Puffy vs Puffy Lux Mattress Comparison

Puffy recently enhanced both of their all-foam mattress models. See how the Puffy and Puffy Lux compare in price, pressure relief, cooling, and more.

Puffy is one of several bed-in-a-box mattress companies. They are known for their high quality foam beds that top our list for best mattress choices for side sleepers. The original Puffy mattress was recently updated to include a patent-pending ClimateComfort foam, which improves the consistency of pressure relief you experience through the night. 

In this comparison, we’ll run through the highlights, foam layers, prices, and dimensions for the Puffy and it’s premier sibling model, the Puffy Lux. Spoiler alert: both of these exceptionally soft mattresses are top rated on Mattress Advisor and relatively affordable for the average consumer.


Puffy vs Puffy Lux Overview

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty

Puffy

Customer Rating
MA Score
9 / 10
Summary

Memory foam mattress that is great for side sleepers

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Type

Memory foam

Trial Period

101 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Puffy Lux

Customer Rating
MA Score
9.3 / 10
Summary

Luxury memory foam mattress the sleeps cool.

Firmness

Medium-soft to medium: 5.5 - 7

Type

Memory foam

Trial Period

101 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Puffy mattress in bedroom

Puffy Mattress Review Highlights

  • The Climate Comfort foam layer is the newest addition to the Puffy mattress brand. It’s a patent-pending cooling foam that is designed to resist changes in temperature. Memory foam, like wood or veins, expands when it warms and contracts when it cools. This can affect the consistency of pressure relief you experience. The ClimateComfort foam sustains the same pressure relief all night long.
  • In our motion isolation test, the Puffy scored a 9.25/10. To help illustrate what that means, consider the wine test. We placed a tall-stem glass of wine on one end of the mattress and had our tester roll around on the other side. The glass and liquid didn’t move. This is an important feature when sleeping with a partner, especially if you are a light sleeper who is disrupted easily.
  • This is an important quality for combination sleepers and anyone who changes position throughout the night. A highly responsive mattress immediately changes with your movements – that way your body is always cradled. In our test, the Puffy scored a 9/10 on responsiveness.
  • If you have low back pain, spinal alignment is especially important. Keeping your spine aligned while sleeping prevents muscle aches and joint pain. With a score of 8.75/10, the Puffy mattress sufficiently cushions your spine, from tailbone to neck, and keeps it in a straight line.
Puffy Lux mattress in a bedroom setting

Puffy Lux Mattress Review Highlights

  • The Plush Dual Cloud Foam foam layer is constructed to provide extraordinary pressure relief
  • Puffy’s Cooling Cloud™ technology enhances airflow and breathability to 8 times that of traditional memory foam. This makes in an excellent choice for sleepers who run hot.
  • The Puffy Lux earned one of our highest scores for pressure relief at 9.5/10. This feature is especially important for side sleepers, who naturally put extra weight on their shoulders and hips. Mattresses high in pressure relieving properties cradle your curves with minimal stress.
  • A responsive bed helps you to feel supported and cozy from the moment you lie down. The Puffy Lux earned 9.25/10 in this category, meaning it responds almost instantly to your changes in position while sleeping. 
  • It’s worth noting that the Puffy Lux responds to your movements while keeping your spine aligned. It scored 9/10 in the spinal alignment category. Since we can’t consciously control our posture while sleeping, a mattress that holds the spine in place is important.

Compare Mattress Dimensions/Sizes

Since the Puffy and Puffy Lux are part of the same mattress brand, their dimensions are identical, except for thickness. The Puffy Lux has an extra layer of foam, making it 2 inches taller.

Puffy Puffy Lux
Thickness 10” 12”
Twin 39” x 75” 39” x 75”
Twin XL 39” x 80” 39” x 80”
Full 54” x 75” 54” x 75”
Queen 60” x 80” 60” x 80”
King 76” x 80” 76” x 80”
Cal King 72” x 84” 72” x 84”

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Compare Puffy and Puffy Lux Prices

The Puffy mattress is not the cheapest bed-in-a-box option, but it still hits an accessible price point. The Puffy Lux has a price range closer to that of luxury mattress brands, although Puffy offers financing for all of their beds.

Puffy Puffy Lux
Twin $795 $1,445
Twin XL $825 $1,495
Full $995 $1,595
Queen $1,150 $1,795
King $1,350 $1,995
California King $1,350 $1,995

Compare What’s Inside

The Puffy mattress has 3 layers, while the Lux model has 4. On the mattress firmness scale, the Puffy is a 7/10, or medium-firm, while the Lux ranges between 5.5 and 7/10, making it medium to medium-firm. Take a look at our breakdown of the individual foam layers in these two mattresses.

Inside the Puffy mattress

Inside the Puffy Mattress

  • The top layer of the Puffy mattress is 2 inches of Cooling Cloud foam. This gel-infused memory foam features temperature regulation technology that draws heat away from your body and improves airflow. Plus, gel-infused foam is naturally cool-to-the-touch.
  • The second layer is 2 inches of ClimateComfort memory foam. This patent-pending foam resists temperature changes, meaning the foam cells don’t expand and contract in response to temperature. This creates consistent contouring and pressure relief all night long.
  • 6 inches of Firm Core Support Foam make up the base layer of the original Puffy. This layer is made of polyfoam, which improves durability of your mattress. It also features Insta-Firm technology, which Puffy says provides 4 times the support of other mattresses.

Inside the Puffy Lux Mattress

  • On top is 1.5 inches of Cooling Cloud Gel-Infused Foam. This breathable memory foam layer keeps you cool by pulling heat away from your body.
  • An extra comfort layer of 1.5 inches of Plush Dual Cloud Foam makes this mattress the best for side sleeping
  • 2 inches of  ClimateComfortMemory Foam act as a transition layer and improve motion isolation, which prevents your sleep from being disrupted by movements from partners, children, and pets.
  • The Firm Core Support Base Layer is 7 inches deep. It helps to absorb motion and add whole-body support. A strong support layer also increases your mattress’s lifespan.

Compare Mattress Advisor Scores

Both the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses scored notably high in our lab evaluation tests, but Puffy Lux scored higher in a few key areas, such as pressure relief. Take a look at how they compare side-by-side in our comprehensive list of Mattress Advisor evaluation scores.

Puffy Puffy Lux
Shipping 9 9
Trial Period 10 10
Return Policy 10 10
Warranty 10 10
Set-Up Test 9.5 10
Motion Transfer Test 9.25 8.25
Edge Support Test 8.75 8.5
Pressure Relief Test 8 9.5
Spinal Alignment Test 8.75 9
Responsiveness Test 9 9.25
Cooling Evaluation 8 8.75
Durability Evaluation 8 8.75
Customer Service Score 9 9
Social Impact Score 7 7
TOTAL SCORE 9/10 9.3/10

See What Real Customers Say

  • On the Puffy’s softness: “We purchased the Puffy about a month ago. Our first night on it was amazing. First off – it is very soft. You sink in just the right amount to feel cozy but not hot. The support is unlike any other mattress I’ve slept on. My shoulders, hips and previously injured lower back do not ache when I wake up. It’s been two years since I’ve felt this good.” – Karley
  • On the Puffy Lux’s feel: “We LOVE our Puffy Lux!! Both my husband and I had such a hard time sleeping on our mattress and after getting this mattress, we have no trouble sleeping! It’s literally like sleeping on a cloud!!!! We are considering getting one for our guest bedroom! We tell everyone about it and recommend everyone get one!!” – Sarah K.
  • On the Puffy and sleeping positions:Puffy mattress is a great mattress for whatever side suits your sleep best! Puffy lets me sleep on my stomach, back, and side without any problems. Many mattresses that I’ve tried are great for back and side sleeping, but Puffy works great when I inadvertently end up sleeping on my stomach. No joint, hip, and back pain at any time! Love my Puffy! It’s doggone good!” – Jo L.
  • On the Puffy Lux’s firmness level: “I took a leap of faith with the Puffy Lux [and] I truly love this bed. I have arthritis and this bed is the perfect balance. It forms to my body with a nice mix of soft but firm.” – Ashley

Verdict: Which Is the Best Mattress?

The Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses may seem very similar, but they really do shine in different areas. To get a better idea of which model best suits you, consider your sleeping position, budget, and sleep environment.

Related: Check out the newest Puffy model, the Puffy Royal.

Sleeping Position

It’s no secret that side sleepers love the Puffy brand. The foam layers combine in a progressive way that contours even the sharpest curves of your body. Both mattress models scored high on pressure relief, which is important for side sleepers and those with neck, shoulder, and back pain.

With that said, back sleepers and stomach sleepers may prefer the slightly firmer feel of the originally Puffy mattress. Remember that the Puffy is 7/10 on the firmness scale, while the Puffy Lux is between 5.5 and 7/10 on the scale. Back sleepers need a firmer mattress surface so they don’t sink too deep into the top layer, which can throw off spinal alignment. Stomach sleepers need enough support to keep their lower back aligned but enough cushion for their shoulders and hips.

Budget

Right away, it’s easy to see that the original Puffy is the better budget option. The Puffy Lux is almost 2 times the price as the Puffy in most of the models. The prices become more comparable as you go up in size.

If price isn’t an issue for you, the Puffy Lux offers extra cooling and cushion in the additional Plush Dual Cloud Foam layer. It also scored a whole 1.5 points higher in pressure relief than the original Puffy. If you need the lowest cost option, the Puffy still ranks high across the board, and it’s top-rated in the memory foam category.

Sleep Environment

Sleepers who tend to run hot will fare well with either Puffy foam bed, however, the Puffy Lux scored slightly higher than the Puffy at 8.75/10, rather than 8/10. Both mattresses incorporate Puffy’s latest cooling technology, which improves airflow and heat dispersion. They also both include the new ClimateComfort Foam that sustains pressure relief, no matter the temperature in your room.

Both beds also scored pretty high in motion transfer, although the Puffy outscored the Puffy Lux with 9.25/10 over Puffy’s 8.25/10. That makes the original Puffy a better option for light sleepers and those who are concerned about movement disturbances from loved ones. 


Overall, buying your new mattress from Puffy will yield quality results. Side sleepers will love the excellent pressure relief in both mattresses, couples will appreciate the motion isolation, and hot sleepers will stay cool. Plus, Puffy offers fast delivery (2-5 days), a 101 night sleep trial, free returns, and a lifetime warranty. As far as mattresses go, it doesn’t get much better than that.

Read More Puffy Comparisons:

Still Deciding?

If you're stuck between multiple mattresses, we can help you compare your options. Check out our comparison tool to evaluate features, ratings, and more!

Compare Mattresses

Comments (0)