updated May 2022

Brooklyn Bedding Signature vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Brooklyn Bedding Signature vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Deciding between the Nectar or Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress? Our comparison will help you make the right choice by putting these beds head-to-head.

Shopping for a new mattress? We’ll compare the Brooklyn Bedding Signature with the Nectar mattress so you can decide if the hybrid or memory foam mattress is a good fit. In our mattress comparison, we’ll examine how they performed during our in-house testing, their similarities and differences, price points, and more.


At a Glance

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty
brooklyn signature mattress

Brooklyn Signature

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.8/10

Summary

Responsive hybrid mattress

Firmness

Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm

Type

Hybrid: memory foam and pocket coils

Trial Period

120 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.7/10

Summary

Affordable quality mattress with excellent trial period

Firmness

Medium-firm: 5.5-6/10

Type

Gel memory foam

Trial Period

365 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty as long as you own the mattress

brooklyn signature mattress
nectar original mattress updated

Brooklyn Signature

Nectar

Customer Rating

MA Score

8.8/10

8.7/10

Summary

Responsive hybrid mattress

Affordable quality mattress with excellent trial period

Firmness

Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm

Medium-firm: 5.5-6/10

Type

Hybrid: memory foam and pocket coils

Gel memory foam

Trial Period

120 days

365 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Lifetime warranty as long as you own the mattress

Key Similarities

  • Sleeping Positions: The Brooklyn Bedding Signature and Nectar mattresses work well for side, back, and stomach sleepers
  • Edge Support: Both beds earned nearly perfect scores in our edge support test, great for couples who spread out or people who use the edges to get in and out of bed. 
  • Customer Service: Both mattress companies are known for their outstanding customer care and experience.  
  • Value: Both are bed-ina-box mattresses that offer high-quality beds at affordable prices

Key Differences

  • Mattress Type: The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a hybrid mattress made from proprietary polyfoam and innerspring coils. The Nectar is a memory foam mattress
  • Firmness Level: The Nectar is a medium-firm mattress with a firmness that rates a 6 on the 1-10 firmness scale. The Signature comes in multiple firmness options: soft (4), medium (6), and firm (8). 
  • Trial Period & Warranty: Nectar’s 365-night sleep trial and forever warranty are more generous than Brooklyn Bedding’s 120-night trial and 10-year warranty, although they both offer full refunds
  • Motion Transfer: Thanks to Nectar’s all-foam construction, it provides superior motion isolation when compared to the Signature mattress. Couples who share the bed tend to sleep more soundly on a bed with great motion isolation properties.
brooklyn signature mattress 1 e1511217599432

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Review Highlights

  • Multiple Firmness Options: This Brooklyn Bedding mattress comes in a soft, medium, and firm model, so you can choose the best firmness for you. 
  • Cushions Pressure Points: The Signature mattress earned a 9.5/10 in our pressure relief test, demonstrating its ability to cushion the body. This means pain relief for side sleepers with hip or shoulder pain. 
  • Good for All Body Types: Its 4” of comfort foam and 6” of coils offer the ideal balance for people of all sizes. Lightweight sleepers enjoy the plush feel of the soft and medium beds while heavier sleepers do well on the firm mattress
  • Cooling Technology: Cooling technology termed TitaniumGel, is found along the mattress surface for optimal temperature regulation. Paired with the breathability of innerspring coils and you have an excellent bed for hot sleepers. 
  • Many Mattress Options: Interested in a more luxurious Brooklyn Bedding hybrid? Read more about the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora, Brooklyn Bedding Sedona, Brooklyn Bedding Plank, and Brooklyn Bedding Bloom mattresses. Or check out the Bowery Hybrid for something even more affordable.
nectar original mattress updated

Nectar Mattress Review Highlights

  • Cradling Foam Feel: People who love memory foam tend to be fans of the enveloping feeling some memory foam mattresses offer. The Nectar mattress’s three foam layers deeply hug the body for a distinct memory foam feel. 
  • Great for Couples: With outstanding scores in our tests for both edge support and motion isolation, the Nectar is one of the best mattresses out there for couples. You can spread out and move around without waking your partner!
  • Generous Policies: With a year-long sleep trial return policy and lifelong warranty, Nectar clearly stands behind customer satisfaction. Even with such a long trial period, only 3% of Nectar customers return their mattresses! 
  • Responsive: The Nectar mattress won’t leave you feeling stuck like some traditional memory foam beds. Their proprietary foams are impressively responsive, which means they quickly adapt to your movements. 
  • Other Mattress Options: Check out the Nectar Premier and Nectar Premier Copper for an even more luxurious experience.

Size Comparison

When it comes to size, the both brands have similar dimensions. Brooklyn Bedding offers more size options, such as split California king and short queen. Nectar, however has a slightly thicker mattress height.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Nectar
Thickness 11.5” 12”
Twin 38” x 75” 38” x 75”
Twin XL 38” x 80” 38” x 80”
Full 53” x 75” 54” x 75”
Queen 60” x 80” 60” x 80”
King 76” x 80” 76” x 80”
California King 72” x 84” 72” x 84”

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Price Comparison

While both mattresses cost less than the average bed, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature is slightly less expensive than the Nectar at full price. It costs around $150 less for a queen-size bed. 

