Best Mattresses of October 2019

By Alesandra Woolley

What is the best mattress of 2019? The short answer is: it depends on your sleeping style, body type and spending budget. The expert review team at Mattress Advisor tested over 120 different beds including memory foam, latex, hybrid, innerspring and pillow top mattresses to bring you the most comfortable mattresses for every body and price point. Take a look at our top picks in each category to find the best mattress for you.

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Mattress Award Price
Leesa Hybrid Best Overall $$
Nectar Best Value $
Saatva Best Luxury $$$
Leesa Best for Side Sleepers $$
Brooklyn Signature Best for Back Sleepers $$
Layla Best for Stomach Sleepers $$
Casper Wave Best for Back Pain $$$
Puffy Lux Best for Pressure Relief $$$
Helix Midnight Luxe Best for Couples $$
Brooklyn Aurora Best for Hot Sleepers $$$
Big Fig Best for Heavy People $$$
Awara Best Eco-Friendly Mattress $$
Tuft & Needle Mint Best Memory Foam $$
DreamCloud Best Hybrid/Innerspring $$
Casper Essential Best for Kids $
Saatva Solaire Best for Seniors $$$

As you read through the details below, consider factors like materials, firmness, support, and price to determine which mattress will be best for you to help you get a good night’s sleep.


Leesa Hybrid Mattress

Best Overall
Leesa Hybrid mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 9.4/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Luxury hybrid mattress made with pocket springs and foam
Firmness Medium-firm (7/10)
Trial Period 100 nights
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $1,799 for queen

Read our full review on the Leesa Hybrid

Why We Love the Leesa Hybrid 

It’s hard to fit the Leesa Hybrid (formerly known as the Sapira) into any one particular category because it’s good at a lot of things. As one of our highest-rated mattresses, we find ourselves recommending the Leesa Hybrid to all types of sleepers. The main reason is because of its impeccable responsiveness and pressure relief.

No matter what position you sleep in, the Leesa Hybrid will adjust to your body’s position and provide the right amount of support and pressure relief in the areas you need it most. Think of it as a cushion that pushes back on areas of high pressure, like your hips and shoulders, so you can wake up on the right side of the bed pain-free each morning.

The individually pocketed coils inside the Leesa Hybrid provide additional support, freedom of movement, and durability. This is the perfect recipe for deep, restorative sleep that many people only dream about.

Who is it Good For?

While the Leesa Hybrid wins the award for “best overall” mattress, it’s particularly good for:

  • 💑 Couples: Leesa Hybrid does a good job of keeping motion transfer at a minimum so you won’t be disturbed by your partner moving around at night.
  • 🛌 People with back pain: Its high performance in relieving pain in the pressure points and spine alignment make it ideal for alleviating back and joint pain while you sleep.
  • 🔥 People who sleep hot: Leesa Hybrid is designed to promote airflow so your body heat doesn’t get trapped inside its layers.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10
  • Trial Period: 9
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9
  • Setup: 8 
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 10

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 9
  • Edge Support: 8
  • Pressure Relief: 9
  • Spine Alignment: 10
  • Responsiveness: 9
  • Cooling: 8
  • Durability: 9

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 9.4/10


Nectar Mattress

Best Value
Nectar mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.7/10
Customer Rating 4.8/5
Materials Gel memory foam
Firmness Medium firm (5.5-6/10)
Trial Period 365 nights (yes, a full year!)
Warranty Lifetime warranty for as long as you own the mattress
Price $699 for queen

Read our full Nectar mattress review.

Why We Love the Nectar Mattress

There are a few things that immediately set Nectar apart from other mattresses:

  • It has one of the longest trial periods in the industry (a full year!)
  • Its warranty is valid for as long as you own the mattress
  • It’s a high-quality option for a low-price budget mattress

Nectar’s gel memory foam surface along with the other three other foam layers provide great pressure relief and motion isolation. It will give you more of a “hugging” feel, which is ideal for people who don’t move around a lot throughout the night. As an added bonus, Nectar’s proprietary cover is specifically designed to keep out dust mites.

Who is it Good For?

💲People on a Budget

As far as bed-in-a-box memory foam mattresses go, the Nectar is one of the most budget-friendly beds on the market. Just because Nectar cuts costs doesn’t mean you need to worry about cutting quality. The combination of gel memory foam and adaptive hi-core memory foam create a mattress that provides both the “hugging” comfort and responsive support that you need in a bed. Plus, people on a budget are usually tight with their cash and worry about making big purchases. With Nectar, you get a lifetime warranty and a 365-day sleep trial so you can rest easy about your purchase.

See the best mattresses for budget shoppers

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9
  • Trial Period: 10
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10
  • Setup: 8 
  • Customer Service: 8.5
  • Social Impact: 5

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8.5
  • Edge Support: 9
  • Pressure Relief: 8
  • Spine Alignment: 7.5
  • Responsiveness: 8.5
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 8.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.7/10


Saatva Mattress

Best Luxury Mattress
Saatva mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.7/10
Customer Rating 4.8/5
Materials Coil on coil and memory foam with euro pillow-top
Firmness Choose between plush, luxury firm or firm
Trial Period 120 nights
Warranty 15-year limited warranty
Price $1,358 for queen

Read our full Saatva mattress review

Why We Love the Saatva Mattress

The Saatva mattress will make you feel like you’re sleeping in a 5-star hotel. It’s made with comfort layers of coil-on-coil construction that sit below memory foam and a plush euro pillow-top. The Saatva is handcrafted in independent, American factories using high-quality materials like organic cotton, eco-friendly foams and recycled steel rod coil units.

Saatva’s superior customer service will also make you feel like royalty. The company offers free in-home set-up for your new mattress and free removal of your old mattress to help make the transition to your new mattress easier. Saatva is rated one of the best mattresses for seniors because of this seamless, hands-off customer experience (plus, it appeals to the various sleeping needs of aging seniors to get a good night’s rest).

In addition to the luxury feel, Saatva also offers exceptional spine alignment to promote healthy and restorative sleep. If you tend to move around throughout the night, Saatva will support your movements no matter what position you sleep in. The best part is that a Saatva mattress is built to last. It’s one of the most durable mattresses on the market, meaning you’ll reap these benefits for years to come.

Who is it Good For?

💰Luxury Mattress Shoppers

If you’re looking for a top of the line mattress, you will find that with the Saatva. When people ask us how to find a bed that feels like sleeping in a luxury hotel, this is where we lead them. In terms of quality construction, the Saatva is handcrafted with high-quality organic and eco-friendly materials to give you a healthy and happy night’s sleep.

But where they really stand out is in their customer service. Saatva offers free white glove delivery with every mattress purchase AND free removal of your old mattress. You won’t have to lift a finger and you’ll sleep like royalty. Now that’s what we call a luxury experience. 

See the best luxury mattresses

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9.5
  • Trial Period: 10
  • Return Policy: 8
  • Warranty: 10
  • Setup: 10 
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 7

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 7.5
  • Edge Support: 8.5
  • Pressure Relief: 6.5
  • Spine Alignment: 9.5
  • Responsiveness: 7.5
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 10

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.4/10


Leesa Mattress

Best for Side Sleepers
Leesa mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 9.3/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Luxury hybrid mattress made with pocket springs and foam
Firmness Medium-firm (6/10)
Trial Period 100 nights
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $999 for queen

Read our full Leesa mattress review

Why We Love the Leesa Mattress

If you’re a side sleeper, it’s important to look for a mattress that will evenly distribute your body weight and support your pressure points – particularly in areas of high pressure like your hips, shoulders and knees. The Leesa mattress is our top pick for side sleepers because of its excellent contouring properties that help relieve this type of pressure.

The Leesa also scored very well in our spine alignment test – meaning this mattress will help keep your spine in a straight line while sleeping on your side.

Another area that Leesa scored highly in during our testing is responsiveness. This means that no matter what position you sleep in, Leesa will provide the support you need. Since side sleepers tend to change positions throughout the night more than other positions, this is a favorable trait when looking for the best mattress for side sleepers.

Who is it Good For?

🛌🏻People Who Sleep on Their Side

The original Leesa mattress is ideal for side sleepers due to its excellent contouring and pressure relieving properties. This bed was constructed to evenly distribute your body weight across the mattress. This is key for side sleepers because you need your spine to stay aligned and you want to avoid too much pressure in the hips and shoulders. The Leesa mattress balances this perfectly to give side sleepers support and comfort all night long. 

See the best mattresses for side sleepers

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10
  • Trial Period: 9 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9 
  • Setup: 8.5
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 10 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 9 
  • Edge Support: 8.5
  • Pressure Relief: 8.5
  • Spine Alignment: 9
  • Responsiveness: 9.5
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 9

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 9.3/10


Brooklyn Signature

Best for Back Sleepers
Brooklyn Signature mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 9.1/10
Customer Rating 4.7/5
Materials Memory foam and coils
Firmness Available in Plush, Medium, and Firm
Trial Period 120 nights
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $949 for queen

Read our full Brooklyn Signature mattress review

Why We Love the Brooklyn Signature

The Brooklyn Signature is a customizable hybrid mattress, giving you the option to choose between soft, medium, or firm, firmness levels. When it comes to back sleepers in particular, both the medium and firm options are perfect—it just depends on what you prefer. 

Scoring nearly perfectly on our pressure relief test, this mattress will bring you nothing but comfort and take unwanted pressure from those painful spots in your back. It also maintains the natural curve of your spine as you sleep, especially important for waking up with no lower back pain.

On top of all these awesome features, the Brooklyn Signature is produced and manufactured in-house from beginning to end. This allows them to cut out the middle man, keep prices low, and keep you happy.

