updated September 2022

Casper Select vs Casper Mattress Comparison

Casper Select vs Casper Mattress Comparison

One is Casper’s Costco exclusive and the other is Casper’s flagship mattress. See how they match up in our Casper Select vs. Casper Original mattress comparison.

Casper is one of the mattress industry’s bed-in-a-box pioneers and has long been a source of sleep products that deliver quality and affordability. Two of their most budget-friendly options are the Costco-exclusive Casper Select and the brand’s flagship mattress, the Casper Original.

Which one is the better choice for your sleep profile and budget? Keep reading to see how they fare when they go head-to-head in our mattress comparison.


Casper Select vs Casper Original Overview

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty
Casper Select Mattress

Casper Select

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.8/10

Summary

Great motion isolation, affordable price

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Type

Memory Foam

Trial Period

90 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.7/10

Summary

Universal firmness mattress for the average sleeper

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Type

Memory foam

Trial Period

100 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Casper Select Mattress
casper original hero

Casper Select

Casper

Customer Rating

MA Score

8.8/10

8.7/10

Summary

Great motion isolation, affordable price

Universal firmness mattress for the average sleeper

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Medium-firm: 6/10

Type

Memory Foam

Memory foam

Trial Period

90 days

100 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

10-year limited warranty

 

Key Similarities

  • Price: The Casper Select and Casper Original mattresses are affordable and great options for budget-friendly shoppers or those looking for a reasonably priced guest bed.
  • Firmness: Both mattresses are medium-firm (6/10 on the firmness scale), meaning they can support all types of sleeping positions.
  • Edge Support: The Casper Select and Casper scored higher than normal for memory foam mattresses in our edge support evaluation, making them great for those who spread out in their bed.
  • Sleep Trial & Warranty: While the Casper Original has a 100-night sleep trial, the Casper Select has a 90-day return window as a product sold through Costco. Both mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty from Casper.

Key Differences

  • Size Options: While the Casper mattress comes in traditional sizes, Casper offers its Select only in full, queen, king, and California king sizes.
  • Buying Process: The Casper Original mattress is available on Casper’s website, but the Casper Select is only available via Costco for its store members.
  • Layers of Foam: The Casper Select has an extra pressure-relieving foam layer, giving your body more support and an added inch of comfort.
  • Responsiveness: While the Casper Select scored an impressive 8.5/10 in our responsiveness test, the Casper Original earned a perfect 10/10, making it a better choice for those wanting ease in moving around.
Casper Select Mattress

Casper Select Mattress Review Highlights

  • The Casper Select is one of Casper’s most affordable mattresses, making it a great option for those on a budget or looking to buy a low-priced bed for a guest room or dorm.
  • With four layers of foam, the Casper Select excels in isolating motion so that your sleeping partner’s movements are less likely to disturb you.
  • You can easily keep this mattress looking fresh thanks to its hand-stitched zip-off cover, which you can throw in the wash.
Updated Casper Mattress

Casper Original Mattress Review Highlights

  • Earning spots on our best memory foam mattress and best mattress for combination sleepers roundups, the Casper Original Mattress is a great choice for shoppers wanting the contouring feel of memory foam feel without the sensation of sinking in too far and feeling stuck.
  • The Casper Mattress works great for average-weight sleepers of all sleeping positions thanks to its medium-firm feel.
  • Its zoned support makes it good for those with back or shoulder pain since it does a great job of keeping your spine in a neutral alignment.

Compare Sizes

The Casper Select and Casper Original come in similar mattress sizes and dimensions. Since the Casper Select is an extra inch thick, it may be a better option for side sleepers who need extra cushioning.

Casper Select Casper Original
Thickness 12″ 11″
Twin N/A 38″ x 75″
Twin XL N/A 38″ x 80″
Full 53″ x 75″ 53″ x 75″
Queen 60″ x 80″ 60″ x 80″
King 76″ x 80″ 76″ x 80″
California King 72″ x 84″ 72″ x 84″

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Compare Prices

Though the Casper Select and Casper both come at affordable prices, the Casper Select costs a few hundred dollars less than the Casper. Keep in mind that you need a Costco membership, which costs up to $120 per year, to buy this mattress. Casper also offers regular sales and discounts for its flagship mattress.

Size Casper Select Casper Original
Twin N/A $895
Twin XL N/A $995
Full $649.99 $1,195
Queen $749.99 $1,295
King $949.99 $1,695
California King $949.99 $1,695

Compare Design

Understanding what goes into each layer of your mattress is important so that you know how it will feel. Both the Casper and Casper Select are all-foam mattresses with very similar design and firmness levels.

The Casper Select is a four-layer mattress made entirely of CertiPUR-US certified foam. Its first layer consists of a breathable open-cell foam that helps promote airflow. The core of the mattress provides pressure relief and consists of a high-density foam layer and zoned transition foam. Finally, it has a durable support foam to support the entire mattress.

Like the Select, the Casper starts with a breathable top layer and also uses CertiPUR-US certified foam. In its core is a zoned support layer with three ergonomic zones to provide spine alignment. The last layer consists of a durable base to help resist sagging.

