Best Innerspring Mattresses of 2023
Learn about what to look for in an innerspring mattress and check out our top-rated picks.
Jan 24th, 2023 •
Traditional innerspring mattress design has adapted to changing times, but you can still enjoy the bouncy feel of coiled springs with many of today’s top innerspring hybrids.
We’ve selected our list of today’s best innerspring mattresses that are anchored by coil systems and supplemented with pillow-tops, memory foam, latex, and more. You can compare our top-rated picks and also find out what to look for in our buyer’s guide.
Best Innerspring Mattress: Our Top Picks
- Best Mattress for Sex – WinkBeds EcoCloud
- Best Pillow Top Mattress – DreamCloud Premier
- Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers – Helix Midnight Luxe
- Editor’s Choice – Saatva Classic
- Best Mattress for Back Pain – Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
- Best Organic Mattress – Birch Natural Mattress
- Best Mattress for Heavy People – Big Fig
- Best Mattress for Athletes – Bear Star Hybrid
- Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers – Purple Hybrid
- Best Mattress for Side Sleepers – Casper Hybrid
Why You Can Trust Mattress Advisor
We hold ourselves to the highest standards of integrity in our product reviews and other content by incorporating real customer feedback, empirical testing, and objective evaluations. Our results and recommendations are never influenced by the commission we may receive from brands, and products we receive are never guaranteed a positive review.
Best Mattress for Sex
- Intimate couples
- Eco-conscious shoppers
- Combination sleepers
medium firm- 6.5/10
The WinkBeds EcoCloud is known for its bounciness and responsiveness, so you don’t feel stuck in the mattress as you move. It earns an 8.5/10 responsiveness score in our Mattress Advisor sleep lab. This makes this product a favorite for sex.
This product features zoning, which means the head and foot are softer, while it’s firmer in the center. Also, the natural latex aspect of this mattress makes it a cooler product for those who sleep hot.
Unless you’re of a lighter weight (under 130 pounds), this product may not be a good choice for the stomach sleeper. Also, this is not the best choice for the shopper on a budget.
Best Pillow Top Mattress
- Fans of soft top layers
- Side sleepers
- People who sleep hot
One of our best pillow top mattresses, the DreamCloud Premier is a great option for those who like their bed to feel soft and contouring on the surface while still being reasonably firm throughout the lower layers. The Euro Top Cradle Layer that covers this innerspring hybrid is made of high-loft memory foam.
If you have aching joints or pain in your back, shoulder, or hips, take note of the Premier’s 9/10 score for pressure relief. These pressure-relieving capabilities also make this hybrid a strong choice for side sleepers.
Although DreamCloud is hardly an ultra-luxury brand, the regular price for a queen-size Premier is nearly $1,600. Customers have also noticed some odor, called off-gassing, during unpacking, although it should clear up after several hours.
Helix Midnight Luxe
Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers
- People who sleep hot
- Restless sleepers
Medium firm: 6/10
The ultra-cool Helix Midnight Luxe could make night sweats seem like a bad dream from a long time ago. The 9.5/10 cooling score makes it one of the coolest mattresses we’ve ever reviewed.
A core layer with 1,000+ individually wrapped pocket coils provides zoned support, while a gel-infused memory foam layer and cooling pillow-top help regulate temperature. Also, the Midnight Luxe earns a 9/10 score for spine alignment—an encouraging sign for people with back pain who want to maintain a healthy sleep posture.
Budget shoppers, keep in mind that this mattress is a luxury product with a price tag to match. Regular price for a queen size mattress is just over $2,000.
- Multiple firmness options
- Lifetime warranty
While there are a lot of great innerspring mattresses out there, the Saatva Classic stands out because it excels pretty much across the board. This luxury hybrid is composed of five premium material layers, including a coil system, memory foam, and a Euro pillow-top. And all of these materials are eco-friendly.
In Mattress Advisor testing, the Saatva Classic earns flawless 10/10 scores for edge support, spine alignment, and durability. Also, you can choose from three firmness options: Plush Soft (3/10 on the firmness scale), Luxury Firm (6/10), or Firm (8/10).