Who is it Good For?

🛌🏻People Who Sleep on Their Back

Each sleeping position has unique needs in a mattress. For back sleepers, it’s important to look for the right balance of support, responsiveness, and comfort. Although back sleeping is the best and most healthy sleeping position, there are a few requirements you need in your mattress to reap the benefits.

If a bed isn’t supportive enough, you’re likely to sink in too far and put your body in an unnatural arch position. However, if it’s too firm you won’t get the slight cushion you need. The Brooklyn Signatures strikes the perfect balance, available in three firmness levels to customize based on your needs. (We recommend the Firm level for primary back sleepers and Medium for combination sleepers who spend some time on their back at night.) 

See the best mattresses for back sleepers

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9
  • Setup: 8
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 9 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 7.25
  • Edge Support: 9 
  • Pressure Relief: 9.5
  • Spine Alignment: 8.5
  • Responsiveness: 8.25
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 8.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 9.1/10


Layla Mattress

Best for Stomach Sleepers
New Layla mattress in a bedroom

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.8/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Copper-infused memory foam
Firmness Soft side (4-5/10); Firm side (7/10)
Trial Period 120 nights
Warranty Lifetime limited warranty
Price $899 for queen

Read our full Layla mattress review

Why We Love the Layla Mattress

The Layla mattress is one of the most unique mattresses on the market! It’s flippable, so you can use both sides of the mattress depending on your firmness preference, and it’s built with memory foam infused with copper. Copper is known to help reduce joint inflammation and ease aches and pains, so you’ll get a good night’s sleep on the Layla! 

In our testing, the Layla performed very well in terms of responsiveness, edge support, and pressure relief. Both sides of the mattress, soft or firm, offer a nice balance of cushion and support. So you won’t sink in to the Layla (especially on the more firm side) but you’ll still get the contouring comfort you need. 

Who is it Good For?

🛌🏻People Who Sleep on Their Stomach

Stomach sleeping is the rarest sleeping position, so if you fall in this category you may have a more difficult time finding a bed that offers everything you need for your unique position. Stomach sleepers need extra support in their mattress to help keep your spine aligned instead of sinking in to an arched position.

The Layla is our number one pick for stomach sleepers because of its two unique features. For one thing, it’s flippable, so you can choose which firmness level works best for you (we recommend the more firm side for stomach sleepers). Secondly, the Layla is infused with copper which helps reduce joint inflammation, pain, and stiffness. Many stomach sleepers end up experiencing lower back or neck pain from this position, so the Layla is perfect for addressing these needs and leading you to a restorative night’s sleep. 

See the best mattresses for stomach sleepers.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 9 
  • Customer Service: 9 
  • Social Impact: 3

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8.5
  • Edge Support: 9 
  • Pressure Relief: 9 
  • Spine Alignment: 8 
  • Responsiveness: 9.5
  • Cooling: 7.5
  • Durability: 8 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.8/10


Casper Wave

Best for Back Pain
Man laying on a Casper Wave mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.6/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Latex foam and memory foam
Firmness Medium-firm to firm: 7/10
Trial Period 100 days
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $2,295 for queen

Read our full Casper Wave mattress review.

Why We Love the Casper Wave

The Wave is Casper’s most advanced mattress. Designed using more than three years worth of customer data, the Casper Wave was built to provide custom support in key areas like the shoulders, hips, and knees. This unique design with targeted support makes the Casper Wave a great fit for side sleepers who need this level of support and those with back and joint pain. 

This high-end memory foam mattress includes five memory foam layers with an ergonomic support system targeting 33 specific body points. The Wave is designed to mirror your body’s natural shape and offer the support you need in the night. It’s great for relieving pressure at the pain points, keeping your spine aligned, and helping you wake up feeling well-rested.

Who is it Good For?

People with Back Pain

The Wave has an advanced design targeting 33 specific body points to match the comfort and support you need in all the right places. This addresses the need to evenly distribute your body weight across the mattress and keep your spine in a neutral alignment during the night so you can avoid back pain. The Casper Wave is even endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA)!

See the best mattresses for back pain

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9 
  • Trial Period: 9 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9 
  • Setup: 8 
  • Customer Service: 9 
  • Social Impact: 9 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8 
  • Edge Support: 9 
  • Pressure Relief: 6.75
  • Spine Alignment: 8.5
  • Responsiveness: 8 
  • Cooling: 8 
  • Durability: 8.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.7/10


Puffy Lux Mattress

Best for Pressure Relief
Puffy Lux mattress in a bedroom

Quick Facts

MA Score 9.2/10
Customer Rating 5/5
Materials Cooling Cloud Foam
Firmness Medium-soft to Medium: 5.5-7
Trial Period 101 nights
Warranty Lifetime warranty for as long as you own the mattress
Price $1,795 for queen

Read our full Puffy Lux mattress review.