Keep in mind that the prices below reflect the full price. To receive an exclusive discount, check out our Brooklyn Bedding and Nectar coupons

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Nectar Original
Twin $699 $873
Twin XL $799 $1,043
Full $899 $1,298
Queen $1,249 $1,398
King $1,499 $1,698
California King $1,499 $1,698

Compare Feel and What’s Inside

In this section, we’re going to take an in-depth look at what makes up each of these mattresses. We’ll explore the differences and explain how they influence the sleeping experience. Then you’ll know which mattress is best for you! 

Inside the Brooklyn Signature Mattress

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a 5-layer hybrid mattress with three firmness options. You can choose from soft, medium, or firm based on your sleeping position and comfort preference. 

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s top layer is crafted from their proprietary polyfoam called TitanFlex. TitanFlex foam is engineered to offer similar pressure relief as memory foam with the ease of movement of latex foam. This means you won’t sink in the way that you will on the Nectar

The next foam layer is called VariFlex, which delivers further cushion while ensuring that you don’t sink in too far. The support core is made up of pocketed Ascension coils, which provide give and support in all the right areas. This breathable layer is one of the reasons why the Brooklyn Bedding Signature is cooler than the Nectar

Finally, a layer of high-density support foam balances the mattress and adds to its longevity.

Inside BB
  • Quilted Mattress Cover: Brooklyn Bedding uses a quilted mattress cover to support a cool night’s sleep.
  • Comfort Foam: The special TitanFlex foam acts like a memory foam and latex foam hybrid and is infused with TitaniumGel for a cool night’s sleep.
  • Transition Foam: This layer uses a proprietary VariFlex that balances cushion and support. 
  • Supportive Innerspring Coils: Pocketed coils provide support and responsiveness while limiting motion transfer
  • Base Layer: A high-density foam adds longevity and stability at the bottom of the mattress.

Inside the Nectar Mattress

The Nectar is a 3-layer memory foam mattress with a medium-firm feel. The top layer is made from a cooling gel memory foam layer. This layer has a distinct memory foam feel, so you’ll sink in and feel embraced by the mattress. This hugging sensation is different from the balanced feel that you’d experience on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature. 

The transition layer is made from a responsive polyfoam that balances the memory foam’s contouring effect. It’s this layer that’s to thank for how easy it is to move around on the Nectar. Unlike some memory foam beds, you’ll never feel stuck. 

The final layer is a high-density foam base that adds stability and edge support. Because this layer is made from motion-absorbing foam rather than coils like those found in the Signature mattress, it better isolates movement. 

nectar matttress layers updated
  • Quilted Mattress Cover: A cool, breathable poly-blend cover that’s soft to the touch covers the Nectar mattress.
  • Comfort Layer: Nectar uses a gel memory foam for optimal cushion and contouring
  • Transition Layer: This layer contains a responsive polyfoam for ease of movement. 
  • Base Layer: At the bottom, Nectar uses high-density polyfoam to provide durability and stability.

Compare Scores and Performance

We tested each of these beds at the Mattress Advisor lab. Take a look at the side-by-side comparison of how they performed. Both models, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature and the original Nectar, scored about the same overall. However, there are scoring differences in specific categories. For instance, the Nectar’s trial and warranty are better, whereas the Brooklyn Bedding Signature has strengths in pressure relief and cooling.

You can learn more about our review and scoring process here

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Nectar
Shipping 8 9
Trial Period 9 10
Return Policy 9 8.5
Warranty 9 10
Set-Up Test 8 8
Motion Transfer Test 7.25 8.5
Edge Support Test 9 9
Pressure Relief Test 9.5 8.5
Spinal Alignment Test 8.5 7.5
Responsiveness Test 8.25 8.5
Cooling Evaluation 8.5 7.5
Durability Evaluation 8.5 8.5
Customer Service Score 9 8
Social Impact Score 9 9
TOTAL SCORE 8.8/10 8.7/10

Motion Transfer

The Nectar mattress earned a high score in our motion transfer evaluation, demonstrating its ability to dampen motion before it spreads across the bed. Couples sleep more soundly on beds that isolate motion, and Nectar’s thick foam layers excel at this. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature earned a good score, but not as high as the Nectar

Pressure Relief

The Brooklyn Signature is one of the highest-scoring mattresses that we’ve tested when it comes to pressure relief. We found that our sleep testers experienced nearly zero areas of high pressure when lying on their sides, a position that often leads to excess pressure at the hips and shoulders. The Nectar also earned an excellent score in this test, but the Signature stands out as a top pick for side sleepers

Spine Alignment

The Brooklyn Signature outperformed the Nectar mattress in our spine alignment test. Supporting healthy spine alignment is important for everyone, but especially so for anyone who struggles with neck or back pain. Thanks to the support of innerspring coils and the contouring cushion of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s proprietary foam layers, it’s a great bed for people with back pain

Let’s Review: Which Is the Best Mattress?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature stands out with its pressure relief, multiple firmness levels, cooling properties, and spinal support. But the Nectar’s deeply cradling feel is perfect for memory foam mattress lovers. Thanks to its excellent motion isolation and edge support, it’s better than the Brooklyn Bedding Signature for couples. 

Other Brooklyn Bedding and Nectar Comparisons

best budget mattress

Still Deciding?

Ready to compare other mattresses against each other? Use our comparison tool to see how two different mattress models compare.