Best Online Mattresses of 2023
Oct 4th, 2022 •
Online mattress shopping has a lot of advantages, including lower prices and longer trial periods than you’ll find with many store-bought mattresses. It’s also much easier to compare mattresses by price, material, and sleep position—and you can shop without pressure from over-eager salespeople.
To simplify the process even further, our Mattress Advisor experts have chosen the 10 best online mattresses of 2023. You can also check out the advice in our online mattress buying guide to help you find the best online mattress deals and choose the right mattress for your best night’s sleep.
Our Top Picks for Best Online Mattress
- Best Innerspring Mattress – Saatva Classic
- Best Memory Foam Mattress – Nectar
- Best Mattress for Back Pain – Casper
- Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers – Helix Midnight
- Best Firm Mattress – Layla
- Best Mattress for Side Sleepers – Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
- Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers – Tuft & Needle
- Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers – WinkBed
- Best Mattress Under $500 – Allswell
- Best Mattress for Heavy People – Purple
Why You Can Trust Mattress Advisor
We hold ourselves to the highest standards of integrity in our product reviews and other content by incorporating real customer feedback, empirical testing and objective evaluations. Our results and recommendations are never influenced by the commission we may receive from brands, and products we receive are never guaranteed a positive review.
The expert review team at Mattress Advisor has tested over 150 different beds including memory foam, latex, hybrid, innerspring, and pillow top mattresses. We look at 14 criteria covering everything from pressure relief and responsiveness to ease of set-up and customer service.
Best Innerspring Mattress
- Back and stomach sleepers who like a firm surface
- Seniors with back pain
- Eco-conscious consumers
The Saatva Classic is more than an innerspring mattress. The combination of supportive coils, pressure-relieving memory foam, and three firmness options makes it a great choice for a wide range of sleeping positions and body types.
- The Saatva’s 10/10 spine alignment and 9/10 pressure relief scores are especially promising for side sleepers and people with back, neck, or hip pain
- You can choose one of three firmness options: plush soft (3/10), luxury firm (6/10), or and firm (8/10)
- Free white-glove delivery, 365-night sleep trial period, and lifetime warranty
- The Saatva Classic isn’t an ultra-luxury bed, but prices might be out of range for budget shoppers
- 7.5/10 motion transfer score is a red flag for couples who are easily disturbed when their partners toss and turn
- All Saatva mattresses are made to order, so delivery can take up to 21 days
Read our full Saatva Classic mattress review.
Best Memory Foam Mattress
- Couples who share a bed
- Budget-conscious consumers
- First-time online mattress shoppers
The original Nectar is one of the best memory foam mattresses we’ve reviewed, as well as being the company’s best seller. With consistently competitive pricing, it’s also a good pick for shoppers on a budget.
- Affordable prices, lifetime warranty, and 365-night sleep trial make the Nectar a solid value mattress
- Motion transfer and responsiveness scores of 8.5/10 match up well with couples and restless sleepers
- Edge support (9/10 score) is exceptionally high for an all-foam mattress and good for sleepers who like to stretch out
- The Nectar’s spine alignment performance (7.5/10 score) could be problematic for people with neck pain
- With a 7.5/10 cooling score, the original Nectar is less than ideal for hot sleepers (a common issue with memory foam mattresses)
- Off-gassing could leave “new mattress smell” lingering for up to several hours after you unpack the Nectar
Read our full Nectar mattress review.
Best Mattress for Back Pain
- Those with back pain
- Combination sleepers
- Couples who share a bed
The original Casper has long been one of the best bed-in-a-box mattresses you can buy. This all-foam bed has a medium-firm feel (6/10) that offers a comfortable fit for most back, side, and stomach sleepers.
- The Casper’s scores for pressure relief (8.5/10) and spine alignment (9.5/10) are promising signs for people with back pain
- Combination sleepers and restless sleepers will appreciate the perfect 10/10 responsiveness score
- The Zoned Support layer is designed to provide targeted support for the shoulders, hips, and lower back
- Hot sleepers should note the 7/10 cooling score, the only testing category where the Casper underperforms
- A number of competitors offer more generous terms than Casper’s 10-year warranty and 100-night sleep trial
- As is typical with memory foam mattresses, the Casper will need a few hours to air out after unpacking
Read our full Casper mattress review.
Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers
- Hot sleepers
- Back sleepers and stomach sleepers
Materials and design help make the Helix Midnight hybrid an effective cooling mattress. The innerspring coil layer provides airflow and the open-cell memory foam is designed to give body heat an exit route.