Why We Love the Puffy Lux Mattress

The Puffy Lux mattress is a plush, yet supportive luxury foam mattress that is slightly soft on the top, but firm enough to provide spine alignment supportive comfort at the pressure points. What sets the Lux mattress apart is an adaptive Dual Cloud layer that contours your body while you’re sleeping.

The Puffy Lux does its job so well that when we brought it into our lab, our tester said, “It feels like sleeping on a cloud!” without even knowing the brand he was testing.

Puffy’s gel-infused memory foam uses convection and conduction technology to disperse heat away from your body, increasing airflow 8x more than standard foam mattresses.

Who is it Good For?

People Who Need Pressure Relief

Optimal pressure relief in a mattress is key to reducing those morning aches and pains. This could be important to you if you’re an athlete/active person, a side sleeper, a senior, someone with disabilities, or just generally a person who doesn’t want to wake up sore in the morning. (Who does?!)

The Puffy Lux does a superior job providing pressure relief for all types of sleepers. It received nearly a perfect score in our pressure relief test!

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 10 
  • Customer Service: 9 
  • Social Impact: 7

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8.25
  • Edge Support: 8.5
  • Pressure Relief: 9.5
  • Spine Alignment: 9 
  • Responsiveness: 9.25
  • Cooling: 8.75
  • Durability: 8.75

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 9.3/10


Helix Midnight LUXE

Best for Couples

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.9/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Memory foam + coils
Firmness Medium firm: 6/10
Trial Period 100 nights
Warranty 15-year limited warranty
Price $1,795 for queen

Read our full Helix Midnight LUXE mattress review.

Why We Love the Helix Midnight LUXE Mattress

The Helix Midnight LUXE is a perfect option for couples who might want different things in a mattress. It’s the ideal firmness (right in the middle) and is designed with zoned lumbar support with its core layer of pocketed coils that provide the right level of support and cradling at different parts of your body. So no matter your body type, you can find comfort on the Midnight LUXE.

The Helix Midnight LUXE is also made with premium, American materials and is designed to promote airflow to keep you cool – an important factor if you’re sharing the bed with someone. Finally, the layers of memory foam layers toward the top of the mattress reduce motion transfer, so if your sleeping partner moves, you won’t be disturbed.

Who is it Good For?

💑Couples

There are a few things couples should look for in a mattress that they will share: motion isolation, durability, and a mutually-agreeable comfort level. The Helix Midnight Luxe delivers all these factors making it ideal for couples who don’t want to worry about compromising.

The motion isolation allows for both of you to sleep peacefully while the other moves around. Durability is key for a bed that will be shared by two so it lasts from years of sleep (and other activities). And the hybrid construction allows for a meet-in-the-middle firmness on which you both can find comfort. 

See the best mattresses for couples.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10 
  • Trial Period: 9 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 7.75
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 5

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 7.75
  • Edge Support: 8 
  • Pressure Relief: 8.5
  • Spine Alignment: 9 
  • Responsiveness: 8.75
  • Cooling: 9.5
  • Durability: 9 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.9/10


Brooklyn Aurora

Best for Hot Sleepers
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress on a bedframe in a bedroom

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.9/10
Customer Rating 4.4/5
Materials Copper Gel Energex, memory foam, and coils
Firmness 3 firmness levels: soft (3/10), medium (5/10), firm (7/10)
Trial Period 120 nights
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $1,699 for queen

Read our full Brooklyn Aurora mattress review.

Why We Love the Brooklyn Aurora Mattress

The Brooklyn Aurora mattress is one of the coolest mattresses we have ever had in the Mattress Lab – temperature wise, and otherwise. Even weeks after unboxing this mattress, it was still cool to the touch.

Its hybrid construction of cooling foams and coil allows for superior airflow and breathability. The top layer even works to actively draw heat away from your body while you sleep. So if you tend to sweat through your sheets at night, you may find that the Aurora helps you stay cool and sweat-free.

Who is it Good For?

🔥Hot Sleepers

Got a case of chronic night sweats? The Brooklyn Aurora is our top pick when it comes to finding a cooling mattress that can help address your symptoms. While your mattress can’t cure your night sweats, it definitely can help play a role in temperature regulation and wicking away your body heat. The Aurora is constructed with copper gel energex, cooling memory foam, and coils for better airflow and breathability. 

See the best mattresses for hot sleepers

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9 
  • Setup: 9 
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 9 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8.5
  • Edge Support: 8 
  • Pressure Relief: 7 
  • Spine Alignment: 8.5
  • Responsiveness: 9.25
  • Cooling: 9.5
  • Durability: 8 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.9/10


Big Fig

Best for Heavy People
Big Fig mattress

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.8/10
Customer Rating 4.5/5
Materials Gel-infused latex foam + coils
Firmness 3 firmness levels: soft (3/10), medium (5/10), firm (7/10)
Trial Period 120 nights
Warranty 20-year limited warranty
Price $1,699 for queen

Read our full Big Fig mattress review.

Why We Love the Big Fig Mattress

The Big Fig was carefully designed to support people with bigger figures. It does a great job of providing pressure relief and supporting heavier parts of the body where it’s needed most.

Heavier sleepers claim that they don’t sink into this mattress like they do with others. The hybrid construction, durable materials and sturdy foundation help with this. The top layer of the Big Fig will also promote a cooler night’s sleep.

Who is it Good For?

➕Plus-Size or Heavy People

Just like most things in life, mattresses are not designed with a  one-size-fits-all approach. Heavier people (200+ lbs.) need more support from a mattress simply due to the forces of gravity. An ultra-soft memory foam mattress cannot offer the support your figure needs. The Big Fig is designed with heavier people in mind to provide the proper amount of support, pressure relief, and comfort.

See the best mattresses for heavy people.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 6 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 7.5
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 4

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 9.5
  • Edge Support: 8.1
  • Pressure Relief: 7.75
  • Spine Alignment: 8 
  • Responsiveness: 9.5
  • Cooling: 9 
  • Durability: 9.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.8/10


Awara

Best Eco-Friendly

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.8/10
Customer Rating 4.8/5
Materials Sustainable latex, wool, and cotton
Firmness Medium-firm: 7/10
Trial Period 365 nights
Warranty Lifetime warranty for as long as you own the mattress
Price $999 for queen

Read our full Awara mattress review.

Why We Love the Awara Mattress

The Awara mattress is newer to the market but is quickly becoming a fan favorite with its eco-friendly features and a competitive price point. It’s constructed with premium 100% organic Dunlop latex that is GOLS certified and 5-zoned pocket-coils to create the perfect blend of support and contour. The interior of the mattress has two core layers topped with an all-natural cotton and wool cover.

With the Awara, you can rest assured that you’re sleeping on quality materials that will last you years to come.

Who is it Good For?

🌎♻️Eco-Friendly Shoppers

Buying a mattress that’s good to the environment, affordable, and high-quality? What a dream! The Awara is built with 100% organic Dunlop latex and all-natural cotton and wool. These materials are naturally breathable, so you’ll get a cool night’s sleep. Plus, with the hybrid construction, nearly anyone can find this bed comfortable.

See the best organic mattresses.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 8.5
  • Customer Service: 8 
  • Social Impact: 5 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 9 
  • Edge Support: 9 
  • Pressure Relief: 7.5
  • Spine Alignment: 8.5
  • Responsiveness: 8.25
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 9 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.8/10


Tuft & Needle Mint

Best Memory Foam
Tuft and Needle Mint mattress on a wooden bed frame in a bedroom

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.9/10
Customer Rating 4.9/5
Materials Foam blend
Firmness Medium: 5/10
Trial Period 100 days
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $895 for queen

Read our full Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress Review.

Why We Love the Mint

The Tuft & Needle Mint is Tuft & Needle’s advanced mattress model that still comes at a reasonable price. If you like Tuft & Needle’s original mattress model, you’ll love the Mint.

The Mint mattress includes Adaptive® Foam that’s made with 30% more heat-wicking graphite than the original model to provide advanced cooling. Plus the Adaptive Transition layer even deeper in the mattress is infused with ceramic gel beads that absorb 5x more heat than conventional blue gel products. 

Some of the best scores for the Mint mattress in our testing were for cooling, responsiveness, and spine alignment. These are all key factors to making a high-quality bed. With all of these great qualities, a medium-firmness level that appeals to all, and an affordable price point, what’s not to love about the Mint?!

Who is it Good For?

🛏️Memory Foam Lovers

Many people love the soft, cushioning feel of memory foam, but hate some of the consequences that can come with this material like trapping heat and lacking support. The Mint doesn’t have either of these issues!

This advanced memory foam bed goes to extreme lengths to keep you cool at night with heat-wicking graphite and ceramic gel beads infused in the foam layers. Plus, the Mint scored a nearly perfect score on our spine alignment test with a 9.5 proving that it offers superior support. Memory foam lovers looking to reap all the benefits of memory foam and avoid some of the pains will find their dream match in the Mint.

See the best memory foam mattresses.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9 
  • Trial Period: 9 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 9
  • Setup: 9 
  • Customer Service: 10 
  • Social Impact: 7 

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 8.1
  • Edge Support: 8.25
  • Pressure Relief: 8 
  • Spine Alignment: 9.5
  • Responsiveness: 8.75
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 8.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.9/10


DreamCloud

Best Hybrid/Innerspring

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.8/10
Customer Rating 4.8/5
Materials Memory foam and coils
Firmness Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Trial Period 365 nights
Warranty Lifetime warranty
Price $999 for queen

Read our full DreamCloud mattress review.

