Best Purple Mattress Alternatives

Shopping for a mattress? Our comparisons can help you decide between Purple and another brand.

By Nicole Gleichmann

Jan 17th, 2023

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Purple is an innovator in the mattress industry. Its signature feature, the Purple GelFlex Grid, is designed to make you feel like you’re floating as it delivers great spine alignment and pressure relief. Purple is also one of many bed-in-a-box companies that compress and roll mattresses into boxes or tubes for delivery.

But a Purple mattress isn’t right for everyone. In this article, we’re going to take a look at a few of the most popular Purple alternatives. We’ll compare their feel, cost, and cooling potential so you can find your best fit.

If you want to view more products, you can use our Compare Mattresses tool to see how they stack up head-to-head.


Best Purple Mattress Alternatives

Purple Model Best Alternative Mattress
Purple Mattress Casper Original
Purple Hybrid The WinkBed
Purple Hybrid Premier 3 DreamCloud Premier
Purple Hybrid Premier 4 Helix Midnight Luxe
Kid’s Purple Saatva Youth

Purple Mattress vs Casper Original

Firmness and Feel

Purple: 6.5/10 firmness

Casper: 6/10 firmness

The original Purple Mattress and the Casper Original are both medium-firm mattresses. The Purple mattress’s hyper-elastic polymer grid layer sits on top of two foam layers and is designed to make you feel like you’re floating, evenly distributing body weight without excess sinkage. The Casper’s memory foam zoned support layer gives you soft support under your shoulder area and firmer support in the lower portion of your body.

Despite their similar firmness levels, these beds are better for different sleeping positions. The Purple’s exceptional contouring is great for side sleepers and back sleepers, balancing spine alignment with pressure relief. Likewise, the Casper’s memory foam design matches up well with side sleepers and back sleepers.

At the same time, the Casper is better for stomach sleepers and combination sleepers. Purple’s 9.25″ thickness might not translate to enough support for stomach sleepers, while Casper’s superior responsiveness makes it the better choice for combination sleepers who change positions during the night.

Another difference between these two is the body types that they support. The Casper is designed to support all body types, while the Purple is best for those who weigh less than 230 lbs.

Cooling

During testing, we found that the Purple (8/10 score) sleeps cooler than the Casper (7/10 score). The Purple is cool thanks to the breathable Purple grid, while the Casper’s all-foam construction tends to trap heat.

Price

These mattresses have similar price points, with a queen-size mattress costing $1,295 for the Casper and $1,399 for the Purple. These prices are slightly less than the average memory foam and hybrid mattress.

Trial Period & Warranty

Purple:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Casper:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Purple Hybrid vs The WinkBed

Firmness and Feel

Purple Hybrid: 7/10 firmness

The WinkBed: 4.5/10 (Soft), 6.5/10 (Luxury Firm), 7.5/10 (firm), or 8/10 (Plus)

The Purple Hybrid has a firm feel, but the WinkBed offers four firmness options (including Plus, recommended for people weighing 250 lbs or more). Though the Purple Hybrid and the WinkBed are hybrid mattresses that offer both foam and coils for comfort and support, specific variations in their construction result in noticeably different sleeping experiences.

One of the Purple Hybrid’s most distinctive features is its signature GelFlex Grid, designed to create a floating sensation as it contours to your body. The WinkBed uses an eco-friendly, gel-infused foam designed for contouring and durability. However, the Purple Hybrid provides far better pressure relief (a perfect 10/10 score vs WinkBed’s 7.75/10 score). Both beds provide good spine alignment, making them solid choices for sleepers with neck or back pain.

With multiple firmness options, the WinkBed mattress caters to a variety of sizes and sleeping positions. The Purple Hybrid, on the other hand, is best suited for back, side, and combination sleepers. In those sleeping positions, the Purple Hybrid should be suitable for most shapes and sizes.

Neither bed is the best mattress for couples, due to below-average motion transfer scores (6.4/10 for WinkBed and 7/10 for Purple). However, the WinkBed has the advantage in edge support (9.75/10 vs 9/10), so you and your partner should feel more support across the entire surface.

Cooling

Of the two, the Purple Hybrid is clearly the best mattress for hot sleepers. The cooling technology really stands out in the Purple Hybrid’s 9.5/10 cooling score. The GelFlex Grid top layer found in the Purple bed promotes better temperature regulation than the gel-infused foam layers of the WinkBed (8/10 cooling score). The spaces between the gel grid promote breathability and prevent heat absorption at night.

Price

A queen-size WinkBed is $1,799 without discounts or sales, while a queen-size Purple Hybrid is $600 more at $2,399. With The WinkBed, the Plus firmness option is an additional $200.

Trial Period & Warranty

Purple:

  • 100-night trial period. Free returns.
  • 10-year warranty.

WinkBeds:

  • 120-night trial period. Free returns.
  • Lifetime warranty.

Purple Hybrid Premier 3 vs DreamCloud Premier

Firmness and Feel

Purple Hybrid Premier 3: 4.5/10 firmness

DreamCloud Premier: 6.5/10 firmness

The Purple Hybrid Premier 3 and DreamCloud Premier are luxury hybrid mattresses. Both are durable and supportive, making them great for heavier people. The Purple mattress is medium-soft on the firmness scale while the DreamCloud Premier is medium-firm.

The Purple mattress features a 3″ top layer called the Purple Grid, made with GelFlex material designed for pressure relief. (On the Purple Hybrid Premier 4, this layer is 4″ thick.) The hybrid design also includes additional foam and support coil layers. The DreamCloud has a plush pillow top supported by memory foam, polyfoam, and durable coils for a plush yet supportive feel.

Both of these beds offer solid pressure relief and spine alignment, making them excellent for sleepers with aches and pains. However, the Purple delivered superior spine alignment, and the DreamCloud better pressure relief. If you struggle with back pain, opt for the Purple. If you have pain at pressure points in the shoulders, neck, or hips, the DreamCloud might be the better choice.

The DreamCloud is better for couples thanks to its ability to reduce motion transfer. It’s also slightly more responsive, making it a good choice for restless sleepers and combination sleepers.

Cooling

The Purple Hybrid Premier 3 and DreamCloud Premier are both great for hot sleepers, thanks in part to their hybrid design. Beds with coil innerspring layers typically provided better airflow and breathability than all-foam mattresses.

Price

The regular price for a queen-size Purple Hybrid Premier 3 is $2,999, or nearly double the price of a queen-size DreamCloud Premier ($1,599). That difference makes the DreamCloud mattress a much more budget-friendly option.

Trial Period & Warranty

Purple:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

DreamCloud:

  • 365-night trial. Free returns.
  • Lifetime limited warranty.

Purple Hybrid Premier 4 vs Helix Midnight Luxe

Firmness and Feel

Purple Hybrid Premier 4: 4/10 firmness

Helix Midnight Luxe: 5/10 firmness

The Purple Hybrid Premier 4 and Helix Midnight Luxe are both hybrid mattresses ranking around the middle on our firmness scale. They use a combination of foam layers and coil systems to provide the right amount of bounce and pressure relief. Of the two, the Purple Hybrid Premier 4 is slightly softer, likely due to its pillow top and extra inch of foam. The Purple Hybrid Premier 4 ranked a 4/10 on the firmness scale while the Helix Midnight Luxe earned a medium-firmness rating of 5/10.

As hybrid mattresses, these both work well for side and back sleepers since they provide the right amount of zoned-lumbar support with their coil systems. However, the softer construction of both these mattresses makes them not suitable for stomach sleepers who may need ample support. The Helix Midnight Luxe also earned a higher score on responsiveness, making it a better choice for combination sleepers who switch positions at night.

During our lab tests, both mattresses earned near-identical scores on motion transfer, edge support, and pressure relief. This means that both options would be great for couples who sleep together and those with back or neck pain. Due to their thick coil systems, they also can support plus-sized sleepers.

Cooling

When it comes to cooling, the Helix Midnight Luxe performed a full point better than the Purple Hybrid Premier 4, earning it a 9.5/10. The Helix Midnight Luxe uses Tencel in its pillow top to provide cooling elements while the Purple Hybrid Premier 4 uses a cooling grid comfort layer and breathable innerspring coils.

Price

The Purple Hybrid Premier 4 costs almost double the price of the Helix Midnight Luxe, with a queen-size Purple Hybrid Premier 4 listed at $3,799 and a queen-size Helix Midnight Luxe listed at $2,099. The Helix is the more affordable option by far.

Trial Period & Warranty

Purple:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Helix:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 15-year limited warranty.

Kid’s Purple vs Saatva Youth

Firmness and Feel

Kid’s Purple: 5/10 firmness

Saatva Youth: 6/10 firmness

The Kid’s Purple mattress and Saatva Youth mattress are two high-quality mattresses designed with kids’ needs in mind. The Kid’s Purple mattress is similar in construction to the original Purple mattress, but with a softer feel. The Saatva Youth is a flippable innerspring mattress with a firmer, bouncier feel.

Both beds are among the best mattresses for kids available today. The Purple mattress pairs the Purple Grid with the soft support of a foam mattress. The comfort gel grid offers cushioning without the foam bed sinking feeling, delivering a floating sensation. The grid adapts to body weight and sleep position, working well for bodies that weigh less than 115 lbs.

The Saatva Youth has a flippable design, with one side formulated for kids ages 3+ and the other for those ages 8+. And with zoned support, this mattress also works well for any sleeping position.

The Kid’s Purple mattress cover is removable and washable, but it isn’t waterproof. The Saatva Youth mattress is accident-proof—a handy feature when kids are young. But we wouldn’t recommend having this be your deciding factor as you can always use a waterproof mattress protector on the Purple bed.

Cooling

Both mattresses are designed to promote temperature neutrality, but the Purple mattress performed better during testing. We give the Kid’s Purple a 9/10 cooling score, while the Saatva Youth earns an 8/10 cooling score.

Price

The Kid’s Purple mattress costs $699 for a twin size while the Saatva Youth costs $795. Saatva also comes in twin XL ($935) and full ($1,055). Although the Saatva bed costs more, keep in mind that Saatva offers free white-glove delivery that includes setting up your new mattress and removing your old one.

Trial Period & Warranty

Purple:

  • 100-night trial. Free returns.
  • 10-year limited warranty.

Saatva:

  • 365-night trial. $99 returns.
  • Lifetime warranty.

Shopping for Purple Alternatives Online

Purple sells most of its mattresses directly to the consumer. Purple and other online mattress brands skip the showroom and pass the savings onto you. Not only do online mattresses tend to cost less than their brick-and-mortar competitors, but there are other benefits, too.

  • Sleep Trials: Online mattress brands tend to offer more generous sleep trials. You may have 100 or 365 days to try out a mattress, and many brands offer free returns.
  • Warranties: Many online mattress companies back their mattresses with long warranties. Some brands offer lifetime warranties, something unheard of in the traditional mattress space.
  • Promotions: You can shop for discount codes online, ensuring that you don’t pay more than you need to. Find special Purple deals here.
  • Time: You save time shopping online since you don’t have to drive around and visit different stores.
  • Zero Pressure: In-store mattress shopping typically involves a commissioned salesperson. You don’t have to worry about high-pressure sales tactics when you’re shopping for a mattress online.

Related: Benefits of Buying a Mattress Online

Purple Mattresses vs Alternatives

Purple’s proprietary technology has brought us one of the most unique mattresses on the market today. The GelFlex Grid combines pressure relief, support, and cooling properties in a way that makes it one of the best mattresses for a wide variety of sleepers. So, why would anyone choose another mattress?

  • Cost Savings: Purple is a luxury mattress brand whose proprietary technology comes with an above-average price point. Shoppers on a budget may want to consider a less expensive mattress.
  • Sleeping Position: The Purple Grid’s body alignment properties relieve pain for many back sleepers and side sleepers, but not for stomach sleepers. The grid can cause the hips to fall out of alignment when you’re lying on your front, especially if you weigh more than average.
  • Warranty: The Purple 10-year warranty is the industry-standard, but there are other mattress companies that offer more generous warranties. Take the Nectar mattress, for example, which comes with a lifetime warranty.
  • Trial Period: Purple’s 100-night sleep trial with a full refund is the bed-in-a-box industry standard. While that’s plenty of time for most people to decide on a mattress, you may want longer to ensure that you’re getting the right mattress for you. Some companies, like Bear, offer year-long sleep trials.

Conclusion

Purple mattresses have some characteristics that make them different from competitors. The Purple Grid creates a weightless feel that’s excellent for side and back sleepers, providing excellent spine alignment and pressure relief. However, there are other great mattresses out there. If you’re a stomach sleeper or someone who prefers the “hugging” feel of memory foam, another brand may be a better choice.

Whether you go with Purple or any of the brands listed above, they all come with generous trial periods that allow you to try your new mattress in the comfort of your home.

Purple Mattress Alternative FAQs

The Casper Original is an excellent alternative to the Purple mattress, although no mattress feels the same as a Purple bed thanks to Purple’s proprietary hyper-elastic polymer grid. While these mattresses incorporate different materials, they offer similar sleeping experiences in many ways. For instance, both beds are medium-firm, received high scores for pressure relief and spine alignment in our Sleep Lab, and have similar price points.

The Purple is better when it comes to cooling, as its grid allows air to flow more freely than Casper’s memory foam. On the other hand, Casper scored better in responsiveness and motion transfer, so it’s good for combination sleepers and couples. Casper also supports stomach sleeping, which is not Purple’s strong suit.

If you’re looking for a bed that offers similar benefits to the Purple Hybrid, we recommend the WinkBed. The WinkBed comes in multiple firmness options, with the firmest model having a comparable firmness as the Purple Hybrid. Both beds are hybrid mattresses with innerspring coils that provide a durable and cool sleeping experience. Purple’s GelFlex Grid and the WinkBed’s foam top layer offer excellent pressure relief and spinal support.

Both of these mattresses are great for side and back sleepers, but we do not recommend the Purple Hybrid for stomach sleepers. The polymer grid top layer creates too much sinkage at the hips of stomach sleepers.