With a regular price of nearly $1,800 for a queen-size, this mattress isn’t ideal for the shopper on a tight budget. Also, the 7.5/10 motion transfer score could make it less than ideal for couples, especially if one or more of them is a light sleeper.
Read our full Saatva Classic mattress review.
Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
Best Mattress for Back Pain
- People with aches and pains
- Side sleepers
- People who sleep hot
Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm
The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is one of Brooklyn Bedding’s top-rated mattresses, with good reason. One of the most important things a mattress can do for you is to help relieve back pain, and the Brooklyn Signature appears to have all the right qualities in that area.
This innerspring/foam hybrid provides superior pressure relief, which is evident from its 9.5/10 pressure relief score in Mattress Advisor testing—an important category for side sleepers as well. It also earns a solid 8.5/10 score for spine alignment. If you’re dealing with back pain, the best of the Brooklyn Signature’s three firmness options is probably the 8/10 Firm.
This hybrid may not be the best option for couples or if you share your bed with your kids or pets. We scored the Brooklyn Signature only a 7.25/10 on motion transfer, which means that it doesn’t do the best job of keeping movement from rippling across the surface.
Birch Natural Mattress
Best Organic Mattress
- Eco-conscious shoppers
- Edge support
- Restless sleepers
The Birch Natural Mattress is great for the eco-conscious shopper—it uses natural latex and organically sourced New Zealand, has an organic cotton cover, and the non-toxic foams are GREENGUARD Gold Certified.
The Birch also gets a flawless 10/10 score for edge support, which helps the mattress resist sagging and allows you to enjoy more of the mattress surface without getting that sinking feeling near the edge. For durability, the Birch also gets a perfect 10/10 score.
While latex is naturally cooling, the insulating effect of the wool and cotton may be partly responsible for the Birch Natural’s 8/10 cooling score. It’s not a bad score, but worth keeping in mind if you tend to overheat at night.
Best Mattress for Heavy People
- People weighing over 230 lbs
- Back and stomach sleepers
- Healthy spine alignment
The Big Fig mattress is designed to help heavy people get the best night’s sleep possible, supporting up to 1,100 lbs. Big Fig also offers a foundation (sold separately) crafted to support more weight than a typical bed.
In our test lab, this innerspring/foam hybrid excels at spine alignment (9/10) and pressure relief (8.5/10). We also give the Big Fig a perfect 10/10 responsiveness score, making it a superb option for restless sleepers and combination sleepers who alternative between different sleep positions during the night.
The larger sizes are quite bulky (140 lbs for a king-size), so you will likely need a friend to help you set this mattress up. Despite its pressure relief performance, the Big Fig might be just too firm for side sleepers.
Bear Star Hybrid
Best Mattress for Athletes
- Athletes and active lifestyles
- Healthy spine alignment
- People who want a durable bed
If you’re looking for an innerspring hybrid mattress designed for athletes, the Bear Star Hybrid could be an all-star addition to your lineup. The Celliant fabric in the cover is designed to aid in muscle recovery. Below the cover, you’ll find layers of adaptive comfort foam, gel-infused memory foam, and 1,300+ encased coils.
With a spine alignment score of 9.5/10, the Star Hybrid is a solid choice for keeping your body naturally aligned in a healthy, comfortable sleep posture. It earns an 8.75/10 responsiveness score, making it a good option for restless sleepers who toss and turn.
On the other hand, the 7.5/10 pressure relief score is a possible red flag for side sleepers and people with back or shoulder pain. Despite the coil layer, we score the Bear Star Hybrid a mediocre 7.25/10 for edge support.
Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers
- Side/back combination sleepers
- Hot sleepers
- Restless sleepers
Medium firm: 7/10
If you find yourself changing sleeping positions throughout the night, the Purple Hybrid’s responsiveness (9/10 Mattress Advisor score) makes it a great choice.
The Smart Comfort Grid gives when a set amount of pressure is applied, so that the heavier parts of your body sink while the lighter parts don’t. This feature helps propel the Purple Hybrid’s strong performance in pressure relief (10/10 score) and spine alignment (8.5/10).
