We’re leaving no stone unturned in this Tuft and Needle vs Brooklyn Signature mattress comparison. You’ll learn all you need to know about performance, comfort, construction, and pricing, plus our recommendations.
We’re leaving no stone unturned in this Tuft and Needle vs Brooklyn Signature mattress comparison. You’ll learn all you need to know about performance, comfort, construction, and pricing, plus our recommendations.
Shopping for a new mattress can be overwhelming, but the good news is that you’re comparing two well-loved, high-quality beds. Tuft & Needle is a newer company that specializes in memory foam mattresses and partners with Crate & Barrel and Lowe’s. Brooklyn Bedding has 25 years of mattress know-how and was one of the original bed-in-a-box mattress companies.
We got our hands on the original Tuft & Needle mattress and Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress. This comparison will help you get the feel for both mattresses, so you can choose the best bed for your needs.
Responsive hybrid mattress
Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm
Hybrid: memory foam and pocket coils
120 days
10-year limited warranty
Budget-friendly mattress for the average sleeper
Medium-firm: 6/10
Foam blend
100 days
10-year limited warranty
Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle share standard mattress sizes, although the Tuft & Needle Twin, Twin XL, and Full size mattresses are 1” wider. Also, the Brooklyn Signature mattress will either be 10” or 11.5” thick, depending on which firmness level you choose.
Brooklyn Bedding also offers custom and specialty mattress sizes, like Short Full (48” x 74”), Short Queen (60” x 74”), Olympic Queen (66” x 80”), Short King (72” x 75”), and RV King (70” x 74”, 70” x 80”, 72” x 80”).
Brooklyn Bedding | Tuft & Needle | |
Thickness | 10” or 11.5” | 10” |
Twin | 38” x 75” | 39” x 75” |
Twin XL | 38” x 80” | 39” x 80” |
Full | 53” x 75” | 54” x 75” |
Queen | 60” x 80” | 60” x 80” |
King | 76” x 80” | 76” x 80” |
California King | 72” x 84” | 72” x 84” |
Learn more about mattress sizes.
Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle manufacture all of their mattresses in the USA. Fewer transportation and middleman costs equate to lower prices for you; however, Tuft & Needle is considered to be the better value mattress – it’s priced between $100-$500 less than the Brooklyn Signature.
Additionally, Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle offer seasonal coupons, and you can apply for financing through both companies.
Brooklyn Bedding | Tuft & Needle | |
Twin | $599 | $350 |
Twin XL | $699 | $395 |
Full | $849 | $495 |
Queen | $999 | $595 |
King | $1,249 | $750 |
California King | $1,249 | $750 |
The Brooklyn Signature and Tuft & Needle mattresses have different constructions that create very different feels. Tuft & Needle is a simple 3-layer foam bed that has a quick response time, but not as much pressure relief, whereas the Brooklyn Signature is a foam and coil hybrid with lots of pressure relief and a plush, bouncy feel.
Take a look at how the Brooklyn Signature and Tuft & Needle mattresses compare across 14 performance categories. The total score at the bottom is a weighted average of all the category scores.
Brooklyn Bedding | GhostBed | |
Shipping | 10 | 10 |
Trial Period | 10 | 9 |
Return Policy | 10 | 10 |
Warranty | 9 | 9 |
Set-Up Test | 8 | 8.5 |
Motion Transfer Test | 7.25 | 8.75 |
Edge Support Test | 9 | 7.25 |
Pressure Relief Test | 9.5 | 7.75 |
Spinal Alignment Test | 8.5 | 8.5 |
Responsiveness Test | 8.25 | 8 |
Cooling Evaluation | 8.5 | 7 |
Durability Evaluation | 8.5 | 8 |
Customer Service Score | 9 | 10 |
Social Impact Score | 9 | 8 |
TOTAL SCORE | 9.1/10 | 8.7/10 |
Our motion transfer test is a way to measure how well a mattress prevents disruptions from traveling across the mattress surface. Both mattresses scored above average in this category, but the Tuft & Needle does a better job of motion isolation than the Brooklyn Signature, so it’s a better choice for couples and light sleepers.
Edge support is often an underrated mattress quality, but it’s especially important if you need to utilize the full width and length of your mattress, or if you often find yourself sitting on the edge of the bed.
The Brooklyn Signature mattress scored significantly higher than the Tuft & Needle for edge support, although Tuft & Needle still scored above average. We recommend the Brooklyn Signature for those concerned about sinking or rolling off the side of the bed.
The Brooklyn Signature also outperformed the Tuft & Needle mattress in the category of pressure relief. Again, both mattresses scored above average, but the Brooklyn Signature is definitely the better choice for side sleepers.
Stomach sleepers need a combination of pressure relief and spinal alignment, and since both mattresses received the same score for spinal alignment, the Brooklyn Signature is cumulatively the better choice.
Back sleepers need the least amount of pressure relief, but it is still an important factor, particularly if you tend to start the night on your back and rotate to your stomach or side.
The Brooklyn Signature mattress is a noticeably cooler mattress than the Tuft & Needle, due in part to the breathable pocketed coil layer and gel infused foam.
The graphite and ceramic beads in the Tuft & Needle mattress definitely add a cooling element, but not as much as the cooling features in the Brooklyn Signature.
Side and stomach sleepers get better pressure relief on the Brooklyn Signature soft or medium mattress. Back sleepers will like the T&N or Brooklyn Signature firm mattress. Couples get better motion isolation with T&N. Hot sleepers will sleep cooler on the Brooklyn Signature. Budget shoppers save more with T&N.
Shoppers who want an in-person feel before buying can do so in select states. Brooklyn Bedding has showrooms and retail partners in Arizona, Utah, Texas, New York, Montana, Minnesota, and Illinois. Tuft & Needle has showrooms in Arizona, California, Oregon, Texas, North Carolina, Washington, and Kansas.
If you aren’t able to visit a showroom, you still get free bed-in-a-box delivery and a sleep trial. Brooklyn Bedding customers get 120 nights, and Tuft & Needle customers get 100 nights. Both mattresses are high-quality and perform well, so choose the one that best suits your sleeping position, lifestyle, and budget.
If you still need to narrow down your options and eliminate some options, check out our mattress comparison tool.
Compare Mattresses
Comments (0)