Casper Select Mattress

Inside the Casper Select Mattress

  1. Breathable Top Layer: An AirScape foam layer with tiny holes to allow airflow across the surface.
  2. Pressure-Relieving Foam: The second foam layer provides pressure relief to major buildup areas, such as the hips and back.
  3. Zoned Support: This unique Casper layer provides ergonomic benefits and helps keep your spine in a neutral position.
  4. Dynamic Support Foam: The final foam layer is thicker than the rest so that it can support the entire mattress.
Updated Casper Mattress

Inside the Casper Original Mattress

  1. Breathable Top Layer: Casper’s AirScape foam helps circulate air and promotes breathability at night.
  2. Zoned Support: This comfort layer contains three ergonomic zones to give targeted support and proper spine alignment.
  3. Durable Support Foam: A base layer helps prevent sinking and gives added support to both you and the bed.

Compare Mattress Advisor Scores

With near-identical overall scores, the Casper Select and Casper Original performed pretty similarly in our mattress lab. See how each mattress did in our various evaluation categories.

Casper Select Casper Original
Shipping 8 8
Trial Period 8 8
Return Policy 8 8
Warranty 8 8
Set Up 9 8
Motion Transfer 9.5 8
Edge Support 9 9.5
Pressure Relief 9 8.5
Spine Alignment 9 9.5
Responsiveness 8.5 10
Cooling 7.5 7
Durability 8 8
Customer Service 9 9
Social Impact 8.5 8.5
TOTAL SCORE 8.8/10 8.7/10

Responsiveness

The Casper Original scored a perfect 10/10 in our responsiveness evaluation, making it the prime candidate for a combination sleeper who switches their positions throughout the night. The Casper Select also scored high in this category, with an 8.5/10, but if you want a surface that’s easy to move around on, the Casper Original is your better option.

Motion Transfer

While sleeping with a partner can be nice when it’s cold, feeling their every movement ripple through the mattress can leave you feeling steamed. Couples need a mattress that limits motion transfer so that their sleep isn’t interrupted by their partner’s tossing and turning.

Earning a near-perfect 9.5/10 in our motion transfer test, the Casper Select’s extra foam layer does a great job of isolating movement. The Casper also did well in this category, earning an 8/10. Either mattress would be great for couples, but especially light co-sleepers should consider the Casper Select.

Spine Alignment

Both the Casper and Casper Select scored high in our spine alignment test thanks to their zoned support layers. Those with back or neck pain will likely find relief from either of these mattresses since it helps promote a healthy neutral alignment.


Which Is the Best Mattress for You?

Determining which mattress is best for you depends on your sleeping position, body type, budget, and a host of other factors. Use the information in this comparison to view these mattresses in the context of what matters to you most.

Sleeping Position

As medium-firm mattresses, both the Casper Select and Casper work well for most sleeping positions. Back sleepers will get great spine alignment thanks to their zoned support layers and side sleepers will find pressure relief in their shoulder areas. We also think both mattresses are great for combination sleepers since they scored high in responsiveness, particularly the Casper.

If you’re a stomach sleeper, you may want to find a firmer mattress that’s more supportive for your hips. Check out our best mattresses for stomach sleepers for a better option.

Sleep Environment

Finding a mattress that isolates your partner’s movement is important if you sleep with your significant other or a pet. The Casper Select received a near-perfect score for motion transfer, making it the better option for couples. However, the Casper still performed pretty well in this category, earning an 8/10.

Another important factor to consider when buying a mattress is whether it will do a good job of maintaining an ideal temperature. Once again, the Casper Select did slightly better than the Casper but both performed pretty average for cooling. Since these are both all-foam mattresses, they won’t keep you as cool as a traditional innerspring or hybrid mattress. If you’re a hot sleeper, consider one of Casper’s hybrid models, like the Casper Hybrid.

Budget

At this point in your mattress search, you’ve probably been drawn to Casper thanks to its high-quality, affordable mattresses. While both the Casper and Casper Select have affordable prices, the Casper Select is the better option for those on a tight budget. A queen-size model costs almost half of what a Casper queen-size model does. Keep in mind that Casper also offers financing options through Affirm for its Original mattress.

Buying Experience

Since the Casper Select is offered through Costco, your buying experience may be slightly different than when buying the Original mattress from Casper. Both mattresses come with 10-year warranties, but the Casper Select is covered by Costco’s 90-day return policy rather than Casper’s standard 100-night sleep trial.

FAQs

Finding the right mattress for you depends on your top needs. For instance, if you’re someone with back pain, it’s important to find a mattress that keeps your spine aligned. Create a list of your top needs and wants in a mattress to help you narrow down your options during your hunt.

For more on how to find the right mattress for you, check out our how to choose a mattress guide.

The biggest difference is that the Select has an extra layer of foam. It also costs less than the Casper and is only offered through Costco.

In addition to the Casper Original and Casper Select, Casper sells foam/innerspring hybrid mattresses including:

The brand also offers the budget-friendly Casper Element.

Finding the right mattress can improve not only your nights but also your days.

Still Undecided?

Our comparison tool can help you evaluate multiple mattresses side by side.