Casper Pillow vs MyPillow Comparison

Shopping for a new pillow? We put Casper and MyPillow side-by-side to see which is better for you.

By Loren Bullock

Aug 31st, 2022

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

The Casper Pillow is lightweight, cool, and incredibly soft. The MyPillow is customizable with a contouring foam feel. Which one is best for you?

In this review, we’re going to compare two of the most popular pillows you can buy: the Original Casper Pillow and the MyPillow Classic. These pillows are made from different materials that create unique sleeping experiences. As such, you’ll easily know which one is best for you by the end of this article.

Casper Pillow MyPillow
Material Siliconized polyester microfiber Shredded polyurethane foam
Best For
  • Hot sleepers
  • Combination sleepers
  • Those who like soft pillows
  • Every sleep position
  • Those who like supportive pillows
  • All body shapes and sizes
Price Range $65-85 $39.98

Key Similarities

  • Both are machine washable and dryable
  • The Casper Original Pillow and MyPillow Calssic come with a trial period
  • Both are made in the United States
  • Both have a soft, breathable 100% cotton cover

Key Differences

  • The Casper Pillow is made from fluffy down-alternative microfiber and the MyPillow is made from moldable shredded foam
  • MyPillow comes in four loft levels, while the Casper Pillow only comes in one
  • The Casper Pillow has gussets for better fill distribution
  • The Casper Pillow sleeps cooler thanks to its breathable weave
  • Casper offers free shipping and free returns during their 100-night trial period; with MyPillow, there’s a shipping fee that’s non-refundable, and to return the pillow you’re responsible for return shipping

Compare Construction and Feel

The Casper Down Alternative Pillow

The Original Casper Pillow is a plush down alternative pillow whose microfiber fill resembles the feel of a luxury hotel pillow. Down alternative pillows are one of the best pillows for people who like the fluffiness and comfort of down, but would prefer a hypoallergenic or cruelty-free alternative. 

Related: Best Down Pillows

What sets the Casper Original Pillow apart from other microfiber pillows is its unique pillow-in-pillow design. An inner pillow adds reliable support while an outer layer is incredibly light and fluffy for squishy comfort. No need to layer pillows for the ultimate balance of cloudlike feel and neck support. Plus, with a gusset along the pillow’s perimeter, you can rest easy knowing the fill will stay in place all night long. 

The Casper Pillow is plush, lightweight, and breathable. It’s easy to fold or mold to your ideal shape, and its versatility works well for combo sleepers who need a pillow that works in multiple sleeping positions. Thanks to the breathability of the cotton cover with a percale weave, this is a comfortable pillow for those who sleep hot. 

Casper’s siliconized polyester microfiber fill is formulated to resist clumping, providing years of like-new comfort. However, the Casper Pillow requires daily fluffing if you want it to retain its original shape and feel. 

The Customizable MyPillow

MyPillow is a shredded polyfoam pillow that’s fluffy and moldable. Its foam fill achieves the balance of cushiony comfort and reliable support that has made the memory foam mattress popular. 

Related: MyPillow Mattress Review

The MyPillow is customizable, coming in fout different loft sizes that suit every body shape and sleeping position. The fill level influences the firmness and feel of the pillow. Here’s a breakdown of the four MyPillow options.

  1. Yellow (Medium-Soft): The lowest polyfoam fill level creates the softest and thinnest pillow. Because the foam compresses with body weight, even the softest MyPillow is medium-soft. 
  2. White (Medium): A moderate fill level results in a pillow of average loft and firmness, best for the average sleeper. 
  3. Green (Firm): With a high fill level, the Green MyPillow is relatively firm and lofty enough for those who like a robust pillow. 
  4. Blue (Extra-Firm): A generous shredded foam fill level ensures that those who typically need to stack pillows find what they need in just one pillow. Because there is so much foam, it compresses with weight for an extra-firm feel. 
    • Best for side sleepers with broad shoulders who need an extra-thick pillow for support. 

Thanks to its foam support and various fill levels, the MyPillow Classic offers superb neck support. Sleepers with neck pain may find relief thanks to the personalized loft and firmness.

MyPillow also comes in a MyPillow Premium option. The Premium pillow has gusseted sides that help to keep the foam evenly dispersed. For those who prefer a loftier pillow, the Premium offers superior support and comfort.

How They Work for Side Sleepers

Side sleeping requires the thickest, most supportive pillow. This is because the neck needs to stay in line with the spine. Too flat of a pillow can lead to neck discomfort and pain, as well as poor sleep. 

MyPillow is one of the best pillows for side sleepers. The Green and Blue pillows are lofty enough to keep side sleepers’ necks in line with their spines. To choose the right pillow size, use the “Find Your Fill Level” tool on the MyPillow site. Using your gender, sleeping position, and T-shirt size, MyPillow can help you choose the fill level that will work best for you. 

The Casper Pillow works for side sleepers, particularly those who prefer an ultra-soft pillow. The combination of a firmer inner layer and soft outer layer balance support with comfort. However, the Casper Pillow has an average loft, and most side sleepers need a pillow with an above-average loft.  

How They Work for Back Sleepers

Both of these pillows are excellent for back sleepers. The Casper Original Pillow’s mixture of fluffiness and support cradle and head in a way that supports healthy spine alignment. And with four loft options, every back sleeper can find a MyPillow suitable for their body size and preferences. 

How They Work for Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers have unique pillow needs. In order to keep the neck from bending backward, it’s best to sleep with no pillow or one that’s extraordinarily thin. 

The thinnest (yellow) MyPillow is designed with stomach sleepers in mind. The compressed foam creates a thin, supportive base for the head and neck. 

The Casper Pillow is a good choice for stomach sleepers because it boasts three pillows in one. There’s the original pillow, the firmer inner pillow, or the plush outer pillow. Every stomach sleeper should be able to find an option that works for them. 

Compare Sizes and Prices

Both the Casper Pillow and MyPillow come in standard-size pillows, although their exact dimensions differ slightly. Casper also offers a king-size pillow.

Original Casper Pillow MyPillow Classic
Standard 18” x 26”

2” gusset

18.5” x 26”
King 18” x 34”

2” gusset


As for price point, both of these pillows fall in the luxury pillow category. The Casper pillow costs less and shipping is free with Casper, but not with MyPillow

Original Casper Pillow MyPillow Classic
Standard $65 $39.98
King $85 N/A

Which Is the Best Pillow For You?

The Original Casper Pillow and MyPillow Classic are luxury pillows with vastly different feels. The Casper Pillow is a down alternative made from ultra-soft microfiber. With its unique pillow-in-pillow design, it provides cloudlike softness with a touch of support that works for most sleepers.

The MyPillow Classic is a shredded foam pillow that comes in four fill levels that range from thin and soft to thick and firm. Because foam becomes firmer when it’s condensed, the MyPillow Classic is best for those who prefer a supportive pillow.