The Original Casper Pillow Review

Check out our review and learn how the Casper Pillow is perfect for all sleep styles.

By Loren Bullock

Aug 15th, 2022

Are you a side sleeper? A stomach sleeper? A back sleeper? How about a combination sleeper who switches positions during the night? Finding the right pillow for your sleep position is just as important as the right mattress.

Casper has a pillow that adapts to every sleep style: the Original Casper Pillow. Want the breakdown to know whether it belongs on your bed? We’ve got you covered.

✔️Customer Rating: 4.5/5
✔️Mattress Advisor Score: 7.8/10
✔️Type: Down Alternative Pillow
✔️Free Shipping
✔️1-Year Limited Warranty
✔️30-Night Sleep Trial

Save up to 40% on Select Mattresses + 50% on Select Bedding

Overview: Like the Casper Original Mattress, the Casper Original Pillow has something for everyone. Since it comes with a two-pillow design, you can choose to remove the inner pillow to make it even flatter or keep it as is for a heavenly loft.

Continue reading to find out if the Casper Original Pillow fits your needs based on its materials, product details, and Mattress Advisor testing scores.

Who is the Casper Original Pillow Best For?

Casper Original Pillow is best for: Casper Original Pillow may not be best for:
  • Back sleepers
  • Those that like down alternative pillows
  • Budget shoppers
 

  • Memory foam lovers
  • People who prefer firmer pillows
  • Plus-sized sleepers

How We Scored the Casper Original Pillow

When reviewing pillows, we rate each factor on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being exceeds expectations and 1 being has significant room for improvement. To reach our final score, we calculate a weighted average from all 5 categories. Read more about our review process here.

Mattress Advisor Test Score (Out of 10)
Temperature Regulation 8.5
Support 7.5
Responsiveness 7.5
Durability 7.5
Construction 8
⭐Total Score for the Casper Original Pillow: 7.8/10⭐

Casper Original Pillow Performance Highlights

✅ Pros

  • Fluffy and Comfortable: Did I mention that this pillow feels like sleeping on a cloud? Because the fill is evenly distributed, it shapes to your head like memory foam, but is much softer.
  • Supports Combo Sleepers: I found comfort in every lounge position with this pillow. Its shape adaptability is exceptional, especially for sleepers who are all over the place, prone to tossing and turning.
  • Trial and Warranty Period: Casper offers a 30-night risk-free trial. If you commit to the pillow, you also take home a limited 1-year warranty.
  • Available in Target Nationwide: If you don’t want to worry about the different variables that come with delivery, the Casper Pillow is in stock at Target. On your next Target run, check it out for yourself!

❌ Cons

  • Pricey: The Casper Pillow acts as a luxury pillow, and is certainly priced like one. $65-$85 for one pillow of this fill is a little steep.
  • Polyester Content: Although the cover is 100% cotton, the polyester content in the fabric lining and fill could cause static buildup and reduce overall breathability.
  • Constant Care Needed: While the fluff is one of this pillow’s most outstanding features, in order to keep it up, they suggest daily fluffing. Otherwise, you can kiss the puff goodbye.

What’s Inside the Casper Pillow?

If you’re wondering what’s inside the Casper Pillow, the short answer is another pillow! That’s right, Casper has created a pillow-in-pillow design.

The inner pillow is filled with a siliconized polyester microfiber fill to give your head and neck comfort and support. This design also means the pillow is responsive to your movements and can quickly adjust to your movements. These fiber clusters also make the inside resistant to clumping. The outer pillow is lined with polyester fabric, making it soft and fluffy.

Tying it together, the outer layer is wrapped in a breathable 100 percent cotton cover. The breathability makes this pillow pretty cool instead of trapping the heat from your head.

Special Features

Along with being able to conform to any sleep style and offering great neck support, the Casper Pillow has some other pretty cool special features:

It Sleeps Cool: Sleep hot? You don’t have to worry about that with this pillow. That 100 percent cotton cover is made with a percale weave, which basically means the fabric is breathable. With the added air flow, the heat radiating from your head isn’t trapped, giving you a cool night’s sleep.

It’s Adjustable: The pillow in a pillow design isn’t just for fun: it allows you to customize how you sleep. Side sleepers may prefer the loft. But if you want something flatter (I’m talking to you, stomach sleepers), then you have the option to remove the inner pillow using the zipper on the side. For something more firm, just use the inner pillow; for something more fluffy, just use the outer pillow.

It’s Easily Washable: Caring for your pillow is one major thing that extends its life, and the Casper Pillow is machine washable, making care a free at-home practice. The Casper website has explicit, step-by-step washing instructions, so there is no confusion on what to do. Just unzip the outer pillow, take out the inner pillow, zip it back up, and toss them both in the washing machine. (Make sure you place it in the dryer with some clean tennis balls or the dryer balls of your choice to keep it fluffy.)


Sleep Experience

Lucky for me, I get to take the Casper pillow home and try it for myself.

The Casper Pillow comes in a cylindrical cardboard container. Inside, the pillow is rolled up and wrapped in plastic. Once the pillow is released from the plastic, it unrolls naturally and slowly begins to puff up.

To help the process along, I did some mild fluffing, and the results were instantaneous. Casper’s Pillow rose to full size almost immediately and was ready to be slept on.

The minute my head hit the pillow, there was a pretty deep sink: my head was cradled on all sides. I can only really compare it to one of those fluffy hotel pillows you wish you could take home. The comfort was comparable to sleeping on a feather down pillow (you know, without the feathers poking you). I guess that’s why they call it a down alternative: all the great feel of a feather pillow with none of the guilt.

When it comes to sleeping positions, I’m a stomach/side combination sleeper, and it certainly adapted to both. The pillow is easily malleable and adjusts to whatever loft I need it to be. It’s so soft that one morning, while side sleeping, I woke up cuddling it.

Though I couldn’t force myself to sleep on my back, I did spend two hours before bed lying on it and reading with no resulting neck pain.


Product Information

Casper Original Pillow Sizes, Dimensions, and Pricing

Size  Dimension Guesset Price*
Standard 18″ x 26″ 2″ $65
King 18″ x 34″ 2″ $85

*Prices listed are standard without sales or Mattress Advisor exclusive discounts. Click below to find the best price for the Casper Original Pillow.

Purchase Details

POLICY DETAILS
Delivery Free shipping, ships within 1-2 business days
Trial Period 30-night sleep trial
Warranty 1-year warranty
Return Policy Free returns during the trial period
Financing None available

Sleep Trial and Warranty

Casper offers a 300-night sleep trial on their pillow during which you can return it for free. They also include a 1-year limited warranty. 

This warranty is available to any customer in the U.S. and only protects against manufacturer defects. To claim this warranty, simply send Casper the pillow and proof of purchase. No shipping costs apply.

Shipping and Returns

The Casper Pillow is manufactured in China but made in the United States. Shipping is free, excluding Alaska, Hawaii, Yukon Territory, Northwest Territory, and Nunavut. Returns are free as well if you are returning from the U.S. and Canada. 

You can expect them to ship within 1-2 business days. For holidays, or other difficult delivery days, keeps tabs on your tracking number for estimated delivery time. But if you don’t want to wait, head over to your local Target.


Final Breakdown

The Casper Pillow covers just about every sleep style. It has the fluffiness and the softness of a feather down with the support of a memory foam pillow

Casper Original is for you if you enjoy a plush, cushioning sleep experience, not so much if you prefer a firm-feeling pillow. But with easy care and a 30-night sleep trial, there isn’t much to lose if you want to give this unique pillow a try.

FAQs

Yes, Casper recommends fluffing the Original Pillow daily to keep it looking pristine. The pillow’s fill is designed to be revived back to its original puffiness after a quick fluff.

To clean the Casper Original Pillow, unzip the outer pillow and remove the inner pillow. Then zip the outer pillow back up and place it in your washing machine. Casper advises washing with cool water and mild detergent on a gentle cycle. Run the rinse cycle twice and tumble dry low with dryer balls.

The Casper Original Pillow has an inner core filled with low-friction, silky fibers. These contour to your head and give springy support. The pillow also has an outer layer filled with the same fibers as the inner core to give the pillow additional cushioning.


By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.