- The 9/10 score for spine alignment and 8.5/10 score for pressure relief are encouraging signs for people with back pain
- With a 9/10 motion transfer score, the Midnight could provide more restful nights for couples who toss and turn
- For an extra $199, you can boost the cooling with an optional GlacioTex Cooling Cover
- The 7/10 firmness matches up well with back sleepers, but some side sleepers might find it too firm
- In terms of being accessible, we found that Helix customer service has room for improvement (7.5/10 score)
- The 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty are good, but several competitors have more generous policies
Read our full Helix Midnight mattress review.
Best Firm Mattress
- Back sleepers
- Growing kids who need a soft and firm side
- People with back pain who need firmness
Soft side: 4-5/10; Firm side: 7/10
The Layla memory foam model is a rare dual-sided mattress and one of the best flippable mattresses on the market. If you prefer a firm bed, though, just keep it firm side up (7/10).
- Dual-sided versatility means you can flip sides to match your changing needs (softer for injuries or pregnancy, firmer for back problems, and so on)
- The Layla mattress can also be a good choice for children who need to transition from softer to firmer as they grow
- The Layla scores 9/10 for edge support and pressure relief and 9.5/10 for responsiveness
- As a 100% foam mattress, the Layla might not provide adequate support for people over 230 lbs
- Like many all-foam beds, the Layla underperforms in cooling (7.5/10 score)
- For the ideal foundation, your options are more or less limited to platform beds with slats spaced no further than 3 inches apart
Read our full Layla mattress review.
Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
- Side sleepers and combination sleepers
- Those with back pain
- Lightweight sleepers
Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm
The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid has three firmness options, but side sleepers will get the best results with soft (4/10 on firmness scale) or medium (6/10). Just sink in and let the top foam layers go to work.
- The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid’s 9.5/10 pressure relief score is a promising sign for side sleepers with back pain or joint pain
- An airflow-friendly innerspring layer helps this mattress perform quite well in cooling (8.5/10) score
- Thanks to a 9/10 edge support score, the Brooklyn Signature lets you spread out and enjoy the whole surface
- Lighter side sleepers might find that an all-memory foam bed provides more of a contouring feel
- The 7.25/10 motion transfer score is a red flag for couples prone to waking up their partner by tossing and turning
- Prices for the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, aren’t extravagant, but frugal shoppers can find comparable beds for less
Read our full Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress review.
Tuft & Needle
Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers
- Combination sleepers
- Hot sleepers
- Couples with different sleep positions
The Tuft & Needle’s Adaptive foam is designed to prevent deep body impressions. What it means for combination sleepers is that you’re less likely to sink too far into the surface, making it easier for you to change sleep positions during the night.
- At $995 for a queen-size, not counting sales or discounts, the Tuft & Needle is a regular on our roundup of best budget mattresses
- You’re sure to appreciate the 8.75/10 motion transfer score if you have a restless sleep partner
- Its 6/10 medium-firmness makes the Tuft & Needle compatible with most sleeping positions
- Side sleepers and people with shoulder pain could find it doesn’t provide enough pressure relief (7.75/10 score)
- The 7.25/10 edge support score is a red flag for people who roll toward the edge in their sleep
- Hot sleepers should take note of the 7/10 cooling score, which is low even for an all-foam mattress
Read our full Tuft & Needle mattress review.
WinkBeds Luxury Firm
Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
- Stomach sleepers of any size
- People with back pain
- People who sleep on the edge of the bed
Medium firm: 6/10
Choose the right firmness option and the WinkBed can help you face some of the challenges of being a stomach sleeper. You need a firmer than average mattress, and the WinkBed offers more firmness in two varieties.
- The Firmer option (7.5/10) helps keep your hips from sinking too far into the mattress and putting pressure on the lower back and midsection
- The innerspring layer provides sturdier, more buoyant support than an all-foam mattress
- The WinkBed also has a PLUS firmness option (8/10) specially designed for heavier people
- The WinkBed performs below expectations in pressure relief (7.75) and motion transfer (6.4/10)
- Budget shoppers should note that the WinkBed is priced at the low end of the luxury price range
- With full sizes and larger weighing well over 100 pounds, setting up the WinkBed is a two-person job
Read our full WinkBed mattress review.
Best Mattress Under $500
- Budget shoppers
- Hot sleepers
- Heavyweight sleepers
Medium - 5/10
Are you in the market for an affordable hybrid mattress? The Allswell brand offers mattresses with respectable quality ratings for less than $500 for a queen size, along with budget-friendly perks like free shipping.
