updated May 2022

Saatva vs Puffy Mattress Comparison

Saatva vs Puffy Mattress Comparison

Want to know how the Saatva and Puffy mattresses compare? In this article, we’ll take a closer look at which type of sleeper each bed is best for to help you decide.

Saatva and Puffy are two high-end online mattress companies that deliver mattresses right to your door, and in Saatva’s case, your bedroom. Their flagship mattresses both offer medium-firm options but vary in their type of construction; Saatva is a hybrid and Puffy is an all-foam.

Keep reading to find out how the Saatva Classic and Puffy Mattress differ in their prices, testing scores, and customer experience.


Saatva vs Puffy at a Glance

Customer Rating
MA Score
Summary
Firmness
Type
Trial Period
Warranty
saatva mattress new e1586527946280

Saatva Classic

Customer Rating
MA Score

9/10

Summary

Customizable luxury hybrid mattress

Firmness

Customizable

Type

Hybrid: coil on coil and memory foam with Euro pillow-top

Trial Period

365 days

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Puffy resp e1585244784424

Puffy Mattress

Customer Rating
MA Score

9/10

Summary

Memory foam mattress that is great for side sleepers

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Type

Memory Foam

Trial Period

101 nights

Warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

saatva mattress new e1586527946280
Puffy resp e1585244784424

Saatva Classic

Puffy Mattress

Customer Rating

MA Score

9/10

9/10

Summary

Customizable luxury hybrid mattress

Memory foam mattress that is great for side sleepers

Firmness

Customizable

Medium-firm: 7/10

Type

Hybrid: coil on coil and memory foam with Euro pillow-top

Memory Foam

Trial Period

365 days

101 nights

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

Key Similarities

  • The Saatva Classic and Puffy are both highly rated on our best mattresses for side sleepers list.
  • Both mattresses offer medium-firm comfort levels, appealing to a majority of sleep positions.
  • The Saatva Classic and Puffy Mattress are great options for those with lower back pain thanks to their high scores in spinal alignment.
  • Both are American-made, which means they have a minimal environmental impact and can ensure high quality.

Related: Benefits of Buying a Mattress Made in the U.S.

Key Differences

  • Puffy scored almost two full points higher than the Saatva Classic in our motion isolation test, making it the better option for couples who sleep together.
  • While both Puffy and Saatva provide customers with generous lifetime warranties, Saatva’s sleep trial is significantly longer. It lasts a full year, and Puffy’s is 101 days.
  • The Saatva Classic comes with a free white glove delivery service so you don’t have to worry about setting up your mattress or removing your old one.
saatva mattress new e1586527946280

Saatva Mattress Review Highlights

  • Scoring a perfect 10/10 in our edge support test, the Saatva Classic is an excellent mattress for those who like to get ready at the end of their bed or take advantage of every inch of their mattress.
  • The Saatva Classic comes in three different comfort options: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. That makes it great for a variety of sleep positions.
  • Its dual-coil design makes this a long-lasting mattress that you can count on having for a very long time.
  • Saatva offers seven other mattress options, including their all-natural latex bed, the Zenhaven, and their luxury hybrid for larger bodies, the Saatva HD.
Puffy Original

Puffy Mattress Review Highlights

  • As an all-foam mattress, the Puffy is extremely responsive, making it easy to change positions throughout the night.
  • The Puffy mattress comes with a stain-resistant cover so you don’t have to worry about damaging your mattress and can make sure it stays as clean as when you first got it.
  • Puffy offers free shipping to the contiguous U.S. and can arrive at your doorstep in as little as two days!
  • Puffy also sells two hybrid mattresses, the Puffy Lux Hybrid and Puffy Royal Hybrid.

Compare Mattress Sizes

The Saatva Classic comes in two height options, both of which are taller than the Puffy Mattress. As far as dimensions go, both mattresses are very similar, with the exception of Puffy not offering split size options.

Saatva Classic
Puffy Mattress
Thickness 11.5″ or 14.5″ 10″
Twin 38″ x 75″ 38″ x 75″
Twin XL 38″ x 80″ 38″ x 80″
Full 54″ x 75″ 54″ x 75″
Queen 60″ x 80″ 60″ x 80″
King 76″ x 80″ 76″ x 80″
Split King 76″ x 80″ N/A
Cal King 72″ x 84″ 72″ x 84″
Split Cal King 72″ x 84″ N/A

Learn more about mattress sizes.


Compare Mattress Prices

Saatva and Puffy mattresses have similar prices, with the Puffy costing slightly more for smaller sizes and the Saatva Classic costing more for larger sizes.

Saatva Classic
Puffy Mattress
Twin $887 $1,449
Twin XL $1,148 $1,499
Full $1,595 $1,649
Queen $1,695 $1,799
King $2,095 $1,999
Split King $2,296 N/A
Cal King $2,095 $1,999
Split Cal King $2,296 N/A

Compare Mattress Structure

When it comes to construction, these two mattresses are nowhere near the same. The Saatva Classic is a hybrid mattress, consisting of foam layers and an innerspring system, while the Puffy is an all-foam mattress.

Saatva’s Classic mattress consists of five premium foam and coil layers to provide optimal comfort and support. As a luxury mattress, it has a hotel-style feel that will leave you feeling like every day is a vacation. This starts with the Saatva’s European-style plush pillow top which will give a cushiony feel. The Saatva Classic also comes with three different firmness options and two heights so you can take full control of how your bed feels. If you prefer a soft feel, select the plush soft comfort level. Those wanting more support can go with the firm level and people in between comfort preferences can settle on the luxury firm, which has a medium-firm feel.

At a slightly shorter stature, the Puffy Mattress is made up of three foam layers, two of which are a proprietary blend. It comes at a medium-firm firmness level, making it great for all sleeping positions. Unlike most memory foam mattresses, you won’t feel trapped on this bed. In fact, it scored a 9/10 in our responsiveness evaluation making it a great option for those that switch positions at night.

Those preferring a firm, supportive mattress will love the Saatva Classic’s firm and luxury-firm options. If you want a softer mattress, go with the Saatva Classic’s plush soft option. However, those who already own a memory foam mattress may prefer the Puffy Mattress since it has a traditional memory foam feel and doesn’t require getting used to any new materials.

Take a closer look at the layers making up the Saatva Classic and Puffy Mattress below.

Inside Saatva Classic

Inside the Saatva Mattress

  1. Quilted Euro Pillow-Top: The top layer consists of a 3″ Euro pillow-top with Lumbar Zone® Quilting to provide cushioning. It’s designed to offer maximum comfort and coziness.
  2. Back Support Layer: A combination of Saatva’s Lumbar Zone® Active Spinal Wire and high-density memory foam provides pressure relief and lower-back support.
  3. Responsive Coils: Saatva uses recycled, pocketed steel coils that react to your body’s movement for better contouring. This makes the mattress stronger in the center third to support your body fully.
  4. Edge Support Layer: High-density foam rails stabilize the mattress edges, extend the sleep surface, and make it easier to get in and out of bed.
  5. Base Coil Unit: Dual-coils of tempered steel provide durability and airflow and reduce sagging over time and allow a better airflow while you sleep.
inside puffy

Inside the Puffy Mattress

  1. Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover: The Puffy Mattress comes wrapped in a hypoallergenic cover that helps keep your mattress super clean.
  2. Cooling Cloud™ Gel-Infused Memory Foam: This top layer of cooling gel foam is designed to disperse heat away from your body and promote airflow for a cooler surface than some other memory foam mattresses.
  3. Climate Comfort™ Memory Foam: This memory foam layer was recently added. Unlike most foams that expand and contract depending on the temperature, this foam doesn’t. When it’s hot, foam tends to expand. When it’s cold, it can contract. This variability in the foam can impact its pressure-relieving abilities; however, the Climate Comfort™ layer by Puffy is resistant to these changes in temperature, providing the same comfort all year long.
  4. Firm Core Support Base Layer: The polyfoam support layer of the Puffy mattress provides structure and durability to the entire bed.

Compare Mattress Advisor Scores

See how the Saatva Classic and the Puffy Mattress scored in our in-lab testing across various categories.

Saatva Classic Puffy Mattress
Shipping 7.5 9
Trial Period 10 10
Return Policy 7 10
Warranty 10 10
Set Up 10 9.5
Motion Transfer 7.5 9.25
Edge Support 10 8.75
Pressure Relief 9 8
Spinal Alignment 10 8.75
Responsiveness 8.5 9
Cooling 9 8
Durability 10 8
Customer Service  9 9
Social Impact 8 7
TOTAL SCORE 9/10 8.9/10

Check out some factors that set these two mattresses apart.

Spinal Alignment

Having a mattress that keeps your spine in a neutral position is important so you can wake up free of aches and pains. The Saatva Classic knocked this out of the park, earning a perfect 10/10 score, with the Puffy Mattress not too far behind. Saatva does a good job of providing lumbar support so you don’t have to worry about slouching in your sleep. Having high scores in spinal alignment makes both mattresses an ideal option for back sleepers who especially need spinal alignment. It also makes it a solid choice for those with back pain.

Edge Support

Another area where the Saatva Classic outperformed the Puffy Mattress was in our edge support. This looks at how well a mattress holds our testers when they sit and lay on the edge. During our evaluation, our testers noticed minimal dipping and they felt fully supported. The Saatva Classic is an excellent choice for those that use their bed to get ready in the morning or need help getting in bed.

Responsiveness

Responsiveness is how easy it is to move around on a mattress. This is especially important for combination sleepers who change positions at night. The Puffy Mattress did exceptional in this category, earning a near-perfect 9/10 score. Our testers also found it easy to switch positions on the Saatva Classic, so either option would be pretty responsive.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer tests how effective a mattress is at isolating motion. Couples who sleep together especially need this so they don’t disturb each other when getting up to use the bathroom. Memory foam mattresses are known to excel in this area and the Puffy Mattress was right on point, earning a 9.25/10. Because of its innerspring system, the Saatva Classic didn’t do a very good job of isolating motion.


Which Is the Best Mattress for You?

With near-identical Mattress Advisor scores, both of these mattresses would be great choices. However, since they have different construction, they may appeal to different types of people. Ultimately, the best mattress matches your sleep position, sleep environment, budget, and ideal customer experience.

Sleeping Position

As you pick which mattress works best for you, consider your sleep position and whether the mattress offers the right pressure relief and firmness for your style. Since the Saatva Classic comes in three different firmness options and two different heights, it works with all sleeping positions.

The Puffy is a solid choice for side, back, and combination sleepers. However, if you like to sleep on your stomach, the Saatva Classic may be a better choice since the Puffy doesn’t lift your hips up properly.

Sleep Environment

If you tend to sleep hot, you know how important it is to find a mattress that promotes breathability. Both mattresses scored pretty high in our cooling evaluation, but the Saatva Classic earned a full point more thanks to its innerspring construction. Memory foam mattresses typically sleep hotter than hybrids, however the Puffy uses a Climate Comfort™ foam for better temperature regulation.

Those that sleep with a partner, child, or pet will want a mattress with great motion isolation. This is one area where the Puffy Mattress beat the Saatva Classic, thanks to its layers of foam. The Saatva Classic’s innersprings make it difficult to isolate motion as well.

Budget

Both the Saatva Classic and Puffy Mattress come with similar price tags. If you are searching for a smaller size, the Saatva is the more affordable option but as the sizes go up, Puffy is the more affordable option. Saatva offers financing options through Affirm and Puffy offers it through Klarna.

Customer Service

When purchasing a mattress, you may want to consider what the buying experience is like with each company. Since Saatva and Puffy are both bed-in-box online companies, they offer sleep trials with their mattresses to give customers a chance to try them out. Puffy’s sleep trial is 101 days, whereas Saatva offers an extra 264 days.

These companies also offer generous warranties so you know you are protected for the duration of owning your mattress. Both Puffy and Saatva provide a lifetime warranty. Since it’s recommended to upgrade your mattress every 6-10 years, you’re covered for more than enough time with both these companies. Plus, Saatva offers free white-glove delivery so you don’t have to worry about setting up your new mattress or removing your old one from your residence.

Other Saatva and Puffy Comparisons

Cariloha

Still Deciding?

If you still need to narrow down your options, check out our mattress comparison tool.