Puffy Mattress Review

      Customer Rating:    4.6/5
      MA Score:    9/10

In this review, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about the Puffy mattress, including how it scored in our Mattress Advisor test. We’ll also give you an overview of the benefits Puffy provides to its customers – like a 101-night trial period and lifetime warranty! Read on to learn more.

Puffy Mattress Highlights

  • The Puffy mattress is a three-layer memory foam mattress made of two types of proprietary foam—ClimateComfort™ foam and Cooling Cloud™ Foam.
  • Puffy’s recently launched ClimateComfort™ foam layer is resistant to contractions and expansions caused by extreme temperatures, so no matter what, this mattress will cradle your pressure points through the dead of winter and heat of summer.
  • Additionally, it’s patent-pending Cooling Cloud gel-infused, memory foam layer helps draw heat away from your body so you don’t get hot and bothered during the night.
  • The Puffy is made with a stain-resistant cover, making it easy to clean and keep clean.

Mattress Advisor Score for Puffy

Here’s how the Puffy mattress scored on different tests and evaluations. Each score is a rating out of 10 points. The total score is a weighted average that incorporates all of the functional and performance characteristics of the mattress. We break down the scores so you can see how the Puffy mattress performed on specific tests and evaluations.


How quickly the mattress ships to your home. (Free shipping = better score!)

Trial Period:

The length of time offered to help you decide if you want to keep the mattress.

Return Policy:

Ease of return process including refund policy and how the mattress is removed from your home.


Length of mattress warranty and what is covered.

Set-up Test:

How easy it is to set up the mattress and move it.

Motion Transfer Test:

How well the mattress performs at isolating motion.

Edge Support Test:

The level of support offered on the edges of the mattress.

Pressure Relief Test:

How well the mattress relieves pressure, particularly around the hips, shoulders, and thighs.

Spine Alignment:

How well the mattress helps keep your spine in proper alignment while you’re sleeping.

Responsiveness Test:

How well the mattress adjusts to different movements or sleeping positions throughout the night.

Cooling Evaluation:

How well the mattress promotes airflow and breathability, or offers special cooling properties.

Durability Evaluation:

Quality and durability of materials, structural support, and expected lifespan of the mattress.

Customer Service Score:

How helpful and responsive the customer service team is.

Social Impact Score:

A measure of social mission, community involvement and charitable giving/partnerships.

Total Score for the Puffy Mattress:

Puffy Mattress Video Review

Take a look at our full Puffy mattress review and see how it performed in our testing to help you determine if this could be the mattress for you.

Score Breakdown

Set-up Test

It took us exactly one minute and 16 seconds (1:16) to unbox the Puffy mattress. This mattress was very light and easy to maneuver. As soon as we opened the packaging, the Puffy took its full shape immediately. It had a mild scent once opened, but this went away within an hour.

So for our setup test, the Puffy gets an awesome score of 9.5 out of 10.

Motion Transfer Test

Motion transfer is just a fancy way of saying how much movement you feel if your partner is moving around. You want this to be pretty minimal.

Part A – The Humans

The Mattress Advisor motion transfer test is a two-part test. We start by asking both sleep subjects to lie on the bed, blindfolded, and rate on a scale from one to ten how much movement they felt when their partner was moving around with 10 being no movement at all.

Turns out, the Puffy does an excellent job at absorbing motion. Our sleep subjects noticed they could hardly feel the movements of their sleep partner while on the mattress. In fact, they didn’t even feel them get up to leave. So for the first part of our motion transfer test, the Puffy gets a 9.

Part B – The Wine Test

Next, comes our wine test. We know this test sounds cliche, but it’s a great visual indicator of how much motion is being transferred from one side of the bed to another.

We had one of our sleep subjects lie down and roll back a forth a few times. We then took a look at how much the wine inside of the glass moved.

The wine glass barely moved at all when on the Puffy. The liquid inside was still too. So for the second half of our test, the Puffy gets a 9.25.

So for a total motion transfer score, the Puffy scored a 9.25 out of 10.

Edge Support Test

When choosing a mattress, you may not think to consider how much support the edge provides. But if you find yourself sleeping on the edge of your bed or use the end to get ready in the morning, you should definitely consider the edge support.

The Mattress Advisor edge support test is a two-part test.

Part A – The Shoe Test

To start, we asked our sleep subjects to sit on the edge of the bed to tie their shoes. They rated this task on a scale from one to ten, with 10 being “extremely easy, with exceptional edge support.”

According to our testers, support on the end of the Puffy mattress was very good. The edge of the mattress actually gripped them as they sat down. So for the shoe test, the Puffy gets an 8.5.

Part B – The Side Test

Next, we had our sleep subjects lie on the edge of the bed in each sleeping position, side, stomach and back, to see if they could sleep comfortably in that section of the bed.

Once again, they felt the edge of the Puffy mattress cradled and gripped their body as they approached the edge, even more so when they were laying down than sitting. So for the second part of our edge support test, the Puffy scored a 9.

So the Puffy scores a grand total of 8.75 for edge support.

Pressure Relief Test

When shopping for a mattress, you’ll want to find something that puts minimal pressure on your hips, thighs and shoulders. This is especially important for athletes when it comes to joint pain. Let’s take a look at how well the Puffy mattress provides pressure relief for its sleepers.

We measure pressure relief by using a pressure mapping film that shows areas of high pressure. Here’s what you need to know: the cool spots are good and the warms spots are bad. The warmer the color, the more pressure is being placed on that area of the body.