- You can get an Allswell mattress in the popular queen size for $449, with 0% APR financing available through Affirm
- Solid scores for pressure relief (8.25) and spine alignment (8.5), plus 5/10 firmness, match up well with side sleepers
- A 9/10 motion transfer score points to more restful nights for couples
- Although the medium 5/10 firmness will appeal to side sleepers, most back sleepers and stomach sleepers need something firmer
- With a 7.5/10 responsiveness score, the Allswell might not give combination or restless sleepers enough ease of movement
- The Allswell’s scores for durability (7/10) and edge support (7.75/10) could mean it’s less resistant to sagging than other mattresses
Read our full Allswell mattress review.
Best Mattress for Heavy People
- Plus-size sleepers
- Those with back pain
- Hot sleepers
Despite lacking a coil system, the original Purple has firmness and features that make it a good choice for heavier sleepers. Purple’s grid system is designed to equally distribute weight and provide a feeling of floating on top of the mattress.
- Estimated weight capacity is 600 lbs total, or up to 300 lbs on each side of a mattress shared by two people
- The 9.5/10 score for spine alignment and 8.5/10 pressure relief score are encouraging signs for people with back pain and joint pain
- The 9/10 mattress durability score is in line with the needs of heavier sleepers
- Restless sleepers and combination sleepers should take note of the 7/10 responsiveness score
- Stomach sleepers might experience too much sinking in the hip area, which could throw off spine alignment
- The 10-year warranty and 100-night sleep trial are pretty standard, but some competitors offer lifetime warranties and 365-night sleep trials
Read our full Purple mattress review.
How to Find the Best Online Mattress
Buying a mattress online for the first time can be a daunting experience. How do you know what you’ll prefer without trying it out first? We’ve got the answers you need in our guide to buying an online mattress.
In this guide, we’ll cover:
- Where to Buy a Mattress Online
- Pros and Cons of Online Mattress Buying
- What to Consider When Buying an Online Mattress
- How to Tell if an Online Mattress Retailer is Trustworthy
Where to Buy a Mattress Online
The internet landscape has no shortage of options, but you’ll have an easier time if you focus on the most relevant places. The best places to buy an online mattress include:
- Brand websites operated by mattress companies
- Online marketplaces affiliated with multiple brands
- Retail websites like Amazon.com or Walmart.com
Each one has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Although direct-to-consumer websites provide a more-or-less straight line between buyer and seller, many online marketplaces offer something valuable in their own right: independent reviews written by experts who have personally tested the products.
How the Purchasing Process Works
If you’ve ever ordered a T-shirt from Amazon or even used a “build your own pizza” menu, the process of actually buying a mattress online won’t seem that complicated. It’s all a process of using your mouse (or your finger, if you’re using a phone or tablet) to select just the mattress you want.
- When you’re on the page that features the mattress you’re interested in, you’ll typically see a menu that lets you begin by choosing which size you want. Use that menu to see the price and dimensions for your preferred mattress size. In some cases, you’ll have the option to add a special mattress accessory such as a cooling cover or “bundle” your mattress purchase to include pillows, sheets, or a foundation.
- Once you’re done shopping, you can add your purchase to your online “cart” and proceed to the billing and shipping information. All reputable websites help protect your personal information with secure payment platforms. You can tell you’re on a secure site if the address includes “https” at the beginning (“s” for secure) and a padlock icon in the address bar.
- If you have questions or get stuck, don’t worry. Many online mattress brands make it easy to get help by letting you open a “chat” window with a customer service representative.
Pros and Cons of Online Mattress Buying
Buying a mattress online has its benefits, but some people just prefer the in-person shopping experience. Here’s a look at how online shopping compares with shopping at a brick-and-mortar store:
- Buying directly from the manufacturer is usually less expensive, since it doesn’t involve salesperson commissions, showroom fees, and other costs.
- Online mattress purchases typically offer longer trial periods and free returns.
- You won’t have to deal with the two extremes of salespeople (either you can’t find one or the one who is present uses pressure tactics).
- You won’t get to physically test out a mattress before buying, although longer sleep trials provide some leeway on this point.
- Online shopping doesn’t offer the same personal touch of asking questions to a salesperson face-to-face (or haggling a lower price).
- If the mattress you want is in stock at a brick-and-mortar store, you could be able to take it home or have it delivered the same day.
