updated June 2022

Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

What sets Puffy and Nectar apart is how they feel, and the difference determines who is best served by each.

Puffy and Nectar are two of the most well-loved bed-in-a-box mattress companies. Their medium-firm mattresses are universally comfortable, working well for side, back, and combination sleepers. However, there are many ways that these popular memory foam beds differ. 

In our Nectar vs Puffy review, we’ll share a side-by-side comparison of how these mattresses performed in our mattress lab, a breakdown of their materials, and an overview of who’s the best fit for each. By the end, you’ll know if one of these mattresses is a good fit for you.


A Quick Overview

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty
Puffy resp e1585244784424

Puffy Mattress

Customer Rating
MA Score

9/10

Summary

Memory foam mattress that is great for side sleepers

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Type

Memory Foam

Trial Period

101 nights

Warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.7/10

Summary

Affordable quality mattress with excellent trial period

Firmness

Medium-firm: 5.5-6/10

Type

Gel memory foam

Trial Period

365 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty as long as you own the mattress

Puffy resp e1585244784424
nectar original mattress updated

Puffy Mattress

Nectar

Customer Rating

MA Score

9/10

8.7/10

Summary

Memory foam mattress that is great for side sleepers

Affordable quality mattress with excellent trial period

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Medium-firm: 5.5-6/10

Type

Memory Foam

Gel memory foam

Trial Period

101 nights

365 days

Warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

Lifetime warranty as long as you own the mattress

The Puffy mattress is a moderately-priced luxury memory foam mattress. Its upper comfort layer is made from low-density memory foam with a cloud-like feel. The generous soft give of the Puffy top layer makes it the better choice for lightweight people and most side sleepers. Another perk of the Puffy is exceptional spine alignment that eases back pain and stiffness. 

The Nectar mattress is thicker than the Puffy and has a more durable feel. The foam within is higher density and feels more like a traditional memory foam mattress than the Puffy. These attributes make it a better fit for heavier sleepers, as well as those who like a close contouring feel. It deeply hugs the body, providing slightly superior pressure relief when compared to the Puffy.  

Key Similarities

  • Both are memory foam mattresses.
  • Both have a medium-firm firmness level that suits side and back sleepers.
  • Both boast a deep, hugging sensation thanks to plush memory foam comfort layers 
  • Both offer lifetime warranties for their mattresses.

Key Differences

  • The Puffy is more suitable for lightweight sleepers thanks to its softer top layer
  • The Nectar is a better fit for sleepers over 230 lbs thanks to its thicker foam layers and reliable support. 
  • Nectar’s year-long sleep trial is more generous than Puffy’s 101-night trial.
puffy mattress bedroom e1544387575202

The Puffy Mattress Review Highlights

  • Those with back pain get get the support they need thanks to the near-perfect score in our spine alignment evaluation.
  • One of the best mattresses we’ve tested for side sleepers and lightweight sleepers thanks to an ultra-soft memory foam comfort layer
  • Works for combination, side, and back sleepers due to a combination of impressive pressure relief and body alignment. 
  • Lifetime warranty demonstrates Puffy’s high-quality foam construction and commitment to customer satisfaction. 
  • You can even check out the Puffy Lux Hybrid or the Puffy Royal Hybrid mattress for a more luxurious experience.
nectar original mattress updated

The Nectar Mattress Review Highlights

  • Low-risk purchase—comes with a generous 365-night sleep trial with free returns. 
  • Contouring, supportive memory foam layers provide the reliable support and pressure relief needed by average to heavy sleepers in every sleep position. 
  • Forever warranty speaks to Nectar’s quality construction and commitment to customer satisfaction. 
  • Satisfied customers—Nectar has one of the lowest return rates (<3%), even with their generous 365-night trial
  • Nectar has some of the best deals and special offers, making their mattress a budget-friendly option.

Compare Sizes

The Puffy and Nectar mattresses come in the same standard mattress sizes. The Nectar mattress is 2” thicker than the Puffy mattress. As a thicker mattress is normally better for heavier sleepers, the added inch can make a difference. 

Puffy Nectar
Thickness 10” 12”
Twin 38” x 75” 38” x 75”
Twin XL 38” x 80” 38” x 80”
Full 54” x 75” 54” x 75”
Queen 60” x 80” 60” x 80”
King 76” x 80” 76” x 80”
Split King N/A 76″ x 80″
California King 72” x 84” 72” x 84”

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Compare Prices

The Puffy and Nectar mattresses have completely different price points, with the Nectar being the better budget option compared to Puffy. Keep in mind that these prices are the standard price and do not include any discounts. To get the lowest price, click on any of the links on this page for exclusive Mattress Advisor deals

Puffy Nectar
Twin $1,449 $499
Twin XL $1,499 $669
Full $1,649 $799
Queen $1,799 $899
King $1,999 $1,199
Split King N/A $1,238
California King $1,999 $1,199

Compare Mattress Materials

With proprietary technology, the Puffy and Nectar mattresses yield different sleeping experiences. In this section, we’ll dive into each bed’s construction and outline how it impacts the mattress’s feel. 

