Best Plush Mattress Toppers

By Laura Mohammad

May 24th, 2022

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Whether you’re trying to bring new life to a mattress or are just starting out on the set-up of your bedroom, plush mattress toppers are always a good idea. Quality of sleep is so important, yet sometimes overlooked. By going the extra mile with a mattress topper, you are investing in your overall health and well-being. 

If you’re not sure where to look first, read this article carefully. Mattress toppers can range in their many factors, such as thickness, density, material, and more. They may even offer additional features that your mattress doesn’t. Do the proper research now so that you won’t be tossing and turning later. Discover our top picks for the best plush mattress toppers and what to look for when shopping for your own. 

Our Top Picks for the Best Plush Mattress Toppers


Best Budget


The oaskys Mattress Pad Cover will provide you with a fantastic level of comfort for about a third of the price of most toppers. 

Sporting a fitted sheet style, this option feels fluffy on top while staying secure to your mattress. Made of 100-percent cotton, this hypoallergenic option will feel pillow-soft as you rest up. Cotton also makes this product very breathable, keeping you cool and this topper is free of odor. It’s high-quality diamond quilt stitching locks in a filling of alternative microfiber down while dispersing it evenly for a consistent balance in comfort. This is a great option for travel; you can create a comfy situation wherever you go. It can roll up incredibly easily into a compact size. 


Best Luxury


The KARRISM Extra Thick Mattress Topper is undoubtedly a luxury item that you’ll love. This option is packed with snow down alternative fill, making it ultra-plush and twice as thick as most mattress toppers. 

Crafted from 100-percent cotton, it is excellent at allowing airflow and regulating body temperature. A baffle box stitching design will keep fill from shifting as you sleep, ensuring that this product will look and feel new for years to come. Whether you’re looking to improve your mattress or take your bed situation over the top, this product by KARRISM will make you very pleased. Stretch this deep-pocket fitted topper over your mattress to literally feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud in no time.


Best Value


LUCID makes a Foam Mattress Topper that will have you rethinking what you need in a night’s rest. In this option, you’ll find a four-inch-thick foam topper that conforms to your body instantly and exceptionally. 

Gel memory foam makes up this product and is known to be the most effective foam at cradling the curves of your body. When it does this, it is actually dispersing your weight evenly and thus providing support while allowing pressure relief. A unique feature of this topper is it’s special ventilated design. Tiny holes throughout the foam allow space for air to escape and odor to dissipate without compromising support.


Also Great


LinenSpa’s Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper will make you feel like you’re sleeping in the lap of luxury. 

This is a 100-percent polyurethane option and does a great job of taking care of you while you rest. By simply adding this layer of comfort to your bed, you can make strides in aligning your spine, relieving pressure, and balancing your body overall. This product is different from the rest in that it is infused with temperature-regulating gel beads. This advanced technology actually traps heat so that it can then distribute it properly. Gel beads also add to the general comfort level of this topper. 

What is a Plush Mattress Topper?

Is there a difference between a mattress topper and a mattress pad? The answer is a resounding “yes.” A mattress pad is usually a thinner mattress add-on that serves the main purpose of adjusting firmness. Mattress toppers are bigger, better versions of pads. They are thicker and aim to succeed on many levels such as comfort, firmness, and protection. Mattress pads are great, but they probably can’t transform your bed in the ways that toppers can if you have a firm mattress that you want to soften up.

There are many differences in the mattress topper family as well. The biggest variation lies in the material. Toppers can be made of anything from memory foam, to alternative down, to latex rubber, and anything in between. Comfort is the most important factor and greatly depends on your material preference, so start your search here.

What to Look For in Your Next Plush Mattress Topper

Where to begin; there are so many differences between mattress toppers, so you’ll need to carefully weigh out your pros and cons. Pro-tip; looking at material, density and thickness will help.

Material: If “plush” is what you’re after, softness is probably a priority. If that’s the case, cotton or down options are the obvious choice; however, certain foams can also rise to the occasion. The material you choose will be the most telling element of your topper. 

Density: Soft, medium, or firm? This really comes down to preference. However, if you’re having back problems, you might want to learn to like a firmer density. 

Thickness: The thickness of your plush topper will tell you how much your mattress will be affected by it. A more generous thickness will transform your bed; whereas, a thinner style will enhance it. 

Additional Features: Some of these options are infused with oils, textured surfaces, or ventilation pathways. You may learn that you want something in a mattress topper that you didn’t know you needed.


As you’ve gathered by now, impeccable comfort is the name of the game when it comes to plush mattress toppers. Comfort means something different for everyone, hence the vast selection in types of toppers. We hope that through this article you have found which type is right for you.