What to Consider When Buying an Online Mattress
When shopping for a new mattress online, the first step is understanding the right type of mattress for you. Price could be your main concern, or you might want a mattress that matches up with your sleeping position. Maybe you need a mattress designed for a medical condition such as back pain or sleep apnea.
In any case, online mattress sellers have products to fit a wide range of needs and preferences. Here’s a list of things to consider before you start shopping:
Materials and Design
Most mattresses you can buy online are made from foam, innersprings, latex, or a combination of these materials (known as a hybrid design). The materials that make up a mattress, and how they’re put together, often affect which type of sleepers they’re compatible with.
- Foam—Most foam mattresses use memory foam or polyfoam, or sometimes layers of both. Memory foam is a material that hugs the body’s curves and is exceptional at relieving pain at pressure points like the hips and shoulders. Some foam mattresses use polyfoam, which is less supportive than memory foam but doesn’t retain body heat as much.
- Innerspring—The traditional innerspring mattress has been around for a long time and is still the most popular type of bed. It contains a core layer of coils that provide firm, springy support. Around this layer of coils are a variety of foams and soft materials designed to enhance comfort and longevity.
- Latex—Latex mattresses are made using natural or synthetic latex. These beds range from medium to medium-firm and have a slightly springy and supportive feel. Just like foam beds, latex mattresses are quiet and great at isolating movement.
- Hybrid—Hybrid mattresses are made using a combination of mattress materials, usually including innerspring coils and layers of memory foam or latex. By using various combinations of materials, mattress companies can create mattresses that work for most everyone. However, hybrid mattresses are usually costlier and heavier than their memory foam or innerspring counterparts.
Most online mattresses mention their firmness levels prominently. The firmness scale runs from 1 (ultra-plush) to 10 (ultra-firm), with most mattresses falling in the 5-6 range.
Mattress firmness matters a great deal, especially for people with back pain, people who are heavier than average, and others who need a firmer mattress. Certain firmness ranges are also considered ideal for different sleeping positions:
- Soft to medium-firm for side sleepers (4-6)
- Firmer for back sleepers and combination sleepers (6-7)
- Very firm for stomach sleepers (7-9)
On the most basic level, however, firmness is about comfort: How firm or soft does your ideal mattress feel?
Your Sleeping Position
- Side sleepers—When you sleep on your side, your hips and shoulders need a soft, plush surface to sink into that also relieves pressure and keeps the spine in a neutral alignment. Medium-firm mattresses that offer good pressure relief for their hips and shoulders are good for most side sleepers.
- Back sleepers—Sleeping on your back is the best position for spine alignment and pain relief. Most back sleepers will feel the best on a medium-firm mattress, which is the most common type of mattress on the market. Although all types of mattresses will work for back sleepers, go with latex or innerspring beds if you prefer a firmer feel and memory foam or hybrids if you like more cushion.
- Stomach sleepers—In most cases, stomach sleepers need to sleep on a firm mattress. The trouble with sleeping on your stomach is that your hips sink into the bed, throwing your spine out of alignment. While there’s no way to completely avoid poor alignment when you sleep on your stomach, a firm mattress is your best bet.
- Combination sleepers—If you change sleeping positions during the night, a medium-firm, highly responsive mattress can make your movements easier and more comfortable. You’ll also need substantial pressure relief from your mattress, since a combination of sleeping positions will put a strain on multiple pressure points.
One of the most common reasons that people wake up in the middle of the night is due to overheating. Sometimes, keeping your bedroom at an ideal temperature for sleep just isn’t enough and you need an assist from your mattress.
If you’re someone who struggles with sleeping hot, you want to be sure to find a mattress for hot sleepers that’s designed to sleep cool. Innerspring, latex, and hybrid mattresses all do a good job at keeping the sleeping surface cool. Some memory foam mattresses are designed to sleep cool, but they still tend to run hotter than your average innerspring mattress.
Buying a mattress online is a great way to save money. Because mattress retailers cut out the middlemen and sell the mattress directly to you, the consumer, these mattresses are less expensive than similar mattresses at a showroom.
For budget shoppers, memory foam and innerspring mattresses are typically the least expensive options. You can find fairly high-quality beds in these categories for as little as $800 for a queen size. Latex and hybrid mattresses are often more expensive, with high-quality queen mattresses generally costing $1,500 or more.