Regular price for a queen-size exceeds $2,000, so look elsewhere if you’re on a budget. Due to its 7/10 motion transfer score, couples and people whose kids or pets share the bed with them might have a less than tranquil sleep experience.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
- Side sleeping position
- Restless sleepers
- Edge support
The Casper Hybrid can help side sleepers enjoy the bouncy feel of innersprings without sacrificing the body-contouring properties of memory foam.
Pressure-relieving airfoam and Zoned Support memory foam sit atop a layer of individually pocketed coils. The combination helps the Casper Hybrid achieve solid scores for pressure relief (8/10) and cooling (8.5/10). Even better than those scores is the Casper Hybrid’s performance in spine alignment, where it earns 9/10. Side sleepers need good spine alignment since the position puts strain on the shoulders, lower back, and hips.
Despite its overall 9.4/10 score, one of the Casper Hybrid’s few flaws is that its 5/10 firmness rating might not match up well with stomach sleepers or people who weigh over 230 pounds.
Many people have been sleeping on an innerspring mattress all their lives without knowing the difference. In this buyer’s guide, we’ll go over all the important considerations you should make when evaluating an innerspring mattress, so you can become a more informed shopper, like the following:
- What is an Innerspring Mattress?
- What Does an Innerspring Mattress Feel Like?
- Pros and Cons of Spring Mattresses
- Who are They Good (and Bad) for?
- What to Consider When Shopping
The simple definition of an innerspring mattress is found in its name—it is a mattress with an inner core of springs. These springs are called coils, and they make up the supportive core of the mattress.
Innerspring mattresses were invented in the late 1800s and became the most popular mattress type starting in the 1930s. The steel coils offer a springy, supportive bounciness that remains unique and sought-after to this day.
Dissect an innerspring mattress and you will find other materials that improve its longevity and comfort. Surrounding the coils is sturdy polyurethane foam. This foam keeps the springs in place and provides firm edge support for when you get in and out of bed.
Many of today’s innerspring mattresses could also be described as hybrids—one part innerspring and one part memory foam or latex. Featuring supportive coils topped by foam or latex layers, hybrid mattresses aim to provide the best of both worlds.
Types of Coils
One of the most important factors to consider when shopping for an innerspring mattress is the type of coils found within. Coil type affects what a mattress feels like, how long it lasts, and how much it costs.
- Bonnell Coils—These springs, which resemble an hourglass, are wired together to produce a durable and supportive mattress. Unfortunately, the result also produces mattresses that are noisy, don’t isolate motion well, and lack the body-contouring feel of memory foam. Many inexpensive spring mattresses use Bonnell coils.
- Pocketed Coils—Also known as individually wrapped coils or Marshall coils, the pocket spring is the most advanced type of coil. Each spring is individually wrapped in a fabric and then joined together during assembly. This results in a mattress with enhanced motion isolation and body contouring properties because the coils work independently of each other. Most top hybrid mattresses use pocketed coils in their innerspring layers.
- Offset Coils—Offset coils are similar to Bonnell coils, but with improvements that make it a more comfortable mattress type. The hourglass shape is slightly altered to create a hinging effect, resulting in enhanced body contouring and motion isolation. In comfort and cost, the offset coil falls between the pocket spring and Bonnell coil.
- Continuous Coils—This design contains a single, continuous wire instead of individual coils. This wire is constructed into rows that resemble a series of S-shapes. It’s incredibly durable and affordable, but not very comfortable or quiet.
The firm, springy support of an innerspring is something that you are probably very familiar with. But outside of this bounciness and stable support, every coil mattress is different.
Take an innerspring pillow top mattress with a comfort layer of conforming memory foam for example. You will feel the soft give and pressure point relief that comes from these comfort layer materials.
On the flip side, if you lie down on a cut-rate innerspring bed, there is often only a very thin layer of polyurethane foam. This type of mattress may feel overly firm and bouncy. The best innerspring mattresses use high-quality materials to provide a balanced feel—firmly supportive and cushioning at the same time.
