Best pacifiers

By Katie Dyal

It’s the middle of the night, and you can’t get your baby to sleep. What do you do?

Well, you should seriously consider investing in a pacifier. Pacifiers have helped parents soothe their babies for decades now. They are comforting because babies love to feel the faux nipple in their mouths, as this reminds them of their mother and adds security to their new lives. If you would like to find the best pacifier for your baby, we’ve got you covered. Here are six of our best picks for pacifiers, as well as some helpful tips for when you don’t know which one to choose. 

The best pacifiers

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Itzy Ritzy

Best overall

Stylish and breathable

Never has there been more stylish pacifiers than these. 

Keep your baby subdued with this two-pack of pacifiers that are made with food-grade and safe silicone. Your baby will be able to suck on it while breathing well, thanks to the built-in breathing holes located on the body of the pacifier. In case of any bumps or falls, these pacifiers are designed with collapsible handles that keep your baby’s mouth safe from harm. The nipple is soft and natural feeling and is perfect for babies of all ages. 

Why we love it:

  • Comes in a two-pack 
  • Ventilation holes for breathing
  • Collapsible handle
  • Natural-feeling nipple
  • Made with food-grade silicone

Best orthodontic pacifier

Soothing and natural

While you can’t fool babies all the time, this pacifier does a pretty good job.

Soothe your crying baby with a pacifier shaped like the real thing, with a scooped bottom that allows for natural sucking. This pacifier is made for healthy jaws, as it reduces pressure on your baby’s jaw and teeth for proper alignment. The heart shape design will fit under their nose perfectly and includes two breathing holes. This pacifier is recommended for babies six to 18 months old.

Why we love it:

  • Orthodontic and promotes jaw alignment
  • Natural nipple shape
  • BPA-free
  • Glows in the dark for easy finding
  • Dishwasher safe
Philips AVENT

Best calming pacifier

Squishy and soft

Bond with your baby with this calming pacifier.

This type of soft and squishy pacifier is used in hospitals all the time to soothe newborn babies. The total silicone design acts as a natural nipple and allows you to insert your finger in the middle for parent bonding time. The pacifier is BPA-free and safe for continuous use through babyhood. It supports your baby’s jaw and disinfects in a pot of boiling water. 

Why we love it:

  • BPA-free silicone
  • Doctor tested
  • Soothing and soft
  • Sterilizes in boiling water
  • Finger insertion hole for bonding time

Best glow in the dark pacifier

Easy to find and symmetrical

Never struggle to find your baby’s pacifier in the night ever again. 

This pacifier features a glow in the dark body that makes those late-night wake-up calls a little easier. Your baby will stay comfortable sucking on these pacifiers and will love the symmetrical shape of the nipple. This pacifier is sterilizable via its microwaveable storage case and made for babies six months and older. 

Why we love it:

  • Glows in the dark
  • Features a curved body and breathing holes
  • Symmetrical nipple
  • Comes with a sterilization case
  • Comes in baby boy and girl colors

Best pacifier and toy combo

Fun and functional

Cheer your baby up with this extra fun pacifier. 

Your baby will love to be soothed and comforted with this plush toy pacifier. The pacifier is made with latex, BPA, PVC, and phthalate-free material and is recommended for babies who are newborn and up to six months old. You will be able to make your baby laugh and watch them fall asleep, cuddling their sweet giraffe friend attached to the end of the pacifier. 

Why we love it:

  • Features a plush animal
  • Easy to find and grasp
  • Made from chemical-free materials
  • Medical grade
  • For babies up to six months old
Dr. Brown's

Best contouring pacifier

Comfortable and lightweight

Your baby will look cute as a button in this butterfly-designed pacifier. 

Watch as the soft silicone pacifier shapes to your baby’s face and allows them room to breathe. This pacifier is constructed out of one piece of silicone, so it will never fall apart or break. It is lightweight and extra soft, which soothes babies even while they sleep. They are easy to clean, and you can wash them on the top rack of the dishwasher for sterilization.

Why we love it:

  • Dishwasher-safe 
  • Easy to find and grasp
  • Contours to baby’s face 

How to find the best pacifiers

Babies can’t tell you what they want in a pacifier, so you have to choose for them. If you are struggling with choosing the best pacifier for your baby, it’s okay. We want to offer you three tips, so you can invest int he best pacifier to soothe your baby.

Choose a natural-shaped nipple: Babies love pacifies, but have you ever known a baby to spit out the one they don’t like? One reason this could be is that babies love natural-feeling pacifiers that feel like their mothers. Even though they aren’t getting any food, babies like to suck on something that feels familiar to them while playing or sleeping. Choose a pacifier that is made with either a symmetrical nipple or an asymmetrical nipple that will calm your baby and keep them happy. 

Choose one-piece pacifiers: Pacifiers that are made with one-piece are ideal for mommy’s on the go. One-piece pacifiers ensure the baby stays comfortable and that the pacifier will never fall apart.

Choose pacifiers that sterilize well: Dropping your baby’s pacifier is inevitable. After all, babies are always moving along the ground and throwing nearby objects. Choose a pacifier that sterilizes in hot water, or better yet, comes with its own sterilization container, as some do. 


Pacifiers are ideal for subduing your baby when they are upset or trying to get them to sleep. They come in all shapes, sizes, and materials, and no two pacifiers are entirely alike. Hopefully, now you are confident in choosing the best pacifier for your little one. Now, you can watch your baby fall asleep on their own and get some rest yourself. 

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *