Best Soft Pillows

By Laura Mohammad

May 19th, 2022

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

It’s no secret that deep, healthy sleep is key when it comes to being our optimal selves during the day. In order to achieve that caliber of sleep on a nightly basis, you’ll want to put a little effort into choosing the best pillows and bedding products. Pick a pair of soft pillows that are extra nice to snuggle up to – after all, sleep depends on comfort. 

When you build a comfortable bed, you’ll fall asleep faster and also stay asleep longer. Nocturnal tossing and turning can steal quality hours away from your sleep time without you even realizing it. When you integrate soft pillows into your bed set-up, you’ll feel the difference of a sound sleep from the moment you wake up. Want to know our favorites? Keep on reading to find out our top picks for the best soft pillows.

Our Top Picks for the Best Soft Pillows


Best Budget

White Classic

The Bed Pillows for Sleeping by White Classic are a classic choice that will make for a super soft bed. These cloud-like pillows are filled with 100-percent polyester that contains hollow cluster fibers.

Hollow fibers create an airiness in your pillows, thus making for a very fluffy cushioning. These pillows are covered in 100-percent cotton that features a 235 thread count. Cotton is known for its excellent breathability and hypoallergenic properties, making it a great choice of material for your everyday pillows to wear. It will keep you cool and safe. These pillows are made in a standard size, measuring in at 20 inches by 28 inches. White Classic’s no-shift construction ensures that your pillow will never flatten out, maintaining a great balance of firmness and fluffiness. What’s more, this two-pack of hotel quality pillows are nice to your wallet as well.


Best Luxury

Dreaming Wapiti

Dreaming Wapiti’s Pillows for Sleeping are anything but basic. For starters, an incredibly soft blend of polyester and bamboo rayon make up the plush, quilted cover fabric. When it’s time for cleaning, simply remove the cover and throw it in the wash. 

The two-pack of pillows contains a filling of 100-percent premium quality memory foam that has been finely shredded. Because these foam strands are smaller, they disperse more evenly and allow for the most conforming effect possible. If you find yourself loving these pillows but wishing for a little more loft, Dreaming Wapiti will send you more filling free of charge. This way, you can add or remove filling to your liking whenever you’d like. The combination of these materials makes for a comfort that securely supports your neck and back while allowing enough air flow for temperature regulation. To really sleep in the lap of luxury, throw on a sleep mask to drift off into sublime slumber.


Best Value


The Hotel Collection Pillows by COZSINOOR will take you right to sleep without having to count sheep. This two-pack product features a 100-percent sateen cotton shell that is wonderfully breathable and cool to the touch. 

The body of these pillows are an ultra-plush down alternative filling that mimics the feeling of luxurious goose down. This down alternative contains hollow fibers, making for an extra fluffy pillow that will continue to stay that way after many uses. It allows for plenty of air flow without lacking in the density department. These materials together make for a hypoallergenic pillow that will rid your bed of dust mites, bacteria, mold, bed bugs and more. It’s also an excellent choice for someone who has very sensitive skin. Superior cushioning targets neck and shoulder pain without added pressure by sitting at the perfect level of loft. This option is currently available at a heavily discounted price, so don’t sleep on buying these pillows.


Also Great


The Bed Pillows for Sleeping by SUMITU will create a level of comfort that will put your current pillows in second place. These extra plush pillows keep a comfy level of loftiness that also provides ample neck and back support. 

This option is crafted out of allergy-proof fiber filling that stops dust, dander and other allergens in its tracks. Clumping won’t be a concern for as long as you have these pillows; no-shift construction guarantees that this two-pack of pillows will maintain a concentrated core and evenly dispersed cushioning. One cool feature about this set of pillows is that the entire product can be put through the washing machine. You won’t ever have to worry about your pillow retaining odors or picking up on dirt or grime past that may get through the cover. This incredibly durable product will remain fluffy as ever despite consistent washing and nightly use.

Soft Pillow Buying Guide

With so many options for pillows on the market, it’s helpful to have a buying guide that will steer you in the right direction based on your sleep style. Keep reading as we share some insight on what sleepers need from a pillow based on how they hunker down. 

Side Sleepers: If you lean towards sleeping on your side, you’ll need a pillow that can handle the pressure. Firm pillows are recommended for this sleep style; however, if firm density isn’t really your thing, you can opt for a soft pillow with an extra-high loft instead. 

Back Sleepers: Sleeping on your back is the most beneficial positioning when it comes to spinal alignment. But to do so, you’ll need to make sure you have the proper support. Go for a soft pillow that’s filled with memory foam – its conforming feel will keep your neck and shoulders right where they need to be. 

Stomach Sleepers: Soft pillows reign supreme when it comes to stomach sleepers. If you like to sleep face first, make sure the pillow you’re using is low-density and preferably flatter than the majority of its counterparts. 

Combination Sleepers: For combination sleepers, we recommend choosing soft pillows that are just as versatile as your sleep style. Go with the happy medium; that is, medium density and loft.

What to Look For in Your Next Soft Pillow

When you’re in the market for soft pillows, you may find yourself surrounded by too many options. At first glance, aren’t all pillows soft? But if you’re specifically looking for pillows that are low in density, we’ve got a few keywords that will help you make sense of your search. Material, density, and maintenance will land you where you need to be. 

Material: When it comes to material, comfort comes first. The most sensitive area of your skin will be making close contact with your pillow, so it needs to be comfortable. Also, pay attention to other perks like breathability or hypoallergenic options. When it comes to filling, the material used will tell you a lot about durability, and just how well a pillow will stand up to wear and tear. 

Density: This may seem obvious; however, it’s important to read the fine print on this one. Just because a pillow is described as “soft” doesn’t mean it’s on the softer side of density. 

Maintenance: Maintenance really varies from pillow to pillow depending on the material. Some can only be spot cleaned, while others can take a trip through the washing machine just fine. Check care instructions first to make sure you’ll be able to keep your pillows clean as recommended. For pillow maintenance in general, always outfit these bed cushions in quality pillowcases for added protection and comfort.


When it comes to pillows, not everyone should go for a medium or high-density option. Some people enjoy a super-soft, fluffy landing when it comes time for sleeping. The aforementioned options show that it’s possible to have the best of both worlds – these worlds being comfort and support.