updated June 2023

Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison

Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison

Wondering whether to buy the Saatva Classic mattress or the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid? Read our guide to see which mattress has the features most important to you—and which is best suited to your type of sleeping.

 

By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

The Saatva Classic and Brooklyn Signature are two of the leading hybrid mattresses on the market. We’ve tested both in our Mattress Advisor lab and can compare them head-to-head. Here we explain which types of sleepers are best suited to each.


Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding at a Glance

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty
Saatva Classic Mattress

Saatva Classic

Customer Rating
MA Score

9/10

Summary

Customizable luxury hybrid mattress

Firmness

Customizable

Type

Hybrid: coil on coil and memory foam with Euro pillow-top

Trial Period

365 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

brooklyn signature mattress

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Customer Rating
MA Score

8.8/10

Summary

Responsive hybrid mattress

Firmness

Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm

Type

Hybrid: memory foam and pocket coils

Trial Period

120 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

Saatva Classic Mattress
brooklyn signature mattress

Saatva Classic

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Customer Rating

MA Score

9/10

8.8/10

Summary

Customizable luxury hybrid mattress

Responsive hybrid mattress

Firmness

Customizable

Choose your preference: Available in soft, medium or firm

Type

Hybrid: coil on coil and memory foam with Euro pillow-top

Hybrid: memory foam and pocket coils

Trial Period

365 days

120 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

10-year limited warranty

Key Similarities

  • Firmness options: Both mattresses are available in three firmness levels. The Saatva Classic is available in plush soft (3/10 for firmness), luxury firm (6/10), and firm (8/10). The Brooklyn Signature’s options are plush (4/10), medium (6/10), and firm (8/10).
  • Cooling: As hybrid mattresses constructed with breathable innerspring coils, the Saatva Classic and Brooklyn Signature provide a cool night’s sleep.
  • Construction: These beds both consist of an innerspring base topped with memory foam, though the Saatva also boasts a 3” Euro pillow top.

Key Differences

  • Feel: The Brooklyn Bedding Signature has a slight hugging memory foam feel compared to the Saatva’s luxury pillow top softness, which doesn’t provide the same cradling sensation.  
  • Delivery: Saatva provides white-glove delivery, which means the company will fully set up your mattress for you; Brooklyn Bedding ships its bed to you in a box.
  • Eco-conscious construction: Only Saatva uses organic and recycled materials in its construction, making it a better choice for eco- and health-conscious consumers.
Another Saatva Classic Pic

Saatva Mattress Review Highlights

  • Good for Back Pain: The Saatva offers exceptional spine alignment and pressure relief, making it a great mattress for back-pain sufferers.
  • Great for Seniors: The Saatva’s higher-than-average, 14.5-inch profile and sturdy edges make it easier for seniors to get into and out of bed. 
  • Luxury Experience: From white-glove delivery to a cushy pillow top, Saatva provides a luxury experience from top to bottom.
  • Eco-friendly Materials: You can sleep soundly knowing that Saatva uses organic cotton, foams that are certified to have low gas emissions, and recycled steel.
  • Other Options: Saatva offers several hybrid, memory foam, and latex beds, including the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid and its smart bed, the Saatva Solaire.
brooklyn signature mattress 1 e1511217599432

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Review Highlights

  • Pressure Relief: The Brooklyn Signature earned a near-perfect score in pressure relief, which means it contours to pressure points such as hips and shoulders. This is particularly important for side sleepers.
  • Suits All Sleepers: Because of the three available firmness levels, the Brooklyn Signature suits all sleep styles. Side and combination sleepers may prefer a soft or medium mattress, while back and stomach sleepers may enjoy the support of a medium or firm model. 
  • Edge Support: Extra-strong coils line the perimeter of this mattress, earning it a 9/10 score in edge support. This is useful for couples, seniors, and people who regularly sit on the edge of the bed.
  • Incredible Value: Brooklyn Bedding is in charge of every stage of manufacturing and sales. This results in cost savings and a more affordable hybrid bed.
  • Other Options: You have many more mattress options to choose from at Brooklyn Bedding, including the Aurora Luxe Cooling, Sedona Elite, and the Titan Plus Luxe for plus-size sleepers.

 


Compare Dimensions/Sizes

Take a look at the chart below to see the dimensions of each mattress and how models from each brand compare:

Saatva Brooklyn 
Thickness 11.5” or 14.5” 11.5″
Twin 38” x 75” 38″ x 75″
Twin XL 38” x 80” 38″ x 80″
Full 54” x 75” 53″ x 75″
Queen 60” x 80” 60″ x 80″
King 76” x 80” 76″ x 80″
Split King 38″ x 80″ (X2) N/A
Cal King 72” x 84” 72″ x 84″
Split California King 36″ x 84″ (X2) 36″ x 84″ (X2)
RV King N/A 70” x 74” 70” x 80” 72” x 80”

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Compare Prices

One of the most notable differences between Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding is the cost of their mattresses, with the price difference reaching nearly $600 for a king.

Saatva is a luxury brand and provides perks such as white-glove delivery, a lifetime warranty, and a 365-night sleep trial (compared to Brooklyn Bedding’s 120 nights). On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding offers incredible value at a low price point because the company manufactures its products from start to finish.

Saatva  Brooklyn 
Twin $1,095 $699
Twin XL $1,395 $832
Full $1,895 $932
Queen $1,995 $1,332
King $2,495 $1,599
Split King $2,790 N/A
California King $2,495 $1,599
Split California King $2,790 $1,664
RV King N/A $1,599

Compare the Construction

What exactly makes these two hybrid mattresses distinct from one another? Let’s look inside each bed, layer by layer, to get some insight.

Inside Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid

Inside the Saatva Classic Mattress:

The Saatva Classic contains five layers that work together to provide a supportive yet comfortable sleep experience. 

 

The 3” organic cotton pillow top adds a luxury cushioned feel. The type of foam used in this layer differentiates the plush, luxury firm, and firm options. Softer foam gives you the feeling of being cradled and sinking into the mattress, while more dense foam makes you feel like you’re sleeping “on” the bed instead of “in” it. The quilted cover gives you more lumbar support beneath your back and hips.

 

Next comes the Saatva’s back-support layer, with high-density memory foam and additional reinforcement with supportive wire along the middle third of the bed. This layer works alongside the zoned coil system below, creating targeted support through the midsection but a cradling feel along the shoulders. 

 

Saatva is one of the only mattresses with a dual-coil design. Underneath the zoned coils is a sturdy base of recycled steel coils. The coil-on-coil construction creates a bouncy feel, which is great for nighttime resituating and adult activities. This design also allows for generous airflow and a cool night’s sleep.  

 

  1. Quilted Euro Pillow Top: A 3” cushiony pillow top provides pressure relief for side sleepers, while lumbar quilting offers extra support. The organic cotton cover is breathable and promotes cooler sleep.
  2. Memory Foam: CertiPUR-US Certified high-density memory foam cradles and supports the middle third of the body. This layer also includes Saatva’s Lumbar Zone Active Spinal Wire, which provides extra support where you need it most.
  3. Pocketed Coils: The Saatva’s first coil layer has sturdier coils along the center third of the bed, delivering outstanding lumbar support. Its pocketed recycled steel coils balance responsiveness and support.
  4. Dense Edge Support: High-density foam rails line the edges of the mattress to minimize sagging.   
  5. Steel Coil Base: A bottom layer of coils allows for increased airflow, sturdier support, and a springier and more responsive feel.
inside brooklyn signature

Inside the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress combines three layers of foam, individually pocketed coils, and a breathable cover to provide an excellent mattress for all types of sleepers. You can purchase a cooling cover for a small additional fee.

 

Beneath the quilted cover is the first layer of memory foam. This hyper-elastic comfort foam measures 1” in firm beds and 1.5” in soft and medium beds. The foam used in this layer gives you the cradling feeling typical of memory foam, while still being responsive. It’s also infused with cooling gel, making it a good choice for hot sleepers.

 

Next is a high-density polyurethane foam layer, which provides additional support. This layer is 2” in firm beds and 1” in soft and medium beds. This is followed by a thick layer of pocketed coils that give the springy, responsive qualities of an innerspring bed. 

 

A high-density base layer adds extra support beneath the coil layer. This sturdy construction makes the Brooklyn Bedding a good bed for heavier sleepers.

 

  1. Quilted Cover (0.5”): A premium quilted cover that’s soft and breathable. You can opt for an even cooler cover for an additional charge.
  2. Comfort Foam (1-1.5”): Responsive memory foam infused with cooling gel offers pressure relief and regulates sleep temperature.
  3. Transition Foam (1-2”): High-density polyfoam provides deep compression support. 
  4. Pocketed Coils (6”): Individually pocketed coils improve responsiveness and deliver extra support for various body types.
  5. Support Foam (.25”): A dense layer of base foam provides support for the coils above and improves durability.

Compare the Scores

Every mattress we review and compare goes through our in-house mattress testing. Read about how the Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding each performed in our mattress testing below.

Saatva Brooklyn Bedding
Shipping 7.5 8
Trial Period 10 9
Return Policy 7 9
Warranty 10 9
Set-Up Test 10 8
Motion Transfer Test 7.5 7.25
Edge Support Test 10 9
Pressure Relief Test 9 9.5
Spine Alignment Test 10 8.5
Responsiveness Test 8.5 8.25
Cooling Evaluation 9 8.5
Durability Evaluation 10 8.5
Customer Service Score 9 9
Social Impact Score 8 9
TOTAL SCORE 9/10 8.8/10

Spine Alignment

Saatva is the better fit for back pain sufferers, as it earned a perfect score of 10/10 in this category. This comes as no surprise, given the level of care Saatva puts into lumbar support in this mattress.

Pressure Relief

Pressure relief is important for side and combination sleepers, as well as anyone with arthritis. Both mattresses offer exceptional pressure relief, though Brooklyn Bedding earned a slightly higher score thanks to the cushioning of its memory foam top layer.

Be sure to consider the firmness level if you want the best pressure relief, particularly if you’re a side sleeper. Lighter-weight side sleepers may enjoy the soft in Brooklyn Bedding and plush in Saatva, while average-weight side sleepers and combination sleepers should consider Brooklyn Bedding’s medium and Saatva’s luxury firm.

Edge Support

You can’t go wrong with either the Saatva or Brooklyn Bedding when it comes to edge support. Both beds are specifically constructed to provide superior support for getting out of bed or sitting along the edge. The Saatva scored a perfect 10/10 in this category–just one of the reasons it’s our top choice for seniors.


Which Is the Best Mattress for You?

Given the many similarities between the Saatva Classic and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid—including multiple firmness options and a hybrid design—many sleepers would be happy with either mattress. However, there are differences that may make one of these beds a better fit. 

We recommend the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid over the Saatva Classic for shoppers on a budget and people who like the hugging feel of memory foam. But if you have back pain or want a more classic luxury pillow top feel, the Saatva Classic is the better pick. 

Both mattresses are excellent options for hot sleepers, people who toss and turn at night, and sleepers of every body size and sleeping position. Each offers a risk-free sleep trial and free shipping—but as a luxury mattress brand, you can expect a higher-end experience with Saatva. This includes free mattress setup and a full year-long trial period, compared to a 120-night trial with Brooklyn Bedding. 

More Saatva Comparisons

More Brooklyn Bedding Comparisons