Inside the Puffy Mattress

The flagship Puffy is a medium-firm mattress made from 3 layers of foam. When you lie on the Puffy, you’ll be met with an ultra-soft feel that’s quickly balanced by full-body support. Let’s dive in and see what materials combine to create the unique Puffy mattress feel.

Puffy Layers
  • Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover: At the top of the Cloud mattress is a stain-resistant cover that keeps your mattress super clean.
  • Cooling Cloud foam (2″): The Cloud’s first layer is proprietary Cooling Cloud foam that’s wonderfully plush, yielding instantaneously to any pressure. It’s this immediate cushion that makes the Puffy one of the best mattresses for both side sleepers and lightweight sleepers. Cooling gel is dispersed throughout this upper comfort layer, stealing heat from the mattress surface for optimal temperature regulation. 
  • Climate Comfort™ Memory Foam (2″): The second layer is primarily responsible for Puffy’s ability to keep the spine in a healthy, neutral alignment by conforming to the body’s unique shape, dissipating weight from pressure points and distributing it evenly across the body. If you’re someone who wakes up with back pain or stiffness, this layer might be just what’s needed to ease the discomfort. 
  • Support Foam (6″): This polyfoam base layer is incredibly responsive thanks to Puffy’s exclusive Insta-Firm technology. Insta-Firm was created to counter sinkage, facilitate ease of movement, and dampen motion transfer along the surface. 

Inside the Nectar Mattress

Like the Puffy mattress, the Nectar mattress is a 3 layer memory foam bed with a medium-firm feel. Nectar’s layers of memory foam create a traditional memory foam mattress feel—one that deeply contours the body. It’s a sensation of sleeping more “in” than “on” the surface.

nectar matttress layers updated
  • Quilted Cool Cover: The Nectar mattress starts with a quilted, breathable cover features heat-wicking and cooling technologies to ensure a cool’s night sleep.
  • Nectar Smart Layer (3″): A high-density, pressure-relieving gel memory foam cradles your joints.
  • Dynamic Support Layer (2″): This adjusting foam bounces back to fully support your body as you sleep.
  • Stay Stable Base Layer (7″): The final layer of the Nectar mattress is a high-density polyfoam support layer that’s responsible for the impressive longevity of the Nectar bed and creates reliable edge support. 
  • Shift-Resistant Lower Cover: The Nectar mattress stays put thanks to a shift-resistant lower cover.

Compare Testing Scores

We tested the Puffy and Nectar mattresses at our in-house testing facility. Here’s how they performed. 

Puffy Nectar
Shipping 9 9
Trial Period 8 10
Return Policy 10 10
Warranty 10 10
Set-Up Test 8.5 8
Motion Transfer Test 7.5 8.5
Edge Support Test 8.5 9
Pressure Relief Test 7.5 8.5
Spinal Alignment Test 9.5 7.5
Responsiveness Test 6.5 8.5
Cooling Evaluation 8 7.75
Durability Evaluation 7.5 8.5
Customer Service Score 9 8.5
Social Impact Score 7 5
TOTAL SCORE 8.3/10 8.5/10

Final Summary: What Is the Best Mattress?

At our in-house testing facility, the Nectar outscored the Puffy mattress, earning an 8.5/10 in comparison to Puffy’s 8.3/10. But this composite score doesn’t tell the whole story. Each of these mattresses is a high-quality bed manufactured by companies committed to customer satisfaction. What’s the best mattress for one person may not be the right fit for someone else. 

The Nectar mattress is the go-to for the indecisive shopper. They offer a 365-night sleep trial, which is much longer than Puffy’s 101-night trial. Nectar’s feel is more like traditional memory foam than the Puffy, meaning you’ll feel deeply hugged and contoured. Its thicker profile and conforming transition layer make the Nectar a better choice for sleepers who weigh more than 230 lbs. 

The Puffy boasts an exceptionally plush comfort layer that allows lighter sleepers to sink in easily. For this reason, the Puffy is one of the best medium-firm mattresses for sleepers who weigh less than 130 lbs —especially side sleepers.

More Puffy and Nectar Comparisons:

iStock 695263328

Still Deciding?

If you're stuck between multiple mattresses, we can help you compare your options. Check out our comparison tool to evaluate features, ratings, and more!