- Best Budget Mattresses
- Best Mattresses for the Money
- Best Mattresses Under $1,000
- Best Mattresses Under $500
Most mattress warranties are straightforward. The manufacturer promises to cover repair or replacement costs for certain defects as long as the warranty is in effect. However, damage related to improper use can void your warranty—if you don’t use the recommended foundation, for example. Take time to read the warranty so that you know what’s covered and what isn’t. The typical warranty lasts 10 or 15 years, even though some companies offer warranties that last as long as you own the mattress.
Although virtual shopping doesn’t involve giving a mattress the physical lie-down test, online mattresses typically come with lengthy trial periods. The industry standard is about 100 days, but a growing number of mattress brands have expanded their sleep trials to a full year. In most cases, the company will ask that you allow a minimum of 30 days to break in your new mattress.
Delivery and Returns
Free delivery is a common perk for online mattress buyers, which means the seller handles the cost of shipping. Most mattress brands also pay for shipping charges if you return the mattress. Just to be on the safe side, read the terms and conditions on the seller’s website to look for any exceptions.
Some online mattress companies also offer white glove service, included free or at an extra cost. With white glove service, the people who deliver your mattress will also set it up in your bedroom.
How to Tell if an Online Mattress Brand is Trustworthy
Smart shoppers looking for great deals on mattresses have several ways to judge the trustworthiness of online retailers. Things to look for include:
- No-risk sleep trials, comprehensive multi-year warranties, and customer-friendly return policies
- A large number of positive customer reviews (Casper, for example, has more than 20,000 customer reviews with an average 4.4/5 rating)
- Secure transactions, typically spelled out and accompanied by a padlock icon, that guarantee safe handling of payments and personal information
- Transparency (how clearly the company states its prices, policies, and contact information for customer service)
Every item on this list is a good indicator that you’re dealing with a reputable business. If you encounter an online mattress seller that seems to be long on smoke and mirrors but short on integrity, trust your judgment and look elsewhere.
Recap: Our Top Picks for the Best Online Mattress
|Saatva||Best Innerspring Mattress||9/10|
|Nectar||Best Memory Foam Mattress||8.7/10|
|Casper||Best for Back Pain||8.7/10|
|Helix Midnight||Best for Hot Sleepers||8.7/10|
|Layla||Best Firm Mattress||8.8/10|
|Brooklyn Signature||Best for Side Sleepers||8.8/10|
|Tuft & Needle||Best for Combination Sleepers||8.7/10|
|WinkBed||Best for Stomach Sleepers||8.6/10|
|Allswell||Best Mattress Under $500||8.2/10|
|Purple||Best for Heavy People||8.4/10|
Shopping for a mattress online is a great way to save money and enjoy perks like a lengthy trial period. The right mattress depends on your personal needs, so be sure to consider your sleeping position, budget, and personal preference when buying an online mattress.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best online mattress brand?
Although no single product will be ideal for everyone, there’s a strong case to be made for Casper as the best brand of online mattress. We looked at Mattress Advisor scores for each Casper model reviewed on our site and the average score came to 9.1/10—a figure that strongly indicates all-around quality. Other top brands include:
Most online mattress companies have solid reputations. What type of mattress you want, how much you’re willing to spend, and what perks are important to you will dictate which brand best fits your needs.
What's the best time to buy a mattress online?
You generally find the best deals on mattresses during holiday sales, when companies offer exclusive discounts to online shoppers. You’ll often see instructions to use “promo codes”—usually a word/number combination such as LABORDAY2022—at online checkout. Major holiday sales take place on:
But with Mattress Advisor’s exclusive discounts, every day of the year is a good day to buy a mattress online. Check out our mattress reviews for the beds you’re interested in and click on the “Check Price” button to see current prices and specials.
Do all online mattresses come in a box?
Most online mattresses are bed-in-a-box products, which involves compressing and rolling the mattress so it fits in a cylinder-shaped box for shipping. One of the exceptions is Saatva, which delivers its mattresses the traditional way and offers free white-glove delivery service that includes unpacking and set-up. The bed-in-a-box concept has its critics, who hold the opinion that the compression process degrades the quality of the materials.
Best Bed-in-a-Box Mattresses
Say goodbye to lugging your new mattress up the stairs and through tight doorways. Check out our top picks for the best mattresses in a box in 2021.
Best Cheap Mattress for Your Budget
Find the perfect affordable and inexpensive mattress for your budget using this comprehensive guide. Shop mattresses all affordably priced around $700.
Best Mattresses of 2023
We've reviewed over 150 beds to select our best mattress of 2023. See our top picks for side sleepers, hot sleepers, kids, seniors, and more.