Best Feather Mattress Toppers

By Amanda Lasater

Jun 10th, 2022

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Mattress toppers are a great solution for anyone who is dissatisfied with how their mattress feels or needs just a little more “oomph” to enhance the mattress’ natural comfort. Today, mattress toppers are made from a wide range of materials, however, there is one material that has been used for hundreds of years to make the most comfortable mattress toppers – feathers. And, while feather mattress toppers have been around for quite a while, they are still as popular as ever.    

Feather mattress toppers, also called featherbeds, are loved by many due to their exceptional softness and cloud-like feel. These toppers also sleep cool, so they can be perfect for people who sleep hot or suffer from night sweats. If you are interested in purchasing a feather mattress topper, we have cuddled up with the most popular toppers available today to bring you the best of the best and help you find your perfect featherbed.

The Best Feather Mattress Toppers


Best Natural Down for Allergies

Pacific Coast Feather Company

Sleeping on this down feather topper from Pacific Coast Feather Company was as close as I’ll ever get to sleeping on a cloud. 

The feathers used in this topper are Pacific Coast Feather Company’s own Hyperclean Resilia feathers which, unlike your typical down feathers, are allergen-free thanks to their rigorous cleaning process. In fact, this featherbed even comes with an allergy warranty – if you find that the topper is not allergen-free, you can return for a full refund. The baffle box design of this topper keeps the feathers in place and prevents clumping while still providing room for incredible comfort and a perfect loft. The fabric is a high quality, 230 thread count cotton made with a unique, tightly woven weave that is finished to keep the down and feathers from poking through. According to the Pacific Coast, their feather-proof Barrier Weave fabric is finer, softer, and more durable than the cotton used by competitors. 


  • Allergen-free guarantee
  • 30 night trial period
  • Baffle box construction


  • No loft measurements given

Best Budget


Lavish Home’s Bluestone Down & Duck Feather Topper is made using a combination of duck feathers as well as down feathers and offers a sleeping experience that is both warm and luxurious. 

The topper features a baffle box construction that stops any frustrating clumping and allows for an even distribution of feathers. It has a fill weight of 9 pounds and contains 95-percent duck feathers and 5-percent duck down feathers with a loft of approximately 4-inches. The feather fill is wrapped in a 100-percent cotton cover with a 233 thread count. 


  • 100-percent duck feathers
  • Stays fluffy


  • Strong odor that takes some airing out

Best Value


The PureDown goose down topper is a steal when you compare its competitive price tag with the quality of this featherbed. 

The nights spent sleeping on this topper were some of the most comfortable and restful nights I have ever had. The 100% cotton fabric cover is filled with the natural white goose down and feathers in two layers: the top layer is filled with goose down while the bottom layer is filled with goose feathers. The baffle box construction is reinforced with double-needle stitching to truly prevent the shifting of feathers through the life of the topper. 


  • High quality
  • Affordable
  • Odor-free feathers
  • Superior baffle box construction paired with double-needle stitching prevents shifting


  • Loft is only 3”

Best Down Alternative


Alternative down may be the best option for you, especially if you suffer from allergies or you are sensitive to natural feathers. 

Whatever the reason, this mattress topper by Superior is perfect for anyone who prefers an alternative down topper. The topper is filled with a lofty, hypoallergenic polyfill designed to mimic the fluff and comfort of real down feathers but without the same allergen issues. The shell is made from 100% premium microfiber, so it is ultra-soft and highly durable. The fill weight of this topper is over 9 pounds with a 2-inch loft height. Unlike natural down, which must be dry cleaned only, this down alternative topper is machine washable. 


  • Machine washable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Very low cost compared to natural down


  • Very thin
  • Not as soft as natural down

How to Pick the Best Feather Mattress Topper

When you are shopping for a featherbed, your main concern will be the materials used. Here is a little information to help you decide upon which type of feather mattress topper will work best for you:

Types of feather toppers:

There are two types of feather mattress toppers available: natural and synthetic.

Natural feather mattress toppers are typically filled with a combination of duck or goose feathers as well as down feathers. “Down” is the term given to the exceptionally soft and insulating layer of feathers found closest to a bird’s skin. Feathers and down feathers come together in down featherbeds to form a marshmallow-like mattress topper that cradles your body when you lay down.

Aside from natural duck and goose feathers, feather toppers may also be made with alternative down. Alternative down mattress toppers are typically made from polyfill and aim to copy the comfort of natural down but without the allergens and ethical concerns.

How to Choose Between Natural and Synthetic

Natural and synthetic feather toppers both have their own benefits and drawbacks, so choosing between the two is going to be based completely on your own wants and needs. 

When it comes to natural feather mattress toppers, the comfort level is unparalleled. Sleeping on a featherbed truly is like floating through the sky on a cloud and this level of comfort will help most people fall asleep and stay asleep. Natural feathers also sleep relatively cool and are a great option for hot sleepers. On the other hand, natural feathers tend to accumulate dust and microbes which end up triggering allergies. They also have a tendency to poke through the bedding and, if enough poke through, this can end up keeping you up at night.

Synthetic alternative down toppers are a great choice for anyone who suffers from allergies. Alternative down is hypoallergenic and the toppers are machine washable, unlike natural feather toppers which need to be dry cleaned. In addition, alternative down does not come with the ethical concerns that natural feather toppers come with. However, the main issue with alternative feather toppers is that they just are not as soft and fluffy as natural down toppers.

Pros and Cons of Feather Toppers

The benefits of feather mattress toppers include: 

  • Exceptional comfort
  • Extremely lightweight
  • Sleep cool
  • Long-lasting

The drawbacks to using a feather topper include:

  • Can be costly to clean – especially natural feather toppers
  • Without a true baffle box design, the filling tends to clump 
  • Natural feathers come with an allergy risk
  • Protruding feathers

Who Should Use a Feather Topper

So, who will benefit the most from a quality feather topper? Here are the groups of people that are most suited for feather toppers and why:

Who Should Use a Feather Topper? Why?
People with an uncomfortably hard or firm mattress Featherbeds are thick enough and soft enough to completely transform the feel of a mattress. One of the most desirable features of feather mattress toppers is their plush, cloud-like comfort.
People who prefer a less restrictive sleep surface Feather toppers do not restrict a sleeper’s movements so they are far easier to move on than other types of mattress toppers.
People who sleep hot Feather mattress toppers do not absorb much body heat and the feathers allow for adequate air circulation, overall keeping the topper cool throughout the night.



Whether you opt for a natural or a synthetic feather topper, we are confident that you are going to quickly fall in love with your bed again. In fact, once you have purchased a new feather mattress topper, we suggest picking up a new alarm clock too because you are not going to want to get out of bed ever again!