Why We Love the DreamCloud

The DreamCloud is a luxury hybrid mattress with all the bells and whistles. In its 8-layer construction, the DreamCloud contains gel-infused memory foam, natural latex, and a coil compression system. Combined, these create a bed that is cooling, comfortable, bouncy, contouring, and supportive. It’s everything you could want in a bed!

The DreamCloud scored particularly well in our spine alignment test, receiving a 9.5 for its exceptional ability at supporting the body in all the right places. It also scored well for responsiveness, meaning you won’t sink in to the bed more than you want to and moving around during the night is seamless.

Who is it Good For?

🛏️Hybrid Mattress Lovers

The DreamCloud has a complex hybrid construction that makes it one of the best hybrid mattresses we’ve seen. It’s eight layers deep, mixing different types of memory foam, latex, and a coil construction to bring out all the best qualities you look for in a mattress. The DreamCloud is comfortably contouring, supportive, and breathable for a cool night’s sleep. 

See the best hybrid mattresses.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 10 
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 10 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 7.5
  • Customer Service: 8 
  • Social Impact: 5

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 7.5
  • Edge Support: 9
  • Pressure Relief: 7.5
  • Spine Alignment: 9.5
  • Responsiveness: 9 
  • Cooling: 8.5
  • Durability: 9 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.7/10


Casper Essential

Best for Kids

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.4/10
Customer Rating 4.6/5
Materials Memory foam
Firmness Medium-firm: 6/10
Trial Period 100 days
Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Price $595 for queen

Read our full Casper Essential mattress review.

Why We Love the Casper Essential

The Casper Essential is Casper’s most affordable and streamlined mattress model. Even though it classifies as a budget mattress, it doesn’t compromise on quality. Typically we would warn you that a queen mattress at the low price of $595 is likely a bust, but we’ve taken the time to lay on the Casper Essential ourselves and test it out. If no one told you the price, you would easily expect it to cost $1,000!

This three-layer mattress borrows elements from Casper’s original model providing pressure relief, breathability, and responsiveness from its first two foam layers. The bottom layer provides support and durability for the Essential.

Who is it Good For?

🧸Kids

The Casper Essential is a truly great option for a kid’s mattress. As your child grows, you don’t want to spend too much on a mattress that they’ll outgrow, but you also don’t want to slack on a poor quality bed. Your child’s sleep is critical to their growth and development, so we know parents care about finding a good mattress for their child.

But we also know you’re looking for something that doesn’t cost an arm and a leg. The Casper Essential is the perfect answer to this. It’s affordable and a good quality bed. Plus, if you choose a big enough size (like a full) your child can grow into it and you can take advantage of its full 7-10 year lifespan.

See the best mattresses for kids.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9 
  • Trial Period: 9 
  • Return Policy: 10
  • Warranty: 9 
  • Setup: 8.5
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 9

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 7.9
  • Edge Support: 9.25
  • Pressure Relief: 7.75
  • Spine Alignment: 8
  • Responsiveness: 7.5
  • Cooling: 7
  • Durability: 6.5

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.4/10


Saatva Solaire

Best for Seniors
Saatva Solaire mattress in a bedroom

Quick Facts

MA Score 8.7/10
Customer Rating 4.9/5
Materials Pillow top, Talalay latex, gel-infused memory foam, vulacanized air chambers
Firmness 50 custom firmness levels
Trial Period 120 days
Warranty 15-year limited warranty
Price $2,695 for queen

Read our full Saatva Solaire mattress review.

Why We Love the Saatva Solaire

The Saatva Solaire is an inflatable airbed that you can customize to meet your exact preferences. We know there’s no bed that’s one-size-fits-all since everyone has different desires in a mattress, but with the customization capabilities of the Solaire, truly anyone can make this bed what they want!

The Solaire comes with an adjustable base so you can elevate your upper or lower body to your desired height. Even cooler is the Solaire’s upper flex capabilities. The Solaire is only split halfway down the middle, so sleepers can select their preferred elevation without disturbing your partner. Plus, there’s a full body massage function! The Solaire will give you a custom and luxurious sleeping experience.

Who is it Good For?

👴🏻Seniors

The Saatva Solaire is a great choice for seniors who have specific needs in a mattress. For one thing, it’s adjustable. An adjustable mattress allows seniors to move easily climb in and out of bed. Plus, sleeping in a slightly elevated position may be beneficial to some of the medical conditions seniors experience as they age.

The customizable comfort is also important to seniors whose bodies are aging. As preferences change, you can adjust the bed to meet your desired comfort level.

See the best mattresses for seniors.

MA Score Breakdown

 

Customer Experience

  • Shipping: 9.5
  • Trial Period: 10 
  • Return Policy: 8 
  • Warranty: 10 
  • Setup: 9.5
  • Customer Service: 9
  • Social Impact: 5

Mattress Performance

  • Motion Transfer: 9
  • Edge Support: 8.5
  • Pressure Relief: 8 
  • Spine Alignment: 8 
  • Responsiveness: 8
  • Cooling: 8.75
  • Durability: 9 

Total Mattress Advisor Score: 8.7/10


How We Chose the Best Mattresses

At Mattress Advisor, we personally test every mattress that’s reviewed in our Mattress Lab using a 14-point testing procedure. Here’s a look at the work that went into selecting the top 10 mattresses that you see in this guide.