When our testers were on the Puffy we saw some red in their shoulders as they laid on their side. However, their backs were free from high pressure.

So for a total pressure relief score, the Puffy gets an 8 out of 10.

Spine Alignment Test

Did you know your sleeping posture is just as important as your posture when you are awake?  For every mattress we test, we take a look at how well it keeps your spine in a straight line.

We took a close up of both of our sleep subjects backs to see the alignment. You’ll want to see a straight line from the neck all the way to the tailbone.

The Puffy did a good job of keeping those spines in neutral alignment. There was only a slight curve as the spine approached the base of the neck.

For spine alignment, the Puffy gets an 8.75 out of 10.

Responsiveness Test

When it comes to getting comfortable on your mattress, responsiveness becomes very important. Responsiveness is just a fancy way of saying how well the mattress adjusts or responds to your sleeping positions while you sleep.

We had our mattress testers lie in each sleeping position, side, stomach and back. As they changed positions and got settled in, we asked them to rate on a scale from one to ten how quickly and easily the mattress responded to their movement.

The Puffy mattress really knows how to listen and respond to its sleepers.

It scored a 9 out of 10 for responsiveness.

Customer Reviews on the Puffy Mattress

Was nervous about buying a matress without testing it out first. But glad I decided to give it a shot. It’s so much more comfortable than my spring matress. Felt weird at first because has a different feel than spring matress. But I sleep better and it’s just comfy. I’m a fluffy guy and I don’t over heat with it. Breaths pretty good I think.” Michael M.
I love this bed. I have a couple blown discs and sciatica so sleeping was always uncomfortable, no matter the position. Now I sleep and rarely move – I wake up with pillow creases in my face – so I know I’m not rolling around like I used to!! LOL I’d recommend this bed to anyone who suffers from hip or back pain – for sure. Love my Puffy!” Eileen M.
Overall the mattress is an excellent mattress. Very comfortable. Setup was a breeze. Degassing of minimal odor was completed in 3 days. Would recommend the mattress to anyone looking for a reasonably priced mattress that offers excellent comfort.” Andrew D.

Product Information


72 lbs. for queen




Medium-firm: 7/10


Memory foam

American Made

Made in the USA

Size Dimensions Standard Price*
Twin 39″ x 75″ $825
Twin XL 39” x 80” $875
Full 54” x 75” $1000
Queen 60” x 80” $1150
King 76” x 80” $1350
Cal King 72” x 84” $1350

*Prices listed are standard without sales or Mattress Advisor exclusive discounts. Check price using the button below for the best deals on the Puffy mattress. 

Foundations Puffy is Compatible With

Puffy is designed to work with any frame or foundation. The sturdier the foundation, the better it will support your mattress.

Solid Platform
Box Spring
Slatted Foundation
Adjustable Base
A Look Inside the Puffy Mattress

The Puffy mattress is made of three proprietary memory foam layers and wrapped in a stain-resistant cover that’s covered in clouds:

  • 2″ Cooling Cloud Gel-Infused Memory Foam: This top layer of gel-infused foam is designed to disperse heat away from your body and promote airflow so you don’t wake up with the night sweats (’cause who likes that? No one).
  • 2″ ClimateComfort™ Memory Foam: This recently added memory foam layer is pretty darn cool. Unlike most foams that expand and contract depending on the temperature, this foam doesn’t. When it’s hot, foam tends to expand. When it’s cold, it can contract. This variability in the foam can impact its pressure-relieving abilities; however, the ClimateComfort™ layer by Puffy is resistant to these changes in temperature, meaning you can rest assured knowing you are getting the same support whether it’s the dead of winter or middle of the summer!
  • 6″ Firm Core Support Base Layer: The base layer of the Puffy mattress provides structure and durability to the entire structure. Its Insta-Firm technology offers 99% better responsiveness and 4x the support of standard mattresses.

Purchase Experience


Compressed and rolled in a box; delivered in 2-5 business days

Trial period

101 days


Lifetime warranty for as long as you own the mattress

Return Policy

Free returns


Available through Klarna

Other Products Sold by Puffy

Puffy Pillow


Mattress Protector

Mattress Pad

Puffy mattress pad

Mattress Foundation

Adjustable Base

Bed Frame

Puffy bed frame

Puffy Mattress FAQs

How does the 101-night trial work?

From the day you receive your Puffy mattress, you’ll have 101 nights to decide if it’s the right mattress for you. If you’re not happy with your Puffy mattress, you can return it for a full refund within your 101-night trial period. Puffy will arrange for a representative to come to your home to pick up your mattress and donate it to a local charity.

How long will it take for my Puffy mattress to be delivered?

The Puffy mattress ships free and should arrive at your doorstep within 2-5 business days.

Will the Puffy mattress have a break-in period?

It can take up to 30 days to fully break in your new mattress. During this time, your body will get used to the new mattress feel and the mattress will have time to fully take shape and provide all the benefits it was designed to offer. But the good news is you have plenty more than 30 days in your trial period!

Can I finance my Puffy mattress?

You sure can! Puffy has partnered with Klarna to offer no-interest payments if your mattress is paid off within 12 months and APR options if paid longer than 12 months. You can receive an instant approval decision at checkout.

Is the Puffy mattress eco-friendly?

All the foams in the Puffy mattresses are CertiPUR-US® certified, meaning they meet some of the most rigorous standards for emissions, content, performance, and durability.

Can I clean my Puffy mattress?

The cover on the Puffy mattress can actually be unzipped and put in the wash.