Best Crib Mattress Toppers

By Amanda Lasater

May 20th, 2022

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Once you have your perfect crib, the next step is buying a crib mattress topper that reaches that same level of excellence. We understand that this purchase is a very important decision. Apart from a sleep soother, this is the one source of comfort you can provide your baby while they sleep. The mattress topper you choose for your child will serve as the resting place for the most important developmental stages in their lives.

You’ll want to create a space that is not only cozy but also very safe, easy to clean, and ideal for your baby. When shopping for your baby’s mattress, make sure that your pick hits all of these marks. Continue reading to see what we’ve chosen as our top picks for the best crib mattress toppers and what to look for when shopping for your own.

Our Top Picks for the Best Crib Mattress Toppers


Best Budget


Milliard makes a Memory Foam Crib Mattress Topper that will fit your crib and your budget perfectly. This model is made up of two inches of 100-percent CertiPUR-US memory foam in a 52-inch by 27-inch size. 

This topper has a 2.5-pound density, which means it will provide ample support and can hold up for years to come. This option is unique in its ventilated design. Increased ventilation equals better breathability. Better breathability means that the mattress will stay clean and won’t retain odors. It also means regulated temperature, allowing for a more comfortable sleep for your baby. Fully wrapped in a waterproof cover, you can be sure that spills, stains, and allergens won’t be a concern. If you’re considering this option, keep in mind that this product is recommended for babies within the 12 to 36-month age range.


Best Luxury


When it comes to mattress toppers for your baby’s bed, The Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad by Newton is the best of the best. It’s comfortable and built to last. 

A GREENGUARD Gold certification ensures that it’s completely safe for your baby to use. It’s also waterproof and the perfect size for all cribs. Feel free to throw this entire topper in the wash – it is completely machine-washable. This topper is clearly great for many reasons; however, the best thing about this option is its Breathe-Thru technology. Newton managed to make a topper that is 100-percent breathable, greatly reducing the risk of suffocation. Breathability also eliminates odor retention and aids in temperature regulation.


Most Verstile


Your baby will be sitting and sleeping pretty on hiccapop’s Pack and Play Dual-Sided Mattress Pad. 

This pad stands out from the pack due to the options it provides. It is dual-sided, meaning that it’s essentially a two-in-one product. One side is firmer, which is ideal for babies. The other side is made of softer memory foam, which suits toddlers best. You won’t have to buy more products as your child graduates to new sleep situations. It is also multifunctional due to its size. Made in the size of 38-inches by 26-inches, it works great as a crib mattress, but can also fit snugly in all of the best playpens. Finishing off this topper is an incredibly cozy jacquard cover that’s also antibacterial and completely waterproof. With this dual-sided dream pad, you’ll be ready for any situation.


Also Great


RUUF’s Crib Mattress Topper will turn your baby’s crib into an uber-soft sleep zone. Made of gel-infused memory foam, this medium density pad will conform to your child’s body and cradle them to sleep. 

This option makes breathability a priority through its ventilated design. By allowing airflow, this product stays cleaner, regulates heat, and provides a safer sleep zone for your baby. This mattress topper comes dressed in a fully zippered cover that will stay secure instead of bunching up throughout the night. It is made of 100-percent terry cotton that is OEKO-TEX standard 100-certified. This cover provides a completely waterproof surface for your mattress topper, and can easily be removed and washed.

What To Look For In Your Next Crib Mattress Topper

We know that shopping for your baby requires a special level of care. With all the options out there, it can be overwhelming to decide which one is best. Luckily, we’ve made a list to help assist you in your search. Material, cover, density, and size will lead you to an option you feel great about.

Material: Material matters for a couple of reasons. You want your baby to be at their most comfortable when they sleep. Most importantly, you’ll need to make sure that your topper isn’t toxic. Some crib mattresses on the market actually contain hazardous chemicals, so be cautious with your choice. 

Cover: The cover of a crib mattress pad does a lot to protect both the mattress and your baby. Pick an option that contains a waterproof and hypoallergenic cover. 

Density: Baby mattresses vary in density, which can be a very important factor in your decision-making process. For infants, a firmer density is a must. Toddlers can enjoy a full spectrum and most likely prefer a softer landing. 

Size: Every other factor will go out the window if the topper you choose doesn’t fit snugly in your crib. Before you buy, make sure the measurements are right.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an organic crib mattress topper?

An organic crib mattress topper is a sleep surface for your baby’s crib that is completely made of naturally sourced materials that have been grown in a controlled setting. 

What labels should you avoid when shopping for a crib mattress topper?

Unfortunately, some crib mattress toppers are made with chemicals that can be potentially toxic. If you see polyurethane, polyethylene terephthalate, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), phthalates, volatile organic compounds or fire retardants anywhere on a label, it’s best to continue your search. 

What does CertiPUR-US mean? 

CertiPUR-US means that the product has been laboratory-tested to pass high standards in issues of emissions, content, performance, and durability. 


Buying the right crib mattress topper may be trickier than you initially thought. They have just as many (if not more) varying factors as your adult mattress, which doesn’t make for an easy choice. By reviewing our recommendations and tips, we hope that you’ve gotten closer to a decision you’re comfortable with.