120+

Mattresses tested and compared

1,200+

Hours spent testing products

12

Experts and specialists consulted

2,500+

Customer reviews analyzed


Comparison Chart

Now that you’ve learned more about each mattress, you can compare them all at once in our chart below.

Mattress Award Standard Price (queen) MA Score (out of 10)
Leesa Hybrid Best Overall $1,799 9.4
Nectar Best Value $699 8.7
Saatva Best Luxury $1,358 8.4
Leesa Original Best for Side Sleepers $999 9.3
Brooklyn Signature Best for Back Sleepers $949 9.1
Layla Best for Stomach Sleepers $899 8.8
Casper Wave Best for Back Pain $2,295 8.7
Puffy Lux Best for Pressure Relief $1,795 9.3
Helix Midnight Luxe Best for Couples $1,795 8.9
Brooklyn Aurora Best for Hot Sleepers $1,699 8.9
Big Fig Best for Heavy People $1,699 8.8
Awara Best Eco-Friendly $999 8.8
Tuft & Needle Mint Best Memory Foam $895 8.9
DreamCloud Best Hybrid/Innerspring $999 8.7
Casper Essential  Best for Kids $595 8.4
Saatva Solaire Best for Seniors $2,695 8.7

 


What is the Best Mattress? 

If you’re here reading this, it’s because you’re wondering what the best mattress out there is. With over 175 mattress brands all competing for your attention, you probably wish we would tell you which is actually best. Unfortunately, like all things in life, it’s not that simple. 

The best mattress varies for everyone depending on preferences, body type, lifestyle, and more. There are tons of different factors that come into play when finding the right mattress for you. 

You could narrow your options down by type; for example, deciding if you want a memory foam, innerspring, latex, or hybrid mattress. Or you could navigate the vast world of mattresses by your preferred sleeping position (i.e. the best mattress for side sleepers, stomach sleepers, back sleepers). Depending on the type of sleeper you are, you may even have certain lifestyle needs to meet such as being heavier weight, a hot sleeper, or part of a couple that will be sharing a bed. 

The point is, there are dozens of ways you could slice this question. While we want to make mattress shopping as easy as possible for you, we can’t just direct you to one particular bed that will please everyone. But we can help you navigate through your shopping journey based on the factors that matter most to you. You can explore our mattress guides to help lead you to the bed of your dreams. 

How to Evaluate a Mattress

So how can you actually tell whether a mattress is one of the best or not, especially when you can’t physically see it and touch it while online shopping. Well, one option is to trust third-party review sites like ourselves. The other option is to spruce up your own mattress knowledge. 

To be fair, you don’t buy a mattress too many times in your life, so it isn’t something we expect you to have an expertise on. We’ll help you figure out what positive signs to look for in a mattress and what to note as a red flag. 

What Makes a Mattress Good? 

Our review process can provide helpful guidelines for what factors make a good mattress. These include motion transfer/isolation, responsiveness, edge support, pressure relief, spine alignment, cooling, and durability. 

To the average person, some of these terms may sound like mumbo jumbo, so we’ll explain it in layman’s terms. A good mattress will be able to offer you the contouring comfort your body needs to rest in its neutral position, while providing a proper balance of support for the sake of durability and maintaining a comfortable sleeping position.

That’s why all these factors matter in evaluating a mattress. If spine alignment looks poor on a mattress, you’ll wake up with aches and pains and the undue stress on your joints can lead to long-term issues. The same goes with pressure relief. You don’t want your shoulders, hips, or knees, to become too sore because your mattress doesn’t balance comfort and support. 

Some factors may matter more than others; for example, motion transfer is more important for those who share the bed with a sleeping partner. And while responsiveness is something everyone should want in a mattress, it’s more important for combination sleepers who move around frequently during the night and need their mattress to be able to respond.

Overall, a good mattress shouldn’t be too extreme. Avoid anything extremely firm or extremely soft. The same is true for price points. Anything that’s unbelievable cheap is most likely cutting corners. 

What Makes a Mattress Bad?

We’ve walked you through the important things that you want to see in a mattress, but keep in mind that there are a number of things you should avoid when mattress shopping. In general, you’ll want to stay away from the extremes.

Take a look at some of the warning signs we’ve outlined below.

Too soft or too firm

Even if you know you prefer something very soft or very firm, it’s a good idea to stay away from the extremes on the firmness scale (1s or 10s). There’s less of a chance you’ll find comfort on an extremely soft or extremely firm mattress over time.

