Best Pillow Filling

By Katie Dyal

Are you intrigued by adjustable pillows and want to add extra oomph? Are you looking to refill a pillow that’s falling flat? Maybe you’ve found a set of decorative pillow covers that you love, but don’t want to buy the full insert. Whatever the reason is, pillow filling can very well be your solution. 

There is a wide spectrum of pillow filling on the market, with options for every person and preference. These choices give you the opportunity to build your perfect pillow. Ranging from classic poly-fill to modern memory foam, this list will give you an idea of what’s out there on the market. These are our top picks for the best pillow filling.

The Best Pillow Filling

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Best Budget


The Fil Poly Pellets Weighted Stuffing Beads from Fairfield will fulfill your needs at a price that fits your budget. 

Having these poly pellets on hand is a great way to amp up the loft of your pillows. This unique filling brings something new to the table in terms of pillow stuffing. Little beads made of 100-percent polypropylene will add a comforting weighted feel to your pillows. Because of their small size, they also offer exceptional flexibility, which will make your pillow feel akin to memory foam or other conforming materials. This option is 100-percent non-toxic, and can even take a trip through the washer and dryer when enclosed in your pillow. Its pour-and-store feature allows you to use what you need efficiently and easily store what you don’t. With this purchase, you’ll receive a six-pound bag that’s currently being offered at the fraction of its original cost.


Best Luxury


Fairfield’s Original Poly-Fil Premium Box is a product that will fit your filling criteria. 

This option proves that sometimes the simple, traditional choice really is best. This box comes packed with a generous amount of 100-percent polyester fiber fill weighing in at 20 pounds. It’s our top pick for luxury due to its smooth consistency and unmatched resilience. It’s so strong and durable that you can even machine-wash it. This option holds pillow filling to a high standard; in fact, it is the standard. Fairfield’s Original Poly-Fil is widely considered to be the best of the best when it comes to polyester fiber fill. No flame retardants or chemicals are added – this product is all no-frills fluff of the highest quality. It is also hypoallergenic, meaning that you won’t have to worry about allergens hanging out around your pillows.

Workingfish’s Shredded Memory Foam with Foam Filling

Best Value


We don’t have a shred of doubt that you’ll love Workingfish’s Shredded Memory Foam with Foam Filling. 

This option provides conforming comfort while allowing you to make your pillow as lofty as you like it.  With this item, you’ll receive five pounds of shredded memory foam that is packed in a space-saving storage container. It is made of 100-percent polyurethane sponge that is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning that it upholds high standards of quality and safety. No added chemicals are used in the manufacturing of this product. It’s no problem if you don’t use it all right away. This foam can easily be stored for long periods of time in its stuffable storage bag. The elasticity of this foam also holds up excellently to extended wear once inside your pillow. This product’s achievement of combined comfort and durability make it an option definitely worth considering.

Xtreme Comforts

Best Memory Foam

Xtreme Comforts

The Shredded Memory Foam Fill Replacement by Xtreme Comforts hits all the marks when it comes to helping out your pillows. 

This CertiPUR-US memory foam is completely safe and doesn’t contain any flame retardants, phthalates, ozone depleters or other harmful substances. In addition, it provides a level of comfort in its cushioning that literally molds to your shape. You may love the feel of this foam so much that you’ll use it in other items around your home. This product by Xtreme Comforts also promises to provide a loftiness that is long-lasting and just fluffy enough. To add, it’s amazingly resilient and can be run through the washer and dryer without worry. With this option, you’ll receive a five-pound vacuum-sealed bag that makes storage easy and won’t harm the foam.

How to Find the Best Pillow Filling

There are many types of pillow filling these days, which gives you the option to build your own pillow experience. With that said, your preference can vary based on use and location. Once you decide on what you’re stuffing and what purpose that item will serve, you can then move onto factors of material, amount and durability. 

Material: Material is everything when it comes to pillow filling. This factor determines the kind of comfort and support you’ll be receiving from your pillow. Are you on a memory foam kick? Match your pillows to a sumptuous memory foam mattress

Amount: Do a little research on what amount is required based on the size of your pillow. Pro tip: you’ll be surprised at how much filling is needed to fill a pillow. When in doubt, size up. 

Durability: If you’re looking to stuff decorative pillows, this one is probably a non-issue. But if you’re looking for an option that will fill your bed pillows, durability is important. Make sure that the filling you choose can stand up to consistent wear.


Pillow filling may seem like a non-necessity, but it really can come in handy in a plethora of scenarios. Think of pillow fillings as comfort enhancers; who doesn’t want a little more of that? Treat yourself to a loftier sleep or mend a below-average pillow. Whatever the use, we encourage you to grab some of your own.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *