Casper Select Mattress Review

Casper Select Mattress

Casper Select Mattress Review

✔️Last updated: November 2022

✔️ Customer Rating: 4.4/5
✔️ Mattress Advisor Score: 8.8/10
✔️ Type: Memory Foam
✔️ Firmness: Medium Soft
✔️ Free Shipping
✔️ 90-Day Sleep Trial
✔️10-Year Warranty

Get up to $300 Off

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Overview: Casper has teamed up with Costco to offer another affordable memory foam mattress, similar to its Original. What sets this mattress, also referred to as the Select, apart is its extra inch of height and additional foam layer. Since it incorporates a special zone support layer, it has near-perfect pressure relief and keeps your spine in an ideal position.

Who Is the Casper Select Mattress Best For?

Casper Select is best for: Casper Select may not be best for:
  • Back sleepers
  • Couples
  • Those who sleep close to the edge
  • Budget-friendly shoppers
  • People with back pain
  • Shoppers looking for a guest room or dorm bed
 

  • Stomach sleepers
  • Hot sleepers
  • People with hip pain or sensitive shoulders
  • Shoppers who prefer traditional innerspring mattresses
  • Those without a Costco membership

Casper Select Mattress Review Highlights

The Casper Select Mattress is a Costco-exclusive product only available to store members. We like to think of it like the airport VIP lounge, giving you specialty premium comfort. This four-layer memory foam mattress has ergonomic zone support, providing great spinal alignment.

Read on to see what other evaluation areas the Casper Select Mattress excelled in and what the buying experience is like.

What We Love About the Casper Select Mattress

  • Casper uses CertiPUR-US certified foam in all its layers, meaning they don’t use ozone-depleting chemicals.
  • The third layer has a zoned support system to provide targeted pressure relief and spinal alignment.
  • This mattress scored high in motion transfer and edge support, making it a great bed for those who sleep with a partner or dog.
  • Casper offers the Select in both an all-foam and hybrid model, allowing you to pick based on your preferred mattress type.

Mattress Advisor Score

Here at Mattress Advisor, we rate each factor on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the best. Then we calculate our final score using a weighted average. Learn more about our review and scoring process.

Mattress Advisor Test Score (Out of 10)
Shipping 8
Trial Period 8
Return Policy 8
Warranty 8
Set-Up 9
Motion Transfer 9.5
Edge Support 9
Pressure Relief 8
Spine Alignment 9
Responsiveness 8.5
Cooling 7.5
Durability 8
Customer Service 9
Social Impact 8.5
⭐Total Score for the Casper Select Mattress: 8.8/10⭐

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Motion Transfer: Since the Select uses Casper’s signature memory foam layers, it does an excellent job at absorbing motion so you can sleep with a partner without sacrificing your sleep quality.
  • Edge Support: Despite being a memory foam mattress, which tends to be known for having no edge support, the Select Mattress did a great job of holding our testers when they sat on the end of the bed.
  • Spine Alignment: Our tester’s spine was very straight thanks to the Select Mattress’s targeted zone support.

Cons

  • Limited Size Options: The Casper Select doesn’t come in any twin or split sizes so if you are looking for a bed for a smaller space or want one that splits, you may need to look elsewhere.
  • Cooling: During our evaluation, this mattress scored pretty average in our cooling category, making it a poor choice for those who sleep hot.
  • Member Only Item: Unlike Casper’s other mattresses, which you can purchase from their website, the Select is a Costco-exclusive item only available to members of the store.

Motion Transfer 

Motion transfer looks at whether a mattress can absorb motions that occur on one side of the bed so that they don’t travel to the other side. This is especially important for those who co-sleep.

In our evaluation, we had one tester lie with their eyes closed while another tester got in bed. The second tester moved around and then got out of bed to see if the one with their eyes closed could feel their movement. The verdict – they barely felt anything!

Edge Support

Having good edge support ensures that you stay in bed at night and don’t tumble to the floor. This is also helpful for the elderly or those who need help getting into bed.

Typically we see higher edge support scores for hybrids since they have coil reinforcement around the perimeter and lower scores for memory foam mattresses since they lack this feature. The Casper Select surprised us by having superb edge support. Our testers felt fully supported when sitting and lying on the edge of the bed.

Pressure Relief

To test pressure relief, we use a special pressure map tool that depicts pressure buildup areas in warm colors. Map images with all cool colors show that the mattress does a great job of relieving pressure.

When our tester lay on their side, the map showed mostly cool colors. There was a small spot of red in the elbow area, but overall it had a great reading.

Next, we had our tester lie on their back and saw that again there were mostly blues and greens. The elbow and leg area had a slight spot of red. Overall, the pressure relief was pretty good, but we gave it an 8/10 since it had a few areas of pressure buildup.

Spine Alignment

Remember when your teacher used to tell you to sit up straight? Well, lying straight is just as important since it ensures your back gets the support it needs at night. The Casper Select did a good job of keeping our tester’s back in a neutral position, earning a near-perfect 9/10 score.

Product Details

Where Does It Fall on the Firmness Scale?

Casper identifies its Select Mattress as a medium-firm mattress, but we felt it was more of a medium soft one, falling at a 6/10 on the firmness scale. This is a bed where you will sleep “in” rather than “on” it and may be too soft for those who prefer firmer mattresses.

Does the Casper Select Sleep Cool?

The Casper Select is your typical memory foam mattress that traps heat and doesn’t keep you cool. While we loved the super soft mattress cover, it wasn’t very cool to the touch. If you feel this mattress hits the nail on all your other wish list items, consider buying a cooling mattress pad to adjust the temperature to a more comfortable level.

What Sleeping Position Does It Work For?

As a medium-soft mattress, the Casper Select works with a majority of sleeping positions. We think that back sleepers, especially, will like this bed since it does a good job of keeping the spine aligned. It also scored pretty well for responsiveness, something combination sleepers need, and gives good pressure relief, which is helpful for side sleepers.

Stomach sleepers may need a firmer mattress to ensure their hips are elevated. This bed definitely has a sink-into-it feel, something that doesn’t support stomach sleepers very well, particularly if you are plus-size.

How Much Weight Does the Casper Select Mattress Support?

While Casper designs its mattresses to work with all types of bodies and doesn’t give their beds weight limits, we think some heavy-weight sleepers may find this bed to cause them to sink too much. Heavy side sleepers, in particular, may have too much pressure buildup. If you weigh over 250 lbs, you may want to consider an innerspring mattress, like the Helix Plus, which is firmer and can hold more. The Casper Select hybrid may also offer better support.

What Foundations or Bed Frames Are Compatible?

the Select Mattress works well with adjustable bases, solid wood platform bed frames, and bed frames with wooden slats that are no more than 3″ apart. Casper doesn’t recommend using a traditional box spring or bed frames with metal slats since they tend to not support the memory foam layers properly.

Casper Select Mattress Materials

The Casper Select is a four-layer memory foam mattress. See what each layer contains below.

Casper Select Layers
  1. Breathable Top Layer: The first foam layer contains a perforated foam that promotes airflow on the surface.
  2. Pressure-Relieving Foam: This foam layer helps relieve major pressure buildup areas in the hips and lower back.
  3. Zoned Support: Casper’s signature zoned support layer offers ergonomic benefits and helps keep the spine aligned.
  4. Dynamic Support Foam: At the bottom is a thicker foam layer, which supports the entire mattress structure.

Casper Select Mattress Sizes, Dimensions, and Pricing

Size Dimensions Weight Price*
Full 53″ x 75″ x 12″ 82 lbs $649.99
Queen 60″ x 80″ x 12″ 85 lbs $749.99
King 76″ x 80″ x 12″ 104 lbs $949.99
Cal King 72″ x 84″ x 12″ 103 lbs $949.99

*Prices listed are standard without sales or Mattress Advisor exclusive discounts. Click here to see the best price for the Casper Select mattress.

What’s Unboxing Like? 

Unboxing the Casper Select Mattress is fairly easy since it comes wrapped in a tall box. Once you carry the box to your desired room, pull the mattress out and cut the plastic to release it from its packaging.

Purchase Details

Policy Details
Delivery Delivered to your doorstep
Trial Period 90 days
Warranty 10-year limited mattress warranty
Return Policy Free returns during first 90 days
Financing None available

Shipping and Delivery

The Select comes with free shipping, delivered right to your door. To see if a mattress is available in your area, type in your zip code on the Costco website. You can add a setup service to your order for an additional fee. Delivery can take anywhere between 1-4 weeks, depending on availability.

Sleep Trial Period

Unlike mattresses purchased directly from Casper, the Select does not come with Casper’s standard 100-night sleep trial. Since it’s sold through Costco, the Costco 90-day return policy applies.

Casper Select Mattress Warranty

Casper offers a limited 10-year warranty for its Select Mattress. This means that they will either repair or replace your mattress if they deem it defective during this period. The warranty covers any indentations in the foam greater than 1″, splitting in the foam layers, and defects in the mattress cover’s zipper. To file a warranty, contact Costco customer service at 1-800-955-2292. 

Casper Customer Service

For questions, you can reach Casper’s sleep specialists seven days a week through one of the following methods:

  • Call 917-382-8157
  • Use the live chat feature on the Casper website
  • Email support@casper.com 

Since this is a Costco product, you can also reach their customer service team by calling 1-800-955-2292. See Costco’s returns policy here.

Return Policy

Casper Select customers can return their mattress to any one of the Costco warehouses worldwide during the first 90 days of owning it.

To initiate a return, go to the Costco website and log into your account. Select “Orders & Returns” and choose the “Return Items” button next to your order. Since this is a larger item, Costco will send an email with additional instructions. Once your return is complete, Costco will issue you a full refund to the credit card you used to place your order.

Is the Casper Select Right for You?

Buying the Casper Select is a wise choice for those wanting an affordable medium-firm mattress. Its exceptional motion isolation and edge support make it a great choice for couples. We also think that back sleepers will appreciate its high abilities to keep your spine aligned.

Since this is a Costco-member exclusive item, we don’t recommend it for those without a membership. Instead, consider one of Casper’s other memory foam mattresses like the Original. It also comes

Casper Select Mattress FAQs

The main difference between the Casper Select and the Casper Original mattresses is that the Select has an extra inch of height and foam layer. The Casper Select also has a lower price tag and scores higher for motion isolation, making it a better option for budget-friendly shoppers and couples. However, Casper offers more size options for its Original mattress, and its flagship earned a perfect 10/10 for responsiveness.

For a deeper look at how these two mattresses compare, check out our Casper Select vs Casper Mattress Comparison.

Yes! Just make sure to follow your heated mattress pad’s instructions to ensure safety.

To ensure an even wear on your Select Mattress, rotate it 180 degrees every few months. Also, make sure you use a proper mattress foundation.


Other Products Sold by Casper

Casper Wave and Box
casper foam pillow
casper base

You May Also Like...

star icon
Same Brand

Casper

casper original hero
star icon
Another Memory Foam

Puffy Mattress

Puffy resp e1585244784424
star icon
Similar Bed-in-Box Mattress

Tuft & Needle

tuft and needle
star icon
Same Price Range

Lull

lull mattress 1 1