Best Customizable Mattresses of 2023

Jan 9th, 2023 •

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Does mattress shopping sometimes make you wish you could just tell someone what you want in a mattress, snap your fingers and a perfectly customized mattress would soon appear at your doorstep? If so, then you’ve come to the right place.

Mattress companies, like Helix and Amerisleep, are making mattresses to fit customers’ specific needs, with options for firmness, weight, cooling properties, sleep position, and more. Most of the customizable mattress companies will have you answer a set of questions to determine an option that will best meet your needs. And a number of them will even allow you to select different specifications for each side of the bed, meaning you and your partner won’t need to compromise when it comes to getting great sleep. Keep reading to find the best mattress for you.

Best Customizable Mattress: Our Top Picks

Best Overall – Helix
Best Customizable Mattress for Back Pain – Saatva
Best Customizable Hybrid Mattress – WinkBed
Best Customizable Foam Mattress – Layla
Best Customizable Mattress for Pressure Points – TEMPUR-Adapt
Best Online Customizable Mattress – Amerisleep

Buying a new mattress is a big investment, so why not invest in one that’s been specifically made for you? Take a look at some of the best mattresses that can be custom made just for you.

Helix

Best Overall

Price: $995 for queen (price may vary based on customization preferences)
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: 10-year warranty; 100 night sleep trial with free returns
Customer rating: 6/5
Type: hybrid – foam combo with microcoils

Helix will match you with a customized mattress after you take a short, but comprehensive questionnaire that takes into account things like your age, weight, height, body shape, mattress preference, sleep position, medical conditions and sleep temperature preferences. They’ll use this information to create a sleep profile that informs a mattress design specifically crafted to suit your needs and preferences.

The company offers the Helix Twilight (firm feel), the Helix Dawn (firm feel), the Helix Midnight (medium feel), the Helix Dusk (medium feel), the Helix Moonlight (soft feel), and the Helix Sunset (soft feel). There are also luxury options available for each of these models.

WHAT HELIX CUSTOMERS SAY:

“I ended up taking the Helix Sleep quiz…well the Helix Midnight has turned out to be the perfect balance of firmness and still the right amount of plushness.”

“The quiz Helix offers to match you with the best mattress for your needs was really helpful in giving us a place to start.”

See Helix mattress reviews.

Saatva

Best for Back Pain

Price: $1,795 for queen
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: lifetime warranty; 365 night sleep trial, with white glove delivery
Customer rating: 4.9/5
Type: innerspring

Though Saatva is technically a hybrid mattress, it boasts a firmer innerspring feel that’s great for spinal alignment and alleviating back pain. Pocketed steel coils and a plush Euro-top work together to deliver a balance of comfort and support. You can choose from three different firmnesses: Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. You can select which firmness works best based on your individual needs and preferences.

Saatva offers free white glove delivery, meaning they will not only deliver but set up your mattress. They’ll even go so far as to remove your old mattress.

WHAT SAATVA CUSTOMERS SAY:

“I have enjoyed sleeping on this mattress since it was delivered, I wake up more refreshed than before. It helps with my back and shoulder pain. Very pleased with the product, excellent materials and craftsmanship.”

“This company fully backs its products, is honest and ethical, and does what it can to fix any issues or problems that may occur.”

See Saatva review.

WinkBed

Best Hybrid

Price: $1,799 for queen
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: lifetime warranty; 120 night sleep trial with free returns
Customer rating: 4.5/5
Type: hybrid

The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress, meaning it uses the contouring comfort layer of a memory foam mattress and the firm support of an innerspring. Four different firmnesses are offered, so depending on your sleeping position and body type, you can select the WinkBed that suits you best. The firmness options include Soft, Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus (for heavier sleepers).

We love the WinkBed because of its cooling ability and spinal alignment support. During our testing, it received an 8/10 and an 8.5/10 in each category, respectively.

WHAT WINKBED CUSTOMERS SAY:

“Really amazingly outstanding customer service which helped time my shipment so it arrived at the right time. An easy set-up and the most wonderful mattress ever slept on.”

“After many months of research I finally chose the Luxury Firm WinkBed and could not be happier with my decision.”

See WinkBed review.

Layla

Best Foam

Price: $1,099 for queen
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: lifetime warranty; 120 night sleep trial, with free returns
Customer rating: 4.5/5
Type: all-foam

The Layla is customizable in the sense that it’s flippable. This unique feature results in a Soft side (4/ 10 on the firmness scale) and a Firm side (7/10 on the firmness scale). The Soft side should be great for joint pain, and the Firm side should be beneficial for back pain. In the end, you can decide which side aligns with your sleeping habits. It should work well for most sleepers.

The layers of copper-infused memory foam provide a slow-moving feel that’s extremely pressure-relieving. In fact, the Layla earned a 9/10 score for pressure relief during our testing process.

WHAT LAYLA CUSTOMERS SAY:

“I cannot say enough about the construction of this mattress. If you like memory foam, you will love this mattress.”

“Well-made! Customer service is prompt and friendly. So glad I discovered Layla.”

See Layla review.

TEMPUR-Adapt

Price: $1,795 for queen
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: lifetime warranty; 365 night sleep trial, with white glove delivery
Customer rating: 4.9/5
Type: all-foam or hybrid

Side sleepers require a softer, pressure-relieving mattress because they put so much weight on the hips and shoulders. TEMPUR-Pedic offers the TEMPUR-Adapt, a fantastic option for side sleepers. It has unmatched pressure relief and motion cancellation. However, they also sell the TEMPUR-ProAdapt and the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt as enhanced versions of the original mattress. The ProAdapt is an inch thicker than the original for even more plushness, and the LuxeAdapt adds another extra inch of material.

Better yet, each of these models comes in a range of firmnesses. After taking into account your needs as a sleeper, you can select your ideal model and firmness. The ProAdapt and Adapt models even come in a Medium Hybrid option, incorporating a mix of coils and foam.

WHAT TEMPUR-PEDIC CUSTOMERS SAY:

“This mattress is fantastic. Just the perfect level of softness with great support.”

“No more tossing and turning all night, and no more waking up stiff and sore. Also no more waking up in the night all hot and sweaty. Would recommend this bed to anyone who is looking for a comfortable night’s sleep.”

See Tempur-Adapt review.

Amerisleep

Price: $1,349-2,149 for queen
Shipping: Free, ships in a box
Warranty and returns: 20-year warranty; 100 night sleep trial, with white glove delivery
Customer rating: 4.5/5
Type: all-foam

Amerisleep offers five models varying in firmness and construction, so they can find which all-foam mattress they prefer. You can choose between the AS1 (8.5-9/10 firmness), AS2 (7/10 firmness), AS3 (6/10 firmness), AS4 (4/10 firmness), and AS5 (3/10 firmness). These quality memory foam mattresses are also offered in hybrid versions, as well as an all-natural bed called the Organica.

The Amerisleep beds are made in the USA and utilize high-quality, plant-based foams. That way, you can feel good about what you’re resting on at night.

WHAT AMERISLEEP CUSTOMERS SAY:

“The A5 has a great warranty, does not develop body impressions in the surface and is one of the most comfortable mattresses I have ever owned.”

“We purchased our A5 5 years ago and it is still just like the day we bought it. It has exceeded our expectations and we get great sleep. We also love how it minimizes the motion when one sleeper tosses and turns.”

Make Your Mattress a Personal Choice

While customizing a mattress to your liking might seem like more work, think about how much time you’ll be spending in said mattress. Sleep is personal, so your mattress should be too.

Still have questions about the best customizable mattresses or feel like telling us about one that you particularly love? Send your questions to questions@mattressadvisor.com.

Best Customizable Mattress FAQs

Are customizable mattresses expensive?

Customizable mattresses are not necessarily expensive. For example, the customizable beds reviewed above range in price from $995 to $2,149 for a queen, so there is plenty of room for different budgets.

The features that cost more in a customizable mattress are extras. For instance, if you purchase a flippable mattress, you’re essentially getting two mattresses in one. So while the price isn’t double, it does cost more than a one-sided mattress. And if there are extra features such as added comfort layers or temperature control, you can expect to pay more. But if the customization relates to standard features such as firmness, increased cost shouldn’t be part of the deal.

Can a mattress be customized? How?

Yes, mattresses can be customized. However, it’s not the type of customization you might think of when you imagine something like a custom paint job on a car. The manufacturer doesn’t make the mattress to your specifications, but rather has various options to choose from to make the mattress perfect for you.

Mattresses are often customized based on firmness and feel. Some companies also offer features you can customize in your own home, depending on what you want in a mattress at any given time. This includes flippable mattresses, which are softer on one side and firmer on another. Other examples include mattresses with built-in temperature control or air chambers (for firmness adjustments), which can be changed using a remote.

Best Customizable Mattresses of 2023

FEATURED MATTRESSES