Casper vs Saatva Mattress Comparison

Key Similarities:

• Our testers loved how well the Casper Original and the Saatva Classic kept their spines aligned. Both mattresses received a near-perfect score for spine alignment, making them great mattresses for back sleepers and those with back pain.
• Both mattresses offer excellent edge support and are well-suited for side sleepers who sleep near the edge. Side sleepers interested in the Saatva should go with the plush soft firmness level for deeper contouring and cradling of pressure points.
• The Casper Original and Saatva Classic work great for all sleeping positions thanks to their medium firmness options. Saatva also offers its Classic in a firmer and softer option.

Key Differences:

• The Saatva Classic is more of a luxury mattress than the Casper Original, which is reflected in the higher price, but it comes with perks like free white glove delivery and customizable firmness.
• Saatva is one of the best cooling mattresses because of its hybrid design, while the Casper isn’t a great choice for hot sleepers due to its all-foam nature.
• The Casper Original is better at responding and adapting to your movements, making it a better fit for combination sleepers than the Saatva Classic.
• Saatva offers a significantly longer sleep trial, lasting a full year, while Casper’s is only 100 nights long.

Compare Construction & Materials

Mattress layers are designed to support specific sleeping positions, while also accommodating a broad range of sleepers. Features include memory foam, coils, and pillow tops. Take a look inside each mattress below, but before we get there, we’re going to closely compare Casper’s and Saatva’s layers. 

The Casper Original is your classic memory foam mattress with three soft foam layers. It’s medium-firm, making it a great choice for all sleep positions. The Casper Original’s all-foam construction and middle-of-the-road firmness level help it deliver excellent pressure relief, responsiveness, spine alignment, and motion isolation. 

In contrast, the Saatva Classic mattress features five premium foam and coil layers designed for maximum support and comfort. The Saatva Classic definitely has more of a ‘“lux” feel to it with its European-style plush pillow top, dual-coil system, and dense memory foam layer. The result is hotel-style comfort. And with three different firmness levels, the Saatva Classic is also well-suited for all sleep positions.

If you like to feel hugged and cradled by your mattress, the Casper Original is the way to go. You could also go with the Saatva Classic’s plush soft option that offers deeper contouring and compression. The Saatva Classic’s luxury firm option is really meant for people who like a nice balance between sinking into their bed and sleeping on top of it. This is also the most popular firmness option among customers who purchase the Saatva.

Verdict: Which Is the Better Mattress?

Hopefully, this Casper vs Saatva comparison has given you a clear idea of which mattress you’ll be sleeping on a few weeks from now. If you’re still undecided, consider your budget, sleep style, and desired purchasing experience.

Your Budget

The Casper is unquestionably the better option for buyers on a budget. They offer a highly rated, quality mattress for a price that most consumers can afford. They also offer financing through Affirm, free returns, and a 10-year warranty.

Saatva is a luxury mattress brand, so a higher price point is expected. They also offer financing through Affirm and a lifetime warranty. You get all your money back if there is a defect with your mattress, but they do charge $99 for mattress replacement after three years.

Your Sleep Style

If you’re shopping for your sleep style, consider that the Casper Original received the highest possible rating for responsiveness. That means it’s great for combination sleepers, couples, or those who expect a midnight visit from a child or pet. It’s also the obvious choice for those looking for a memory foam mattress. The combined layers of foam provide optimum pressure point relief, and this bed is the runner-up for the best mattress for side sleepers.

According to Saatva, its hybrid mattress is recommended by chiropractors and is a top-rated choice for side sleepers and people with back pain. The combination of memory foam and coil-on-coil support systems makes it a better choice for heavyweight sleepers. Each side can accommodate up to 300 lbs. Additionally, Saatva shoppers can customize their firmness level.

Your Buying Experience

Finally, if buying experience is your main priority, both companies have excellent customer service ratings. Casper’s set-up requires more work, but you’ll have your bed more quickly. Your mattress will be delivered to your door, compressed and boxed, within 3-9 days, and you’ll be required to set it up yourself. The queen size weighs in at 82 lbs, which means that two or three people should be able to carry the box to your room. You can test out the Casper for 100 days risk-free. If you don’t like it, returns are free. Casper’s customer service team is ready to help you seven days a week.

Alternatively, Saatva custom-makes your mattress, so it takes up to 21 days for delivery. If you don’t have the desire or capability to set up your bed, Saatva offers a free white glove delivery service. That means they’ll set up your bed in whichever room you prefer and remove your old bed at no extra charge. Make sure to select the white glove delivery and old bed removal options at check-out. Saatva offers a 365-day trial period, but returns are $99. If you have further questions, their customer service team is available 365 days a year, 24/7.

Customers give the Casper Original a 4.5/5 ranking and the Saatva Classic a 4.9/5 ranking. Our team at Mattress Advisor slightly favors the Saatva Classic with a final score of 9.3, whereas we rated the Casper Original an 8.7/10, so you can bet you’ll get a good night’s sleep with either mattress.

Other Casper and Saatva Mattress Comparisons:

• Casper vs Amerisleep
• Casper vs Loom & Leaf
• Casper vs Tempur-Pedic
• Casper Wave Hybrid vs Casper
• Casper vs Zinus
• Saatva vs DreamCloud
• Saatva vs Helix
• Saatva vs Loom & Leaf
• Saatva vs Leesa
• Saatva vs Puffy