Very cheap, very expensive 

Mattresses under $500 (for a queen size) usually mean that you’re getting a lower quality mattress. That could be fine for a guest bedroom or temporary sleeping space, but be aware that cheaper mattresses won’t last you as long. And while you can certainly buy a quality mattress around $1,000, there are always going to be options that cost more and promise more. 

We’ve actually seen mattresses that cost upwards of $20,000 – and while yes, it’s likely a great mattress, it’s definitely not worth that much. 

No trial period or return policy

If you buy a mattress that doesn’t offer a trial period or return policy, you’re essentially stuck with that mattress or will lose some or all of your money if you decide it’s not the right fit for you. This is especially important when purchasing a mattress online, but just because you tested a mattress in a store doesn’t mean it’s going to feel the same when you sleep on it for a while. 

Your body also needs different amounts of support in your wake state vs. your sleeping state – so it’s almost impossible to know if a mattress is going to work for you until you sleep on it for a few weeks.

No warranty

When investing in a product as significant as a mattress, it’s important to make sure you’re purchase is protected. There’s always a chance for a manufacturing flaw or error with the way the mattress was made. 

Warranties allow you the opportunity to send back your mattress and get a new one within a certain time period (usually 10-20 years). A warranty is also a good sign that a mattress company can stand by their quality and in the off-chance that your mattress wasn’t properly made, they’ll promise to fix it.

Poor customer reviews

While it’s usually a good idea to disregard the most extreme reviews, if you come across a mattress that has a significant number of poor reviews (or an overall lower customer satisfaction score) it’s usually a good idea to stay away from those. 

It’s a good idea to get a sense of the total number of customer reviews and see how many of them are not favorable. If you’re looking for a particular feature in a mattress (i.e. cooling), and you find that a decent amount of customers are complaining about sleeping too hot, then it’s probably time to move on.

Too thin

Typically mattresses will range from 9-12” depending on the brand and model. Mattresses thinner than this likely won’t provide the level of cushion and support that you need for quality sleep.


We get that choosing your mattress is a big deal – it’s where you dream, love, recharge, binge watch your favorite Netflix shows and nurse yourself back to sleep during flu season. By this point, we hope we’ve helped you select the best mattress for you. At the very least, we hope you have a better understanding of what’s out there and what to look for in a mattress.

If you still have unanswered questions, leave us a comment below and we’ll do our best to help you out.

Sweet dreams!

FAQs

How much does a new mattress usually cost?

The average price of a bed-in-a-box mattress that you can buy online is around $1,000 for a queen-size bed. You can find budget mattresses in the $600-$700 range. Luxury hybrid mattresses may cost a bit more and typically sell for $1,500-$2,000.

If you shop in a traditional mattress store, expect to pay upwards of 40% more on your mattress. You’ll be paying for things like commission and overhead, as opposed to online retailers who sell directly to the consumer.

If I buy a mattress online and don't like it, can I return it?

Before purchasing an online mattress, we recommend thoroughly reading many mattress reviews, although if you buy a mattress and decide it isn’t right for you, you typically can return it. Almost all online mattresses come with a trial period that typically lasts a few months. During this time, you have the luxury of sleeping on your new mattress in your own home to decide if it’s right for you. If not, you can return it for a refund. The company you purchased from with usually come pick up the mattress from your home and arrange for a donation to a local charity. If your mattress came in a box, you don’t have to worry about trying to get it back in.

How long should my mattress last?

Mattresses can last anywhere from 5-10 years depending on the quality and materials, as well as how much use the mattress gets. After 10 years, your mattress has accumulated dust mites and bacteria after regular use and it is good for your health to invest in a new one.

What if my partner and I want different things in a mattress?

It’s common for couples to have different sleeping styles and preferences when it comes to choosing a mattress. If your preferences vary greatly, look for something in the middle in terms of firmness, support and “hug.” Other important factors to consider when sharing a bed are motion transfer and cooling.

If I buy a new mattress, will I need a new box spring or bed frame too?

If your existing box spring or bed frame is in good condition, you may still be able to use it with your new mattress. The important thing to consider is whether your mattress foundation is compatible with the type of mattress you have. For example, memory foam mattresses will need more supportive foundations than innerspring mattresses. Using the appropriate foundation can have a big impact on how your mattress feels.


About Mattress Advisor

The team at Mattress Advisor has spent 1,200+ hours personally testing, evaluating, comparing, and reviewing mattresses. Our proprietary scoring system takes into account 14 scientific and human elements to provide you with the information you need to navigate the murky waters of mattress shopping.

Here at Mattress Advisor, we’re relentless in our pursuit to help you live your best days by getting your best night’s sleep. Have a question? Drop us a line. We’re happy to help.


Comments (618)

  1. MAYBE IT SHOULD BE CLEAR THESE ARE ALL NEW MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX COMPANIES IGNORING ALL TRADITIONAL BRANDS

  2. How long will a quality mattress last for?I just payed $2500 for mine and hoping for a minimum of ten years.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *