Casper vs Layla Mattress Comparison

When buying an online memory foam mattress, the Layla and Casper are bound to pop up. These two mattresses are fan favorites, with countless positive reviews and happy customers. 

We’re going to compare these mattresses head-on and learn their differences in our Casper vs Layla mattress comparison. Learn how they performed in our in-house testing, how they’re similar and different, and how these factors influence which mattress is best for you.

The Highlights

Key Similarities

• Both have a similar, budget-friendly price point. 
• Both are memory foam mattresses. 
• Both offer a good balance of cushion and support for lightweight sleepers. 
• Both have a zoned support layer and responsive feel that works well for every sleep position, even combination sleepers. 

Key Differences

• The Layla mattress is flippable and boasts different firmness options on each side. One side is softer than the Casper and the other side is firmer. 
• Casper scored higher in our spine alignment test, making it a better choice for sleepers with back pain.
• Layla Sleep’s sleep trial and warranty are more generous than Casper’s.

The Dimensions

Casper and Layla mattresses are available in the same standard sizes. The Layla is 1” thinner, but our sleep testers didn’t feel like one was more or less supportive than the other. They each are best for sleepers who weigh less than 230 pounds.

Learn more about mattress sizes.

Casper vs Layla Prices

Layla and Casper each come at a similar price point, with the Layla more expensive in smaller sizes and the Casper more expensive in larger sizes.

Compare Inside Layers

Even though the Layla and Casper mattresses are memory foam beds, they’re constructions are quite different. Let’s take a look at what sets these beds apart. 

Casper is a 3-layer, medium-firm, memory foam bed. What makes the Casper mattress an excellent option for every sleeping position is a second layer of zoned support foam. Extra cushion at the shoulders relieves pressure for side sleepers, while a sturdier core that resists sagging supports back and stomach sleepers. 

The Layla mattress is one of very few flippable all-foam mattresses. Not only does a flippable mattress have twice the sleeping surface that can boost longevity, but the Layla has a different firmness level on each side. The soft side rates a 4 on the 1-10 firmness scale and the firm side a 7 out of 10. 

Four layers of foam make up the Layla. The softer side has a thick comfort layer above a zoned support transition layer, delivering exceptional cushion and a deep, encompassing feel. The firmer side has a thin layer of foam directly atop the firm support layer for a supportive sleeping experience.

MA Scores

We’ve tested both mattresses at our in-house testing lab, evaluating their performance on factors that influence the feel, performance, and customer experience. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of how the Casper and Layla measured up.

TLDR: Which Mattress Is Better?

There is no clear winner when comparing the Layla and Casper mattresses. Each of these beds performed highly during our in-house testing and evaluation, and they both work well for similar sleepers: those who weigh less than 230 pounds. 

The Casper mattress is better for sleepers with back pain. Its ability to keep the spine aligned no matter the sleeping position is unmatched by the Layla or most other mattresses. It’s also one of the most responsive memory foam mattresses that we’ve ever tested, so you won’t feel stuck as you switch positions at night. 

The Layla also caters to every sleeping position. Its flippable design means that side, back, and stomach sleepers can all find what they need. Additionally, with a soft and firm side, the Layla is one of the few beds that accommodates changing needs—such as those of growing children or pregnant women. Plus, it offers slightly better pressure relief than the Casper, so side sleepers with shoulder or hip pain may find more relief with the Layla. 

Both mattress companies come with free shipping and free returns, although Layla’s shipping policy and trial period are more generous than Casper’s. Nevertheless, you can try either of these mattresses in your own bedroom, helping to make online mattress shopping less stressful.  

Other Comparisons You May Like:

• Layla vs Nectar Mattress
• Layla vs Purple Mattress
• Casper vs Nectar Mattress
• Casper vs Purple Mattress
• Casper vs Amerisleep Mattress
• Casper vs Loom & Leaf Mattress
• Casper vs Yogabed Mattress