Let’s explore the advantages and disadvantages of sleeping on an innerspring mattress.
- Sleeps cool. The coil center allows plenty of air circulation, resulting in a mattress that sleeps cooler than most other mattresses.
- Good for sex. Thanks to the springiness of steel coils, this type of mattress has lots of bounce.
- Affordable. While there are a wide range of innerspring mattress costs, you can find inexpensive options.
- Solid edge support. Firmness around the edge of the mattress is helpful for people who sleep near or sit on the edge of their bed.
- Noisy. Springs are known for creaking and squeaking, a problem that can grow worse over time as they begin to lose tension.
- Transfers motion. Springs easily transmit movement from one side of the bed to the others, which can be disruptive for sleepers who share a bed.
- Durability. On average, innerspring mattresses do not have as long of a lifespan as other mattresses, largely due to sagging over time. Spring quality will largely determine longevity.
- Lack of contouring. In comparison to other mattress types, innerspring mattresses are not as good at contouring to a sleeper’s unique body shape—particularly troublesome for side sleepers.
The benefits of the innerspring mattress make it a solid option for many different types of people—many but not all. Here’s a look at who might benefit, and who might not.
- Back and stomach sleepers. Those who need (or just like) a firmer mattress tend to find innerspring mattresses comfortable. Back sleepers and stomach sleepers, in particular, require a firm mattress to maintain proper spine alignment.
- Hot sleepers. Many people who sleep hot find that innerspring mattresses are the best option for their needs. Because of the abundant air circulation allowed by the space between the coils, this is the most breathable mattress material. This also makes the coil mattress good for those who live in a warm climate without air conditioning.
- Seniors. Another group who can benefit from a spring mattress are people who have trouble getting into or out of bed. The bouncy support and firm edges make it easy to get on and off of the mattress and to move around at night. This can benefit the elderly or others who have mobility challenges.
Not the Best for:
- Side sleepers. When you sleep on your side, you need a mattress that provides more give at your shoulders, hips, and ankles. Without enough give, improper spine alignment and pain at these pressure points is common. Memory foam mattresses are the best option for optimal pressure point relief.
- Co-sleepers. Coils might be good for sex, but when it’s time to go to sleep, poor motion isolation and squeaking springs can ruin the mood. Latex mattresses are a popular option for couples because they’re made of a responsive foam that doesn’t have some of the flaws of a coil mattress.
- People who want durability with consistency. An innerspring mattress could have several hundred coils or even more than 1,000. If some of the coils start to lose tension before the others, you could wind up with a mattress that has uneven support across the surface.
Related: Latex vs. Innerspring
When you start shopping for an innerspring mattress, there are a handful of factors that you should take into consideration to ensure that you find a quality mattress that works for you.
Innerspring mattresses and innerspring hybrids tend to work very well for stomach sleepers and back sleepers, owing to their firmness. Combination sleepers who alternate between their back and their side can also get good results. Side sleeping is the only position where the firm support of innersprings could be a problem.
Side sleepers put added strain on their down-facing shoulder, their hips, and their lower back. The body-contouring effects of memory foam allow these areas to sink into the mattress surface just a bit, which helps cushion the sensitive pressure points and promote healthy spine alignment.
Still, a hybrid with multiple layers of foam above an innerspring core could work for many side sleepers. Just look at the ratio of foam layers to coils—if the mattress is 12″ thick, for example, the foam layers should add up to at least 6″.
Coil Count and Gauge
Coil count is the number of coils in a mattress, and it affects the feel and longevity of a mattress. As a general rule, the more coils, the better it will feel and the longer it will last. Look for a mattress that has a minimum of 800 coils. Once you exceed 1,000 coils, you are unlikely to feel a difference.
Coil gauge is a measure of how thick the coils are. A coil gauge normally measures between 12 and 15. Counterintuitively, a higher gauge means a thinner coil. A high-gauge, thin coil is going to be more flexible, with a bit of a softer feel. A low-gauge, thick coil is going to be very firm and durable.
If you like a firm mattress, look for a coil gauge of 13 or lower. For those who like a bit more give to a mattress, 14 is a good coil gauge.
You can find both budget-friendly and luxury innerspring mattresses. A good-quality coil mattress will usually cost upwards of $800 for a queen size. There are cheaper options, but keep in mind that an inexpensive model is unlikely to provide a mattress that is both comfortable and durable. This does not mean that every expensive mattress will be worth it. Read reviews and product listings carefully to ensure that you are getting the quality that you pay for.
Related: Best Budget Mattresses
Trial Period and Warranty
Always look for a mattress that offers a generous trial period and a long-lasting warranty. Most bed-in-a-box mattresses will come with a 90-100 day trial period. During this time, you can return or exchange the mattress for little-to-no cost. Some will even extend this offer for a full year, allowing you to thoroughly test out your new mattress.
Mattress warranties normally cover manufacturing issues only. A good warranty should last a minimum of 10 years. Be wary of short warranties. They often signal a poor-quality product.
Related: Get the full rundown on mattress shopping in our comprehensive Mattress Buying Guide.
How long does an innerspring mattress last?
Most innerspring mattresses last from seven to 10 years, with the recommendation of replacing it after 10 years. There are many factors that affect the lifespan of an innerspring mattress, including:
- Type of coils: Independently moving coils, like pocketed coils, tend to have a longer lifespan. Bonnell coils, which move collectively, impact larger parts of the mattress, which can cause broader wear-and-tear.
- Coil gauge: Low gauge coils are thicker and typically last longer.
- Wear and tear: Stress and general wear-and-tear reduce the longevity of the coils in innerspring mattresses. For example, when more body weight (from kids jumping on the bed) is applied, the coils will wear out faster.
Are innerspring mattresses good for back pain?
The general answer is: only if they’re hybrids, and only if they use high-quality coils. A hybrid mattress that has layers of memory foam or latex above an innerspring core provides more pressure relief and zoned support than springs alone. The innerspring layer should use individually pocketed coils that more easily contour around the lower back.
Related: Best Mattresses for Back Pain
How many springs in a mattress is good?
The answer to this question has one caveat: the gauge of the coils in the mattress. While a higher-quality mattress will have above 1,000 springs, it is also critical to review the gauge of the springs. A mattress with 1,200 springs with a high gauge (thin coils) is not as high quality as a mattress with 1,000 low gauge springs (thicker, more durable coils).
It’s important to shop for mattresses with a wider context in mind, instead of focusing solely on counting coils, so you can find the best mattress for your needs.
Recap: Picks for Best Innerspring Mattress
We understand how hard mattress shopping can be. We hope our top picks and our comprehensive buyer’s guide have helped you on your journey to finding a mattress that will give you great sleep for many years to come.
As a reminder, here are our top picks for the best innerspring mattresses:
|Mattress||Award||Mattress Advisor Score|
|WinkBeds EcoCloud||Best Mattress for Sex||8.5/10|
|DreamCloud Premier||Best Pillow Top Mattress||8.9/10|
|Helix Midnight Luxe||Best for Hot Sleepers||8.7/10|
|Saatva Classic||Editor’s Choice||9.0/10|
|Brooklyn Signature Hybrid||Best for Back Pain||8.8/10|
|Birch Natural Mattress||Best Organic Mattress||9.2/10|
|Big Fig||Best for Heavy People||8.8/10|
|Bear Star Hybrid||Best for Athletes||9.0/10|
|Purple Hybrid||Best for Combination Sleepers||8.9/10|
|Casper Hybrid||Best for Side Sleepers||8.9/10|
Best Hybrid Mattresses
Searching the web for the best hybrid mattress? Hybrid beds are some of the most popular bed-in-a-box mattresses. Check out our top picks and shopping tips.
Best Memory Foam Mattress
See our expert reviews for the best memory foam mattresses on the market. Our top picks feature mattresses for back pain, side sleepers, hot sleepers, and more.
Best Mattresses of 2023
We've reviewed over 150 beds to select our best mattress of 2023. See our top picks for side sleepers, hot sleepers, kids, seniors, and more.