replacement or your money back. Add this to your child’s travel gear and be assured of a nice dry bed.

milliard mattress pad

Best Memory Foam

Milliard Memory Foam Topper Crib/Toddler Bed Mattress

Since crib mattresses tend to be on the firm side for safety, consider a mattress pad that is also an extremely comfortable 2-inch memory foam topper. It has a removable waterproof 65% cotton cover that is ventilated and washable.

Your baby or toddler will enjoy the comfort of this soft foam, but they must be able to turn over from a face-down position for it to be safe. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified, a designation that ensures it is free from flame retardants, mercury, lead, formaldehyde, and phthalates, to keep baby healthy. Looking for a mattress pad to keep baby dry? Consider adding comfort at the same time.

margaux and may mattress pad

Best Breathable Bamboo

Margaux & May Crib Mattress Protector Pad

You have the crib and mattress, and maybe even a topper too. What you need is a good quality mattress pad to complete the ensemble. This breathable cover, with an ultra-soft bamboo top layer, is vinyl, phthalate, BPA, and lead free to keep baby healthy while sleeping.

Unlike a topper, it has just a touch of padding and is long-lasting, with no shrinking or melting. It is also hypoallergenic and highly absorbent. Machine wash and dry, it comes with a lifetime guarantee for replacement or your money back. If you are looking for breathable bamboo for the crib, this is your pad.

american baby mattress pad

Best Basic

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Pad

Sometimes you just want a basic mattress pad without all the extras, one that does the job and performs reliably, or one that can be used as a back-up. This American Baby Company pad is made from 100% soft polyester on the top layer, an absorbent middle, and a waterproof bottom layer that will keep the mattress dry.

It fits snuggly with deep reinforced corners and elastic around the edge to hold it in place. Easy to remove for machine wash and dry, it is quiet and comfortable. Try this crib mattress pad when you need to keep the mattress dry and want a low cost, easy to clean, and long-lasting pad.

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress Pad For Your Needs

What Do You Want In A Mattress Pad? –  Do you have a really good mattress and just want protection for it? Do you have an extra-firm mattress that you would like to add some cushion to? Do you need an organic mattress pad or something chemical free? Do you want to protect against mold and allergies? A short list of your needs will help narrow down the kind of crib mattress pad that is right for you.

What Do You Want To Spend? – Determine a price range. Mattress pads are reasonably priced, but you may have an amount in mind. Decide on your budget to help narrow choices.

What Kind Of Fabric Do You Like? – A soft synthetic, an organic cotton terry, a breathable bamboo, or something else – decide what material you like and then choose from that type of fabric.

What Features Do You Need? – Deep pockets, a zippered closure, extra padding, memory foam? What are must-haves for your crib mattress pad?  

Related: Mattress pad vs topper


Mattress pads are an essential crib item. Leaky diapers, spit-up, or a drippy bottle, can all soak through and ruin the crib mattress. If you are in the market for a crib mattress pad, consider one of our “best” pads and insure a clean dry crib.